AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 6 lecture · Part 9 of 11 · 10 min

6.5 Rolling with forces, and slippingWhy it rolls, and what happens when it skids

Mr. Thompkins
Energy told us how fast a rolling object goes. It didn't tell us how big its acceleration is, how much friction it needs, or what happens when there isn't enough. For that, we bring back Newton's second law and its rotational twin, side by side.

Take an object rolling down an incline of angle θ. Three forces act: gravity $Mg$ at the center of mass, the normal force $N$ at the contact point, and static friction $f_s$ at the contact point, pointing up the slope. Why up the slope? Gravity alone would make the object slide without turning. Friction at the bottom, pointing up the slope, both slows the sliding and makes a torque about the center that spins the object up.

$mg$$N$$f_s$
Forces on a hoop rolling down a 25° incline, lengths roughly to scale. Static friction points up the slope. On an FRQ, draw friction and the normal force at the contact point, where they act, because their torques matter.

Write the two laws. Along the slope (down is positive): $Mg\sin\theta - f_s = Ma$. Torque about the center of mass: only friction has a lever arm, so $f_sR = I_{cm}\alpha$. Add the rolling condition $\alpha = \frac{a}{R}$ and $I_{cm} = \beta MR^2$: $f_sR = \beta MR^2\frac{a}{R}$, so $f_s = \beta Ma$. Substitute into the first equation: $Mg\sin\theta - \beta Ma = Ma$, so $a = \frac{g\sin\theta}{1 + \beta}$.

?Wait, how big can static friction be?
Static friction adjusts to whatever value is needed to prevent sliding, up to a maximum: $f_s \le \mu_s N$. If the needed friction is bigger than $\mu_s N$, the surfaces slide and kinetic friction, $f_k = \mu_k N$, takes over.

The friction needed is $f_s = \beta Ma = \frac{\beta}{1 + \beta}Mg\sin\theta$. It must be no more than $\mu_s N = \mu_s Mg\cos\theta$. So rolling without slipping needs $\mu_s \ge \frac{\beta}{1 + \beta}\tan\theta$. Steeper ramps and larger β need more grip.

A hoop on an incline
A 3.0 kg hoop rolls without slipping down a 25° incline. Find (a) its acceleration, (b) the friction force on it, and (c) the smallest coefficient of static friction that allows rolling without slipping.
  1. Newton's second law along the slope: $Mg\sin\theta - f_s = Ma$. Torque about the center: $f_sR = I\alpha = (MR^2)\left(\frac{a}{R}\right)$, so $f_s = Ma$.
    Why?
    Write both laws and the rolling condition before combining. On the exam each one can earn a point.
  2. (a) Combine: $Mg\sin\theta = 2Ma$, so $a = \frac{g\sin 25°}{2} = \frac{(9.8)(0.423)}{2} = 2.07\ \text{m/s}^2$.
  3. (b) $f_s = Ma = (3.0)(2.07) = 6.21\ \text{N}$, up the slope.
  4. (c) $N = Mg\cos 25° = (3.0)(9.8)(0.906) = 26.6\ \text{N}$, so $\mu_s \ge \frac{f_s}{N} = \frac{6.21}{26.6} = 0.233$.
    Why?
    Check with the formula: $\frac{\beta}{1 + \beta}\tan\theta = \frac12\tan 25° = 0.233$. Same answer, and it shows the mass didn't matter.

Answer: (a) 2.1 m/s². (b) 6.2 N up the slope. (c) At least 0.23.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Two equations: forces along the slope, and torque about the center.
  2. For a hoop, $I = MR^2$, so the torque equation gives $f_s = Ma$.
  3. For (c), $\mu_s = f_s/N$ with $N = Mg\cos\theta$.

What if the object slips? Then $v_{cm} \ne R\omega$, the contact point slides, and kinetic friction $f_k = \mu_kN$ acts, pointing opposite to the way the contact point slides. Kinetic friction does work, so mechanical energy is lost to heat. The good news: the sliding can't last. Friction keeps pushing $v_{cm}$ and $R\omega$ toward each other until they match. From then on the object rolls, and on level ground it needs no friction at all.

