AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 6 lecture · Part 7 of 11 · 9 min

6.4 Collisions with rotating objectsWhen a lump of putty hits a rod

Mr. Thompkins
A ball sticks to a pivoted rod. Students reach for linear momentum and get it wrong, or reach for energy and get it wrong. There's exactly one quantity that survives this collision, and choosing the right axis makes it work.

During a collision, the forces between the objects are huge and brief. For a ball hitting a rod that hangs from a pivot, the pivot pushes on the rod during the impact. That push is an external force on the ball and rod system, so linear momentum is not conserved. But the pivot force acts at the pivot, so its lever arm about the pivot is zero, and its torque about the pivot is zero. Gravity acts too, but the collision lasts so short a time that gravity's angular impulse is negligible (and with the rod hanging straight down, gravity's torque about the pivot is zero anyway). So angular momentum about the pivot is conserved through the collision.

?Wait, how do I find the angular momentum of the incoming ball?
Treat it as a particle: $L = mvd$, where d is the perpendicular distance from the pivot to the ball's line of motion (section 4). A ball moving horizontally that hits the rod a distance $\ell$ below the pivot has $L = mv\ell$.
v = 6.0 m/sputty 0.10 kgpivotrod 0.90 kgL = 1.2 mswings to 21.5°
A 0.10 kg ball of putty moving at 6.0 m/s hits the bottom end of a 0.90 kg, 1.2 m rod hanging from a frictionless pivot, and sticks. The dashed line is the highest point of the swing that follows.

Afterward, the problem usually has a second stage: the rod and ball swing up. In that stage the collision is over, the pivot is frictionless, and gravity is the only force doing work, so mechanical energy is conserved. Two stages, two laws. Mixing them up is the trap.

Two stages: collision, then swing
For the setup in the figure: (a) find the angular speed of the rod and putty just after the collision; (b) find the fraction of kinetic energy lost in the collision; (c) find the maximum angle the rod swings to; (d) state whether the linear momentum of the putty and rod system is conserved during the collision, and explain.
  1. (a) Stage 1, the collision. The pivot exerts no torque about itself, so L about the pivot is conserved: $mv\ell = \left(\frac{ML^2}{3} + m\ell^2\right)\omega$, with $\ell = L = 1.2$ m.
    Why?
    Write the law in symbols first. Graders look for the right conservation law with the right rotational inertia after the collision.
  2. $I_f = \frac{(0.90)(1.2)^2}{3} + (0.10)(1.2)^2 = 0.432 + 0.144 = 0.576\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2$, and $L = (0.10)(6.0)(1.2) = 0.72\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{s}$. So $\omega = \frac{0.72}{0.576} = 1.25\ \text{rad/s}$.
    Why?
    Don't forget the putty's own rotational inertia after it sticks. Leaving it out is one of the listed traps for this unit.
  3. (b) $K_i = \tfrac12(0.10)(6.0)^2 = 1.80\ \text{J}$ and $K_f = \tfrac12(0.576)(1.25)^2 = 0.45\ \text{J}$. Lost: $\frac{1.80 - 0.45}{1.80} = 0.75$, so 75%.
    Why?
    Sticky collisions lose kinetic energy to deformation and heat. That is exactly why energy conservation can't be used in stage 1.
  4. (c) Stage 2, the swing. Energy is conserved: $\tfrac12 I_f\omega^2 = \left(Mg\frac{L}{2} + mgL\right)(1 - \cos\theta)$. The right side is $(0.90)(9.8)(0.60) + (0.10)(9.8)(1.2) = 6.47\ \text{J}$ times $(1 - \cos\theta)$.
    Why?
    Each center of mass rises by its distance from the pivot times $(1 - \cos\theta)$: the rod's by $\frac{L}{2}(1 - \cos\theta)$, the putty's by $L(1 - \cos\theta)$.
  5. $1 - \cos\theta = \frac{0.45}{6.47} = 0.0696$, so $\cos\theta = 0.930$ and $\theta = 21.5°$.
  6. (d) No. Just before, $p = (0.10)(6.0) = 0.60\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}$. Just after, $p = M\frac{L}{2}\omega + mL\omega = (0.90)(0.60)(1.25) + (0.10)(1.2)(1.25) = 0.825\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}$. The pivot exerted an external force on the rod during the impact, so linear momentum changed.
    Why?
    A claim plus evidence plus reasoning: the numbers show it, and the reason is the external force from the pivot.

Answer: (a) 1.25 rad/s. (b) 75%. (c) About 21°. (d) No: the pivot pushes on the rod during the collision, so momentum goes from 0.60 to 0.825 kg·m/s.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Stage 1 is the collision: which quantity does the pivot not disturb?
  2. After sticking, $I = \frac{ML^2}{3} + mL^2$. Set $mvL = I\omega$.
  3. Stage 2 is the swing: set $\tfrac12 I\omega^2$ equal to the rise in potential energy of both centers of mass.
Pause and think
Suppose the putty were replaced by a rubber ball with the same mass and speed that bounced straight back. Would the rod swing higher or lower than before?
I thought about it. Show me
Higher. Angular momentum about the pivot is still conserved. The ball starts with $+mvL$ and leaves with a negative angular momentum, so the rod must end up with more than $mvL$. A bouncing ball hands over more angular momentum than one that sticks, just as in Unit 4 a bouncing ball gives a bigger impulse than one that stops.

The same law handles purely rotational collisions. Drop a disk onto a spinning turntable so they lock together, and the friction between them is internal: $I_1\omega_1 + I_2\omega_2 = (I_1 + I_2)\omega_f$. That is the rotational version of a perfectly inelastic collision, and as in Unit 4, kinetic energy is lost.

?Wait, what is a perfectly inelastic collision?
From Unit 4: the objects stick together and move with one common velocity afterward. Momentum is conserved (if there is no external force), but kinetic energy is not. It is the collision that loses the most kinetic energy allowed by momentum conservation.
Check yourself
A uniform disk spins at 30 rad/s about a vertical axle. An identical disk, not spinning, is dropped onto it, centered on the same axle, and they quickly turn together. Which statement is correct?
  1. AThey turn at 30 rad/s, and no kinetic energy is lost.
  2. BThey turn at 15 rad/s, and half of the kinetic energy is lost.
  3. CThey turn at $30/\sqrt2 \approx 21$ rad/s, and no kinetic energy is lost.
  4. DThey turn at 15 rad/s, and three quarters of the kinetic energy is lost.
Show the answer

B. L is conserved: $I(30) = 2I\omega_f$, so $\omega_f = 15$ rad/s. Then $K_f = \tfrac12(2I)(15)^2 = 225I$ against $K_i = \tfrac12 I(30)^2 = 450I$: half is lost. The $\sqrt2$ trap comes from conserving energy, which friction between the disks does not allow.

  • Collisions with a pivoted object: conserve L about the pivot. The pivot force has no torque about the pivot, but it does change linear momentum.
  • After sticking, add the stuck object's rotational inertia (m times distance squared).
  • Collision stage: angular momentum. Swing stage afterward: energy. Two stages, two laws.
  • Objects that lock together while spinning: $I_1\omega_1 + I_2\omega_2 = (I_1 + I_2)\omega_f$, and kinetic energy is lost.