AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 6 lecture · Part 2 of 11 · 9 min

6.1 Energy conservation with rotationWhere the energy goes when things spin

Mr. Thompkins
Conservation of energy was your best friend in Unit 3. It still is. The only change is that the energy now has one more place to go: spinning. Forget that bucket and every answer comes out too fast.

The bookkeeping is the same as Unit 3: $K_i + U_i + W_{other} = K_f + U_f$. Now every spinning part gets a $\tfrac12 I\omega^2$ inside $K$. For gravity, an extended object's potential energy is $U = Mgy_{cm}$, where $y_{cm}$ is the height of its center of mass.

?Wait, why does only the center of mass height matter for gravity?
Add up every piece: $U = \sum m_i g y_i = g\sum m_i y_i$. Since $y_{cm} = \frac{\sum m_i y_i}{M}$, that sum is $My_{cm}$, so $U = Mgy_{cm}$. For gravitational potential energy, an extended object acts as if all its mass were at its center of mass.
m = 2.0 kgvM = 3.0 kgR = 0.10 mωh = 1.5 msolid disk pulleyfrictionless axlestring does not slip:v = Rω
A 2.0 kg block hangs from a light string wrapped around a pulley that is a uniform 3.0 kg disk of radius 0.10 m. Released from rest, the block falls 1.5 m.

Here's the classic. A block hangs from a string wrapped around a pulley that has real mass. When the block falls, it speeds up, and so does the pulley. The string doesn't slip on the pulley, so the rim moves at the same speed as the string: $v = R\omega$. That connection, called a constraint, is what lets one equation solve the whole thing.

?Wait, when is mechanical energy conserved?
When the only forces doing work are conservative ones, like gravity and springs. Here the axle is frictionless. The string's tension does negative work on the block and an equal amount of positive work on the pulley, so tension just moves energy from the block into the pulley. Gravity is the only thing changing the total.
A pulley with mass
For the setup in the figure, the block is released from rest. (a) Find the block's speed after it falls 1.5 m. (b) How much of the energy ends up in the pulley? (c) How fast would the block be moving if the pulley had no mass?
  1. Choose the system: block, pulley, string and Earth. Energy is conserved: $mgh = \tfrac12 mv^2 + \tfrac12 I\omega^2$.
    Why?
    Naming the system and saying why energy is conserved (no friction, no work by outside forces) is often its own point on an FRQ.
  2. Substitute $I = \tfrac12 MR^2$ and $\omega = \frac{v}{R}$: $\tfrac12 I\omega^2 = \tfrac12\left(\tfrac12 MR^2\right)\frac{v^2}{R^2} = \tfrac14 Mv^2$. The radius cancels.
    Why?
    The pulley's energy depends on its mass and the block's speed, not on its radius. A wider pulley spins slower and that exactly makes up for its larger I.
  3. So $mgh = \tfrac12\left(m + \tfrac{M}{2}\right)v^2$, and $v = \sqrt{\frac{2mgh}{m + M/2}} = \sqrt{\frac{2(2.0)(9.8)(1.5)}{2.0 + 1.5}} = \sqrt{16.8} = 4.10\ \text{m/s}$.
  4. (b) The pulley's share is $\tfrac14 Mv^2 = \tfrac14(3.0)(16.8) = 12.6\ \text{J}$, out of $mgh = 29.4\ \text{J}$. The block keeps $\tfrac12(2.0)(16.8) = 16.8\ \text{J}$.
    Why?
    Always check that the parts add up to the total: 12.6 + 16.8 = 29.4 J.
  5. (c) A massless pulley takes no energy, so $v = \sqrt{2gh} = \sqrt{2(9.8)(1.5)} = 5.42\ \text{m/s}$.
    Why?
    The massive pulley makes the block slower, which is the reasonable direction. Saying so in a sentence is the kind of check graders like to see.

Answer: (a) 4.1 m/s. (b) 12.6 J of the 29.4 J. (c) 5.4 m/s, faster, because no energy goes into spinning.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Write $mgh$ on the left and every kind of kinetic energy on the right.
  2. Replace $\omega$ with $v/R$ and $I$ with $\tfrac12 MR^2$. What happens to R?
  3. You should get $mgh = \tfrac12(m + M/2)v^2$.
At release (J)29.4UK blockK pulleyAfter 1.5 m (J)U16.8K block12.6K pulley
Energy accounts for the pulley problem, in joules. All 29.4 J of gravitational energy ends up as kinetic energy, split between the falling block and the spinning pulley.

