AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 4 lecture · Part 9 of 11 · 9 min

4.4 Collisions in two dimensionsConserve x and y separately

Mr. Thompkins
Billiard balls, hockey pucks and cars at an intersection don't stay on one line. The good news is that you already know everything you need: momentum is a vector, so it's conserved in each direction separately. Two dimensions just means two equations.

If no net external force acts, $\Sigma\vec p_{before} = \Sigma\vec p_{after}$ as vectors. Write it as two scalar equations: $\Sigma p_x$ before $= \Sigma p_x$ after, and $\Sigma p_y$ before $= \Sigma p_y$ after. Set up axes so that as many velocities as possible lie along one axis, usually the incoming velocity along $+x$.

?Wait, how do I split a vector into components?
For a vector of size A at angle θ above the +x axis: $A_x = A\cos\theta$ and $A_y = A\sin\theta$. Going back: $A = \sqrt{A_x^2 + A_y^2}$ and $\theta = \tan^{-1}(A_y/A_x)$, checking the quadrant from the signs (Unit 1).
A glancing collision
On an air table, puck A (0.30 kg) moving at 5.0 m/s along $+x$ hits puck B (0.20 kg) at rest. Afterward A moves at 3.0 m/s at 30° above the $+x$ axis. (a) Find B's velocity (speed and direction). (b) Was the collision elastic?
  1. x: $(0.30)(5.0) = (0.30)(3.0)\cos 30^\circ + (0.20)v_{Bx}$, so $1.50 = 0.779 + 0.20v_{Bx}$ and $v_{Bx} \approx 3.60\ \text{m/s}$.
    Why?
    One equation per axis, each with every object's component in it. Before the collision, the y-momentum is zero.
  2. y: $0 = (0.30)(3.0)\sin 30^\circ + (0.20)v_{By}$, so $v_{By} = -\frac{0.45}{0.20} = -2.25\ \text{m/s}$.
    Why?
    B must go below the axis to cancel the y-momentum A picked up. A negative component is information, not a mistake.
  3. Combine: $v_B = \sqrt{3.60^2 + 2.25^2} \approx 4.2\ \text{m/s}$ at $\tan^{-1}\left(\frac{2.25}{3.60}\right) \approx 32^\circ$ below the $+x$ axis.
  4. (b) $K_i = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.30)(5.0)^2 = 3.75\ \text{J}$. $K_f = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.30)(3.0)^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}(0.20)(4.25)^2 \approx 1.35 + 1.80 = 3.15\ \text{J}$. About 0.60 J (16%) was lost, so it was inelastic.
    Why?
    Use the unrounded speed, 4.248 m/s, when you square it. Rounding to 4.2 first gives 1.76 J, a small but avoidable error.

Answer: (a) About 4.2 m/s at 32° below the +x axis (b) inelastic: kinetic energy fell from 3.75 J to about 3.15 J.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Before the collision all the momentum is along x: $1.50\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}$.
  2. A's components after: $0.30(3.0\cos 30^\circ)$ in x and $0.30(3.0\sin 30^\circ)$ in y.
  3. B has whatever is left over in x, and exactly cancels A's y-momentum.
$p_{A} = 1.50$ before$p_A' = 0.90$$p_B' = 0.85$30°32°after = before: the two after-arrowsadd up, tip to tail, to the before-arrowkg·m/s
The puck collision as a momentum triangle, drawn to scale. The two momenta after the collision add, tip to tail, to the single momentum before it. This picture is a fast way to check a 2-D answer.
Pause and think
Two pucks of equal mass collide elastically, one starting at rest. A famous result says they always leave at 90° to each other. In the puck problem above, the angle between the two final velocities is 30° + 32° = 62°. What does that tell you?
I thought about it. Show me
That the collision wasn't elastic, which matches the energy calculation. (The masses here also aren't equal, so the 90° rule wouldn't apply anyway. For equal masses, elastic, one at rest, the triangle of momenta becomes a right triangle, because $p^2 = p_A'^2 + p_B'^2$ is exactly the energy equation.)
?Wait, why can't I just add the speeds before and after?
Because speed is a scalar and momentum is a vector. Two momenta pointing in different directions add like the sides of a triangle: the total is less than the sum of the sizes. Conservation applies to the vector, so it holds component by component, not speed by speed.

Perfectly inelastic collisions in two dimensions are even easier, because there's only one final velocity to find. Find the total momentum vector before, divide by the total mass, and that's the velocity of the wreck (it's also $\vec v_{cm}$, which can't change in the crash).

Check yourself
At an icy intersection, a 1200 kg car heading north at 15 m/s collides with an 1800 kg van heading east at 10 m/s, and they lock together. What is their velocity right after the crash?
  1. A8.5 m/s at 45° north of east
  2. B12.5 m/s at 45° north of east
  3. C8.5 m/s at 56° north of east
  4. D25 m/s at 45° north of east
Show the answer

A. East: $(1800)(10) = 18{,}000$. North: $(1200)(15) = 18{,}000\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}$. Equal components give 45°, and $|\vec p| = 18{,}000\sqrt{2} \approx 25{,}500$, so $v = \frac{25{,}500}{3000} \approx 8.5\ \text{m/s}$. Choice B averages the speeds, and choice C uses the speed ratio 15/10 for the angle instead of the momentum ratio.

Check yourself
A box at rest in deep space explodes into three pieces. A 1.0 kg piece flies off at 6.0 m/s along $+x$ and a 2.0 kg piece at 2.0 m/s along $+y$. The third piece has mass 0.50 kg. What is its speed?
  1. A4.0 m/s
  2. B8.0 m/s
  3. C14 m/s
  4. D20 m/s
Show the answer

C. The total momentum stays zero, so the third piece must carry $(-6.0, -4.0)\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}$: size $\sqrt{36 + 16} \approx 7.2\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}$, and $v = \frac{7.2}{0.50} \approx 14\ \text{m/s}$, pointing down and to the left. Choice D adds the momentum sizes, 6.0 + 4.0, before dividing, which treats them as scalars.

  • 2-D: conserve $p_x$ and $p_y$ separately. Two equations, two unknowns.
  • Put the incoming velocity along +x so the initial y-momentum is zero.
  • Check with a tip-to-tail momentum triangle.
  • Sticky 2-D crash: $\vec v' = \frac{\Sigma m\vec v}{\Sigma m}$, the center-of-mass velocity.