AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 4 lecture · Part 11 of 11 · 8 min

Unit 4 wrap-upPut it together

Mr. Thompkins
You've done the whole unit. Let's zoom out. Every problem in Unit 4 starts with the same two questions: is there a net external force on my system during this event, and is the collision elastic? The table below turns those questions into a choice of tool.
The question gives you or asks forReach forIn symbols
p(t), or "the force at an instant"Second law, momentum formΣF = dp/dt
F(t) or an F-t graphImpulse-momentum theoremΔp = ∫F dt (area)
A collision or explosion, external forces negligibleConservation of momentumΣmv before = Σmv after
"Elastic", or a question about lost energyKinetic energy, after momentum½Σmv² before vs after
The motion of the whole systemCenter-of-mass velocity$v_{cm}$ = Σmv/Σm, ΣF_ext = $Ma_{cm}$
A hit followed by a swing, slide or springTwo stagesMomentum for the hit, energy for the rest
Which tool for which question.
?Wait, when exactly is momentum conserved again?
When the net external force on the system is zero, or when the event is so short that the external forces deliver a negligible impulse (most collisions). It can also be conserved in one direction only: horizontally, say, when all the external forces are vertical.

Three ideas tie the unit together. First, forces change momentum: $\Sigma\vec F = \frac{d\vec p}{dt}$, and over time that adds up to impulse, the area under F(t). Second, internal forces come in third-law pairs, so they give equal and opposite impulses and can't change a system's total momentum or move its center of mass. Third, momentum and kinetic energy are different: momentum is always conserved in an isolated collision, kinetic energy only in an elastic one.

Pause and think
Connect two topics. During a collision, cart A pushes on cart B and B pushes on A. Explain how conservation of momentum follows from the impulse-momentum theorem and Newton's third law.
I thought about it. Show me
By the third law the two forces are equal and opposite at every instant, and they act for exactly the same time, so their impulses are equal and opposite: $J_{on\,B} = -J_{on\,A}$. By the impulse-momentum theorem, $\Delta p_B = -\Delta p_A$. So whatever momentum one cart gains, the other loses, and the total doesn't change.

Traps that cost points

✕ Dropping the sign on a bounce, so $\Delta p$ comes out too small.
✓ Write $\Delta p = m(v_f - v_i)$ with signed velocities. For a bounce the speeds add.
✕ Multiplying the peak force by the contact time.
✓ Impulse is the area under F(t): integrate or find the area of the shape.
✕ Conserving kinetic energy in a collision where objects stick or dent.
✓ Conserve momentum. Use kinetic energy only when the problem says elastic.
✕ Adding momenta as plain numbers in two dimensions.
✓ One equation for x, one for y.
✕ Using one energy equation for a whole ballistic pendulum.
✓ Momentum for the hit, energy for the swing.
✕ Thinking an explosion moves the center of mass toward the bigger piece.
✓ Internal forces can't change $\vec v_{cm}$. The pieces spread out around it.
✕ Conserving momentum for one object while an outside force acts on it.
✓ Choose a system big enough that the force becomes internal, or use impulse.
✕ Leaving milliseconds or grams in the formula.
✓ Convert to seconds and kilograms before you multiply.

Key relationships for Unit 4

$\vec p = m\vec v$
MomentumA vector, in kg·m/s
$\Sigma\vec F = \frac{d\vec p}{dt}$
Second law, momentum formSlope of p(t) is the net force
$\vec J = \int\vec F\,dt = \Delta\vec p$
Impulse-momentum theoremArea under F(t); units N·s
$F_{avg} = \frac{\Delta p}{\Delta t}$
Average forceSame impulse, longer time, smaller force
$\Sigma m_i\vec v_i = \Sigma m_i\vec v_i'$
Conservation of momentumNo net external force on the system
$\vec v_{cm} = \frac{\Sigma m_i\vec v_i}{\Sigma m_i},\quad \Sigma\vec F_{ext} = M\vec a_{cm}$
Center-of-mass motionConstant velocity when the net external force is zero
$v_1 - v_2 = -(v_1' - v_2')$
Elastic, one dimensionUse with momentum
$K = \frac{p^2}{2m}$
Kinetic energy from momentumComparing objects with equal momentum

