AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 5 lecture · Part 5 of 12 · 9 min

5.3 Torque as a cross product, and the torque from gravityWhich way does a torque point?

Mr. Thompkins
Physics C asks one more thing of torque: it's a vector, $\vec\tau = \vec r \times \vec F$. That sounds abstract, but it gives you a clean formula when the problem hands you components, and a reason why gravity acts at the center of mass.
?Wait, what's a cross product?
$\vec A \times \vec B$ is a vector of size $AB\sin\theta$, perpendicular to both $\vec A$ and $\vec B$. Its direction comes from the right-hand rule: point your fingers along $\vec A$, curl them toward $\vec B$, and your thumb points along $\vec A \times \vec B$. Order matters: $\vec B \times \vec A = -\vec A \times \vec B$. For unit vectors, $\hat\imath \times \hat\jmath = \hat k$ and $\hat\jmath \times \hat\imath = -\hat k$.

For a force in the xy-plane acting at a point $\vec r = (x, y)$ from the axis, the torque points along z, the axis of rotation: $\tau_z = xF_y - yF_x$. A positive $\tau_z$ points out of the page (toward you), and it turns things counterclockwise as you look at the page. A negative one points into the page and turns things clockwise. So the vector definition and the "counterclockwise is positive" rule agree.

xyaxis (origin)$\vec r$$\vec F$τ out of the page(+z, counterclockwise)
$\vec r = (0.40, 0.30)$ m and $\vec F = (-5.0, 12)$ N. Curl the fingers of your right hand from $\vec r$ toward $\vec F$: your thumb points out of the page, so the torque is counterclockwise.
Torque from components
A force $\vec F = (-5.0\,\hat\imath + 12\,\hat\jmath)$ N acts at the point $\vec r = (0.40\,\hat\imath + 0.30\,\hat\jmath)$ m, measured from an axis along z through the origin. (a) Find the torque vector. (b) Check its size with $rF\sin\theta$.
  1. (a) $\tau_z = xF_y - yF_x = (0.40)(12) - (0.30)(-5.0) = 4.8 + 1.5 = 6.3\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}$.
    Why?
    Watch the double negative: $-(0.30)(-5.0) = +1.5$. Most errors with this formula are sign errors in the second term.
  2. So $\vec\tau = +6.3\,\hat k\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}$: out of the page, counterclockwise.
  3. (b) $r = \sqrt{0.40^2 + 0.30^2} = 0.50\ \text{m}$ and $F = \sqrt{5.0^2 + 12^2} = 13\ \text{N}$. Then $\sin\theta = \frac{6.3}{(0.50)(13)} \approx 0.97$, so the angle between them is about 76°.
    Why?
    That matches the figure: $\vec r$ points at about 37° and $\vec F$ at about 113°, a difference of about 76°.

Answer: (a) $\vec\tau = +6.3\,\hat k$ N·m (counterclockwise) (b) $rF\sin\theta = (0.50)(13)(0.97) \approx 6.3$ N·m, consistent.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Use $\tau_z = xF_y - yF_x$.
  2. $x = 0.40$, $y = 0.30$, $F_x = -5.0$, $F_y = 12$.
  3. Positive $\tau_z$ means out of the page, counterclockwise.

Gravity acts at the center of mass

Every bit of an object feels gravity, so how do you find the torque gravity exerts on, say, a rod sticking out from a pivot? Add up the torques of all the pieces. For a horizontal object with gravity straight down, a piece $m_i$ at horizontal distance $x_i$ from the pivot contributes $x_im_ig$ (clockwise if it's to the right). The total is $g\Sigma m_ix_i = g(Mx_{cm}) = Mg\,x_{cm}$. So the total gravitational torque is exactly what you'd get with all the weight acting at the center of mass. That's why you can draw one $Mg$ arrow at the center of mass in every torque problem.

?Wait, how do I find the center of mass of a rod whose density changes?
$x_{cm} = \frac{1}{M}\int x\,dm$ with $dm = \lambda(x)\,dx$, and $M = \int\lambda\,dx$ (Unit 2). Do the mass integral first, then the moment integral, then divide.
pivotL/2$Mg$$x_{cm} = 5L/9$heavier endL
A rod that gets heavier toward its far end, $\lambda = b(1 + x/L)$, held horizontal on a pivot. Its center of mass sits at $5L/9$, past the middle, and that's where the weight acts for the torque.
Gravity torque on a tapered rod
A rod of length L = 0.90 m and mass M = 1.2 kg has linear density $\lambda(x) = b(1 + x/L)$, where x is measured from the pivot end and b is a constant. It's held horizontal. (a) Find the center of mass in terms of L. (b) Find the torque of gravity about the pivot.
  1. Mass: $M = \int_0^L b\left(1 + \frac{x}{L}\right)dx = b\left(L + \frac{L}{2}\right) = \frac{3}{2}bL$.
  2. Moment: $\int_0^L x\,b\left(1 + \frac{x}{L}\right)dx = b\left(\frac{L^2}{2} + \frac{L^2}{3}\right) = \frac{5}{6}bL^2$.
  3. (a) $x_{cm} = \frac{(5/6)bL^2}{(3/2)bL} = \frac{5L}{9}$, which is 0.50 m for L = 0.90 m.
    Why?
    Past the middle (0.45 m), toward the heavier end, as it should be. The constant b cancels, so you never need its value.
  4. (b) $\tau = Mg\,x_{cm} = (1.2)(9.8)(0.50) \approx 5.9\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}$, clockwise if the rod sticks out to the right.

Answer: (a) $x_{cm} = 5L/9 = 0.50$ m (b) about 5.9 N·m.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Find M by integrating λ from 0 to L.
  2. Then integrate $x\lambda$ from 0 to L and divide by M.
  3. Torque from gravity: $Mg$ times the horizontal distance to the center of mass.
Pause and think
Where would you put a pivot so that gravity exerts no torque at all on the rod, whatever angle it's held at?
I thought about it. Show me
At the center of mass. Then $x_{cm} = 0$ measured from the pivot, so gravity's torque is zero in every orientation. That's why an object balances on a support placed right under its center of mass.
Check yourself
A student computes $\vec F \times \vec r$ instead of $\vec r \times \vec F$ for a torque. How does her answer compare with the correct torque?
  1. AIt's the same vector.
  2. BIt has the same size but points the opposite way.
  3. CIt's zero.
  4. DIt's bigger by a factor of $\sin\theta$.
Show the answer

B. The cross product is anticommutative: $\vec F \times \vec r = -(\vec r \times \vec F)$. Same size, $rF\sin\theta$, opposite direction, so she'd call a counterclockwise torque clockwise.

  • $\vec\tau = \vec r \times \vec F$; for the xy-plane, $\tau_z = xF_y - yF_x$.
  • Positive z (out of the page) is counterclockwise. Order matters.
  • Gravity's torque equals $Mg$ acting at the center of mass.
  • For a nonuniform object, find $x_{cm}$ by integration first.