Now a different kind of problem: an object turning on a fixed pivot, like a door, a swinging rod or a gate. Every point of it moves in a circle around the pivot, so you can write all of its kinetic energy as $K = \tfrac12 I_{pivot}\omega^2$, with $I$ measured about the pivot. You don't need to split it into "center of mass moving plus spinning about the center of mass". Using $I$ about the pivot already includes both, through the parallel-axis theorem.

?Wait, what is the parallel-axis theorem again?
$I = I_{cm} + Md^2$, where $d$ is the distance from the center of mass to the new axis, which must be parallel to the axis through the center of mass. Example: a rod about its end is $\frac{ML^2}{12} + M\left(\frac{L}{2}\right)^2 = \frac{ML^2}{3}$.
Pause and think
A light rod is replaced by a real 1.5 kg rod with a 0.50 kg ball on its end, pivoted at the other end and released from horizontal. Predict: at the bottom, is the ball moving faster or slower than a ball dropped freely through the same height L?
I thought about it. Show me
Faster: about 4.43 m/s compared with 3.96 m/s for free fall (you'll compute it next). The parts of the rod near the pivot lose potential energy in proportion to their distance from the pivot, but they need kinetic energy in proportion to that distance squared. So the inner parts give up more energy than they use, and the rigid rod passes the extra out to the end.
A rod with a ball on the end
A uniform rod of mass 1.5 kg and length 0.80 m has a 0.50 kg ball (treat it as a point mass) fixed to its free end. It is pivoted at the other end and released from rest in a horizontal position. Find its angular speed and the speed of the ball as the rod swings through the vertical.
swings downpivotL = 0.80 mrod 1.5 kg (start)ball 0.50 kgω = ?
  1. Rotational inertia about the pivot: $I = \frac{M L^2}{3} + mL^2 = \frac{(1.5)(0.80)^2}{3} + (0.50)(0.80)^2 = 0.32 + 0.32 = 0.64\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2$.
    Why?
    Rotational inertias about the same axis simply add.
  2. Potential energy lost: the rod's center of mass drops $\frac{L}{2}$ and the ball drops $L$: $\Delta U = Mg\frac{L}{2} + mgL = (1.5)(9.8)(0.40) + (0.50)(9.8)(0.80) = 5.88 + 3.92 = 9.8\ \text{J}$.
    Why?
    Use the height of the rod's center of mass, not its end. Using L for the rod is the most common slip here.
  3. Energy conservation: $9.8 = \tfrac12 I\omega^2$, so $\omega = \sqrt{\frac{2(9.8)}{0.64}} = 5.53\ \text{rad/s}$.
  4. Ball speed: $v = L\omega = (0.80)(5.53) = 4.43\ \text{m/s}$, more than the free-fall $\sqrt{2gL} = 3.96\ \text{m/s}$.

Answer: $\omega \approx 5.5$ rad/s and the ball moves at about 4.4 m/s.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Find I about the pivot for the rod and for the ball, then add.
  2. How far do the rod's center of mass and the ball each drop?
  3. Set the total drop in potential energy equal to $\tfrac12 I\omega^2$, then use $v = L\omega$.
Check yourself
In the pulley problem, the solid-disk pulley is replaced by a hoop-shaped pulley of the same mass and radius. Released from rest, the block falls the same height. Compared with before, the block's final speed is
  1. Alarger, because a hoop is lighter in the middle
  2. Bsmaller, because the hoop has a larger rotational inertia and takes more of the energy
  3. Cthe same, because the mass of the pulley did not change
  4. Dthe same, because the radius cancels
Show the answer

B. A hoop has $I = MR^2$, twice the disk's. Its kinetic energy becomes $\tfrac12 Mv^2$ instead of $\tfrac14 Mv^2$, so it takes a bigger share of $mgh$ and the block is slower. The radius does cancel (the trap in the last choice), but the shape factor does not.

Exam tip from Mr. T

On an energy FRQ, write the conservation equation in symbols with every term labeled before any numbers. A missing ½Iω² term is the single most common reason students lose the first point in this unit.

  • Energy conservation with rotation: include $\tfrac12 I\omega^2$ for every spinning part, and use $U = Mgy_{cm}$ for extended objects.
  • A string that doesn't slip ties the motions together: $v = R\omega$.
  • For an object on a fixed pivot, $K = \tfrac12 I_{pivot}\omega^2$ covers all of its kinetic energy.
  • A massive pulley or a rotating part always makes the falling object slower than free fall would.