AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 6 lecture · Part 8 of 11 · 10 min

6.5 Rolling without slippingSpinning and moving at once

Mr. Thompkins
Let's have a race. A hoop, a solid disk and a solid ball are released together at the top of the same ramp. Make your prediction now. Here's a hint that surprises most people: the winner doesn't depend on which one is heaviest or biggest.

Rolling without slipping means the point of the object touching the ground doesn't slide. Think of a tire leaving a perfect print, with no skid marks. In one full turn, the tire lays its whole circumference on the road, so the center moves forward $2\pi R$. More generally, when it turns through an angle $\theta$, the center moves $x = R\theta$. Differentiate: $v_{cm} = R\omega$, and again: $a_{cm} = R\alpha$. That is the rolling condition.

?Wait, why is arc length $R heta$?
A radian is defined so that an angle of θ radians cuts off an arc of length $R\theta$ on a circle of radius R. One full turn is $2\pi$ radians, so it cuts off $2\pi R$, the circumference. This is why all rotational formulas need radians.

Here's the clever way to see rolling. Every point on a rolling wheel has two motions added together: the whole wheel translating forward at $v_{cm}$, plus spinning around the center with rim speed $R\omega = v_{cm}$. At the top, the two add: $2v_{cm}$. At the center, only the translation: $v_{cm}$. At the bottom, they cancel: zero. The contact point is momentarily at rest.

translationevery point: vrotationrim: ωR = vrollingtop 2v, bottom 0+=2vvcontact point is at rest for an instant
Rolling is translation plus rotation. At the top the two velocities add to 2v. At the contact point they cancel, so the point touching the ground is at rest for that instant.
Pause and think
A bicycle rolls without slipping at 6.0 m/s. How fast is a speck of mud on the top of the tire moving, relative to the ground? A speck touching the road?
I thought about it. Show me
The top speck moves at 12 m/s, twice the bike's speed. The speck touching the road is at rest for an instant. That's why the top of a rolling tire looks blurry in photos while the bottom looks sharp.

Now the energy. A rolling object has both kinds of kinetic energy: $K = \tfrac12 Mv_{cm}^2 + \tfrac12 I_{cm}\omega^2$. Write $I_{cm} = \beta MR^2$, where β is a pure number set by the shape (1 for a hoop, 1/2 for a disk, 2/5 for a solid sphere). With $\omega = \frac{v_{cm}}{R}$: $K = \tfrac12 Mv_{cm}^2 + \tfrac12\beta MR^2\frac{v_{cm}^2}{R^2} = \tfrac12 Mv_{cm}^2(1 + \beta)$.

?Wait, why doesn't friction take energy away from a rolling object?
Work needs the point where the force acts to move. Static friction acts at the contact point, and for rolling without slipping that point is at rest at every instant. No displacement, no work. Friction still matters (it is what makes the object spin), but it only shifts energy between translation and rotation. The total mechanical energy is conserved.

Roll from rest down a height h: $Mgh = \tfrac12 Mv^2(1 + \beta)$, so $v = \sqrt{\frac{2gh}{1 + \beta}}$. Mass cancels and radius cancels. Only the shape factor β is left. The smaller β is, the less energy gets tied up in spinning, and the faster the object goes. So the race order is fixed: solid sphere, then solid disk, then hollow shell, then hoop.

Shapeβ = I/(MR²)v at bottom, h = 1.0 mShare of K in spin
Hoop or thin pipe13.13 m/s50%
Thin spherical shell2/33.43 m/s40%
Solid disk or cylinder1/23.61 m/s33%
Solid sphere2/53.74 m/s29%
Block sliding, no friction04.43 m/s0%
Speed at the bottom of a 1.0 m drop for each shape, rolling without slipping from rest. A frictionless sliding block is included for comparison.
hoop (J)4.9K trans4.9K rotdisk (J)6.5K trans3.3K rotsphere (J)7K trans2.8K rot
Where 9.8 J goes when a 1.0 kg object rolls down a 1.0 m drop. A hoop puts half its energy into spinning; a solid sphere only 2/7 of it.
Rolling up a hill
A solid cylinder rolls without slipping across level ground at 3.0 m/s, then rolls up a ramp. (a) How high does its center rise before it stops? (b) A block sliding at 3.0 m/s up a frictionless ramp rises how high, for comparison?
  1. (a) Energy is conserved: static friction does no work. At the bottom: $K = \tfrac12 Mv^2(1 + \beta)$ with $\beta = \tfrac12$. At the top: $Mgh$.
    Why?
    State why energy is conserved here: rolling without slipping, so friction does no work.
  2. $h = \frac{(1 + \beta)v^2}{2g} = \frac{(1.5)(3.0)^2}{2(9.8)} = 0.689\ \text{m}$.
  3. (b) The block has only translational energy: $h = \frac{v^2}{2g} = \frac{9.0}{19.6} = 0.459\ \text{m}$.
    Why?
    The cylinder goes higher at the same speed because it carries extra energy in its spin, and friction from the ramp converts that spin energy into height as it slows the rotation.

Answer: (a) About 0.69 m. (b) About 0.46 m.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Write the cylinder's total K with both terms, using $\omega = v/R$.
  2. For a solid cylinder, $K = \tfrac34 Mv^2$.
  3. Set $\tfrac34 Mv^2 = Mgh$ and solve for h.
Pause and think
Now the same cylinder at 3.0 m/s, still spinning, reaches a ramp made of perfectly frictionless ice. How high does it go?
I thought about it. Show me
Only 0.459 m, like the sliding block. With no friction there is no torque about its center, so its spin can't change: it keeps spinning at the same ω all the way up. Only the translational energy, $\tfrac12 Mv^2$, turns into height. It slides back down still spinning. Friction is what lets the spin energy help.
Check yourself
A 5.0 kg solid sphere of radius 0.10 m and a 1.0 kg solid sphere of radius 0.20 m are released from rest at the top of the same ramp and roll without slipping. Which reaches the bottom first?
  1. AThe 5.0 kg sphere, because it is heavier
  2. BThe 1.0 kg sphere, because it is larger
  3. CThey tie
  4. DThe 1.0 kg sphere, because it is lighter
Show the answer

C. $v = \sqrt{\frac{2gh}{1 + \beta}}$ and both have $\beta = \frac25$. Mass and radius cancel, so at every height they have the same speed and they tie. The top trap is the first choice: "heavier is faster" is a myth for rolling and for falling.

  • Rolling without slipping: $v_{cm} = R\omega$ and $a_{cm} = R\alpha$. The contact point is at rest; the top moves at $2v_{cm}$.
  • $K = \tfrac12 Mv_{cm}^2 + \tfrac12 I_{cm}\omega^2 = \tfrac12 Mv_{cm}^2(1 + \beta)$, with $\beta = \frac{I_{cm}}{MR^2}$.
  • From rest down a height h: $v = \sqrt{\frac{2gh}{1 + \beta}}$. Only shape matters. Sphere beats disk beats shell beats hoop.
  • Static friction does no work in rolling without slipping, so mechanical energy is conserved.