?Wait, which way does kinetic friction point?
Opposite to the sliding of one surface relative to the other. For a skidding object, find the velocity of the contact point (center velocity plus rim velocity at the bottom). Friction on the object points opposite to that velocity.
Pause and think
A wheel is spinning in the air, with its bottom moving backward, and is set down on the floor without any forward speed. Which way does friction push it, and what does that friction do to v and to ω?
I thought about it. Show me
The bottom of the wheel slides backward across the floor, so kinetic friction on the wheel points forward. That forward force speeds up the center ($v$ grows from zero), and its torque about the center opposes the spin ($\omega$ shrinks). The wheel scoots forward and starts rolling once $v = R\omega$.
A spinning disk set on the floor
A uniform solid disk (mass 2.0 kg, radius 0.15 m) spins at 40 rad/s with its center at rest, and is set down on a floor with $\mu_k = 0.30$. Find (a) how long it slips, (b) its speed when it starts rolling without slipping, and (c) the kinetic energy turned into thermal energy.
  1. Friction on the disk: $f_k = \mu_kMg$, forward. Translation: $a = \frac{f_k}{M} = \mu_kg = (0.30)(9.8) = 2.94\ \text{m/s}^2$, so $v = 2.94t$.
  2. Rotation: friction's torque about the center opposes the spin. $\alpha = -\frac{f_kR}{I} = -\frac{\mu_kMgR}{\tfrac12 MR^2} = -\frac{2\mu_kg}{R} = -\frac{2(0.30)(9.8)}{0.15} = -39.2\ \text{rad/s}^2$, so $\omega = 40 - 39.2t$.
    Why?
    The mass cancels in both equations. The same friction force speeds up one motion and slows the other.
  3. (a) Slipping stops when $v = R\omega$: $2.94t = 0.15(40 - 39.2t) = 6.0 - 5.88t$, so $8.82t = 6.0$ and $t = 0.680\ \text{s}$.
  4. (b) $v = (2.94)(0.680) = 2.0\ \text{m/s}$. Check: $R\omega = 0.15(40 - 39.2 \times 0.680) = 2.0\ \text{m/s}$. They match.
    Why?
    Always check that the two speeds really agree at the time you found. It catches sign errors.
  5. (c) Before: $K = \tfrac12 I\omega_0^2 = \tfrac12\left(\tfrac12(2.0)(0.15)^2\right)(40)^2 = 18\ \text{J}$. After: $K = \tfrac12 Mv^2(1 + \tfrac12) = \tfrac34(2.0)(2.0)^2 = 6.0\ \text{J}$. Thermal energy: $18 - 6.0 = 12\ \text{J}$.

Answer: (a) 0.68 s. (b) 2.0 m/s. (c) 12 J, two thirds of the starting energy.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Write v(t) from the friction force and ω(t) from the friction torque.
  2. Friction speeds up $v$ and slows $\omega$. Use $\alpha = -f_kR/I$.
  3. Set $v(t) = R\omega(t)$ and solve for t.
00.20.40.60.811.20123456t (s)speed (m/s)rolling startsRω (rim speed)v of center2.0 m/s
The spinning disk after it touches the floor. The center's speed rises and the rim speed falls until they meet at 2.0 m/s, 0.68 s later. After that it rolls, and on level ground nothing changes.
Check yourself
A bowling ball is thrown so that it slides down the lane with no spin at first. While it slides, the kinetic friction force from the lane
  1. Apoints forward, increasing both its speed and its spin
  2. Bpoints backward, decreasing its speed and increasing its spin
  3. Cpoints backward, decreasing both its speed and its spin
  4. Dis zero, because the ball has no spin yet
Show the answer

B. The contact point slides forward with the ball, so friction points backward. That force slows the center, and its torque about the center starts the ball spinning forward. Speed drops and spin grows until $v = R\omega$. The last choice is a trap: friction depends on sliding, not on spin.

Exam tip from Mr. T

When an FRQ asks for a force diagram of a rolling object, draw each force at the point where it acts: gravity at the center, normal force and friction at the contact point. If you draw friction at the center, you can't show its torque, and the diagram can lose the point.

  • Rolling down an incline: $Mg\sin\theta - f_s = Ma$ and $f_sR = I_{cm}\alpha$, with $a = R\alpha$. Result: $a = \frac{g\sin\theta}{1 + \beta}$.
  • Friction needed: $f_s = \beta Ma$. Rolling without slipping needs $\mu_s \ge \frac{\beta}{1 + \beta}\tan\theta$.
  • Slipping: kinetic friction opposes the sliding of the contact point, does work, and pushes v and Rω together until rolling starts.