AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 4 lecture · Part 10 of 11 · 9 min

4.4 Collisions inside bigger problemsMomentum for the hit, energy for the rest

Mr. Thompkins
Free-response questions rarely stop at the collision. Something hits, and then it swings, slides, climbs a hill or squeezes a spring. The skill they test is knowing which law to use in which stage, and where one stage ends and the next begins.

Break the story into stages. During a collision, forces are huge and brief, kinetic energy is often lost, and momentum is conserved. Before and after the collision, forces like gravity and springs act over longer times, so momentum of the moving object changes, but mechanical energy is conserved if there's no friction. So: momentum across the collision, energy across the motion. Never write one energy equation from before a sticky collision to the end of the story.

block 2.0 kgbullet 10 ghstage 1, the hit: momentumstage 2, the swing: energystring and block not to scale
A ballistic pendulum: a bullet lodges in a block hung from two strings, and the block swings up a height h. The two parallel strings keep the block level, so it swings without turning.
?Wait, how does energy conservation work for a swing?
If only gravity does work (the strings pull perpendicular to the motion, so they do none), kinetic energy turns into gravitational potential energy: $\tfrac{1}{2}MV^2 = Mgh$, so $V = \sqrt{2gh}$. The mass cancels and the path doesn't matter, only the height (Unit 3).
The ballistic pendulum
A 10 g bullet is fired horizontally into a 2.0 kg block hanging at rest, and it stays inside. The block rises 5.0 cm. (a) Derive an expression for the bullet's speed in terms of the masses, h and g. (b) Calculate it. (c) What fraction of the bullet's kinetic energy survives the collision?
  1. Stage 2 first, working backward: from just after the hit to the top, energy is conserved: $\tfrac{1}{2}(m + M)V^2 = (m + M)gh$, so $V = \sqrt{2gh}$.
    Why?
    Start from the stage you have the most information about. Here the height tells you the speed just after the collision.
  2. Stage 1, the hit: momentum is conserved (the collision is so quick that the strings stay nearly vertical and give no horizontal impulse): $mv = (m + M)V$.
  3. (a) Combine: $v = \frac{m + M}{m}\sqrt{2gh}$.
  4. (b) $V = \sqrt{2(9.8)(0.050)} \approx 0.99\ \text{m/s}$, and $v = \frac{2.010}{0.010}(0.99) \approx 199\ \text{m/s}$, about 200 m/s.
    Why?
    Convert grams to kilograms and centimeters to meters first. Leaving h as 5.0 makes the speed 10 times too big.
  5. (c) For a perfectly inelastic hit on a block at rest, the fraction kept is $\frac{m}{m + M} = \frac{0.010}{2.010} \approx 0.005$: only about 0.5% survives. The bullet's 198 J drops to about 0.98 J.
    Why?
    That's why the energy-only shortcut fails so badly: it would give $v = \sqrt{2gh(m + M)/m}$, about 14 m/s, off by a factor of 14.

Answer: (a) $v = \frac{m + M}{m}\sqrt{2gh}$ (b) about 199 m/s (c) about 0.5%.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Find the block's speed just after the hit from the height it reaches.
  2. $V = \sqrt{2gh}$, then use momentum for the hit: $mv = (m + M)V$.
  3. Fraction of kinetic energy kept in a sticky hit on a mass at rest: $\frac{m}{m + M}$.
Before the hit198K$U_g$Just after0.98K$U_g$Top of swingK0.98$U_g$
Energy through the ballistic pendulum, in joules. The hit wipes out more than 99% of the kinetic energy. The swing then converts what's left into potential energy with nothing lost.
Pause and think
A student skips the collision stage and writes one equation: $\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 = (m + M)gh$. Why is that wrong, and will the student's speed be too high or too low?
I thought about it. Show me
It assumes kinetic energy is conserved through the collision, but the bullet sticks, so almost all of it becomes internal energy. The equation says only 0.98 J of the bullet's energy came in, so it gives a speed that's far too low: about 14 m/s instead of about 199 m/s.
A hit, then a spring
A 0.50 kg ball of clay moving at 6.0 m/s hits and sticks to a 1.0 kg block at rest on a frictionless floor. The block then slides into a light spring with $k = 300\ \text{N/m}$. (a) Find the speed just after the hit. (b) Find the spring's maximum compression. (c) What fraction of the clay's original kinetic energy ends up stored in the spring?
  1. (a) Hit: momentum. $(0.50)(6.0) = (1.5)V$, so $V = 2.0\ \text{m/s}$.
  2. (b) Squeeze: energy. $\tfrac{1}{2}(1.5)(2.0)^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(300)x^2$, so $3.0\ \text{J} = 150x^2$ and $x = \sqrt{0.020} \approx 0.14\ \text{m}$.
    Why?
    Once the hit is over, the floor is frictionless and the spring is conservative, so mechanical energy is conserved.
  3. (c) The clay started with $\tfrac{1}{2}(0.50)(6.0)^2 = 9.0\ \text{J}$. The spring stores 3.0 J at most, which is one third. That matches $\frac{m}{m + M} = \frac{0.50}{1.5}$.

Answer: (a) 2.0 m/s (b) about 0.14 m (c) one third.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Two stages: the sticky hit, then the spring.
  2. Hit: $m v = (m + M)V$.
  3. Spring: $\tfrac{1}{2}(m + M)V^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2$.
?Wait, what's the energy stored in a spring?
A spring compressed or stretched a distance x from its natural length stores elastic potential energy $U_s = \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2$ (Unit 3). It comes from integrating the spring force: $\int_0^x kx'\,dx' = \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2$.
Check yourself
In a ballistic pendulum the block is much heavier than the bullet. If the bullet's mass were doubled (same speed, same block), about how high would the block rise?
  1. AThe same height
  2. BAbout twice as high
  3. CAbout four times as high
  4. DAbout half as high
Show the answer

C. Momentum: $V = \frac{m}{m + M}v$. With $M \gg m$, doubling m about doubles V. Height goes as $V^2$ ($h = V^2/2g$), so the block rises about four times as high. Choice B forgets that height depends on the square of the speed.

  • Collision stage: momentum. Smooth motion stages: energy (if no friction).
  • Ballistic pendulum: $v = \frac{m + M}{m}\sqrt{2gh}$.
  • Never use one energy equation across a sticky collision.
  • Work backward from the stage you know the most about.