FRQ strategy for Unit 4

  1. Name the system and the principle in a sentence before any equation: "No net external force on the two-cart system, so momentum is conserved."
  2. Draw a before-and-after sketch with a positive direction (or x and y axes) and signed velocities.
  3. Mathematical Routines: write impulse as $\int F\,dt$ with limits, and $\Sigma F = dp/dt$ when you have p(t). Show the derivative or integral, then the numbers.
  4. Translation Between Representations: the area under an F-t graph is impulse, the slope of a p-t graph is force, and a center-of-mass x-t graph is a straight line when momentum is conserved. Make your sketch match your equations.
  5. Experimental Design and Analysis: measure velocity before and after (motion detector) and force over time (force sensor); compare the area under F(t) with $m\,\Delta v$; linearize so the slope means something.
  6. Qualitative/Quantitative Translation: explain the reasoning in words first ("the bounce reverses the momentum, so the impulse is larger"), then show the equation says the same thing.
  7. For a collision followed by motion, label the stages and say which law each one uses.
?Wait, how do I integrate a sine pulse?
$\int\sin(kt)\,dt = -\frac{1}{k}\cos(kt)$. Over one half cycle, from 0 to T with $k = \pi/T$: $\left[-\frac{T}{\pi}\cos\frac{\pi t}{T}\right]_0^T = \frac{T}{\pi}(1 + 1) = \frac{2T}{\pi}$.
Mixed FRQ practice
Cart A (1.0 kg) moves at 4.0 m/s toward cart B (3.0 kg), which is at rest on a frictionless track. A spring bumper on B makes the collision elastic. During the 0.050 s contact, the force between the carts is modeled as $F(t) = F_{max}\sin\left(\frac{\pi t}{0.050}\right)$. (a) Find both velocities after the collision. (b) Find the impulse on cart B. (c) Find $F_{max}$. (d) At the moment the spring is most compressed, the carts move with the same velocity. Find that velocity and the energy stored in the spring then.
  1. (a) Elastic, target at rest: $v_A' = \frac{1.0 - 3.0}{4.0}(4.0) = -2.0\ \text{m/s}$ and $v_B' = \frac{2(1.0)}{4.0}(4.0) = +2.0\ \text{m/s}$.
    Why?
    Check: momentum $-2.0 + 6.0 = 4.0$ ✓. Kinetic energy $2.0 + 6.0 = 8.0\ \text{J}$, the same as $\tfrac{1}{2}(1.0)(4.0)^2$ ✓.
  2. (b) $J_B = \Delta p_B = (3.0)(2.0 - 0) = 6.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}$, in A's original direction.
    Why?
    A gets $-6.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}$: equal and opposite, as the third law demands.
  3. (c) $J = \int_0^{0.050}F_{max}\sin\left(\frac{\pi t}{0.050}\right)dt = F_{max}\frac{2(0.050)}{\pi}$. Set it equal to 6.0: $F_{max} = \frac{6.0\pi}{0.10} \approx 190\ \text{N}$.
    Why?
    $\int_0^T\sin\left(\frac{\pi t}{T}\right)dt = \frac{2T}{\pi}$. A half sine wave has about 64% of the area of the rectangle around it.
  4. (d) Moving together means a shared velocity, which must be $v_{cm} = \frac{(1.0)(4.0)}{4.0} = 1.0\ \text{m/s}$. The kinetic energy then is $\tfrac{1}{2}(4.0)(1.0)^2 = 2.0\ \text{J}$. Total energy is still 8.0 J, so the spring stores $8.0 - 2.0 = 6.0\ \text{J}$.
    Why?
    At maximum compression the collision looks perfectly inelastic for an instant. The "lost" kinetic energy is parked in the spring, and the spring gives it all back because this collision is elastic.

Answer: (a) A: −2.0 m/s, B: +2.0 m/s (b) 6.0 N·s (c) about 190 N (d) 1.0 m/s, 6.0 J.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. For (a), use the elastic formulas with the target at rest.
  2. For (b), impulse on B is B's change in momentum. For (c), integrate the half sine and set it equal to that impulse.
  3. For (d), the shared velocity is the center-of-mass velocity; compare kinetic energies.
Check yourself
A truck and a small car collide head on. Which statement about the collision is correct?
  1. AThe truck exerts a larger force on the car than the car exerts on the truck.
  2. BThe car and the truck receive impulses of equal size, but the car's velocity changes more.
  3. CThe car receives a larger impulse, because it's lighter.
  4. DThe truck receives a larger impulse, because it has more momentum.
Show the answer

B. By the third law the forces are equal and opposite for the same time, so the impulses, and the changes in momentum, have equal size. The car's mass is smaller, so its $\Delta v = \Delta p/m$ is larger, which is why the people in the car feel the crash more. Choices A, C and D all break the third law.

Check yourself
A 0.20 kg puck at rest gets a push whose force-time graph is a triangle: the force rises from 0 to 30 N in 0.10 s and falls back to 0 at 0.30 s. What is the puck's final speed?
  1. A7.5 m/s
  2. B15 m/s
  3. C22.5 m/s
  4. D45 m/s
Show the answer

C. Area of the triangle: $\tfrac{1}{2}(0.30)(30) = 4.5\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}$, so $v = \frac{4.5}{0.20} = 22.5\ \text{m/s}$. The peak's position doesn't change the area. Choice D uses the whole rectangle, $30 \times 0.30$, which is twice the triangle. Choice A uses only the rising part.

Mr. Thompkins
That's Unit 4. Go try the Unit 4 practice questions while this is fresh. When you miss one, come back to that section and open its recall cards. Next up, Unit 5: everything you just learned about pushing things in a line, now applied to making things spin.