4.4 Elastic collisions in one dimensionWhen kinetic energy survives too

In an elastic collision in one dimension you have two unknowns, the two final velocities, and two equations: momentum and kinetic energy. The energy equation has squares in it, which looks messy, but there's a beautiful shortcut. Group each equation by object:
Momentum: $m_1(v_1 - v_1') = m_2(v_2' - v_2)$. Kinetic energy (cancel the $\tfrac{1}{2}$): $m_1(v_1^2 - v_1'^2) = m_2(v_2'^2 - v_2^2)$. Factor each difference of squares and divide the energy equation by the momentum equation. Everything cancels except $v_1 + v_1' = v_2 + v_2'$, which rearranges to $v_1 - v_2 = -(v_1' - v_2')$.
?Wait, how does a difference of squares factor?
In words: in a one-dimensional elastic collision, the objects separate at the same speed they approached. The relative velocity just reverses. That linear equation replaces the squared one, and with momentum it gives you two simple equations. If the target starts at rest, solving them gives $v_1' = \frac{m_1 - m_2}{m_1 + m_2}v_1$ and $v_2' = \frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2}v_1$.
I thought about it. Show me
- Momentum: $(0.30)(0.60) + (0.20)(-0.40) = 0.30v_1' + 0.20v_2'$, so $0.30v_1' + 0.20v_2' = 0.10$.
- Relative velocity reverses: $v_1 - v_2 = 0.60 - (-0.40) = 1.0\ \text{m/s}$, so $v_2' - v_1' = 1.0$, which gives $v_2' = v_1' + 1.0$.
Why?
This is the elastic shortcut. Use it only when the problem says elastic, or gives you a reason to believe it. - Substitute: $0.30v_1' + 0.20(v_1' + 1.0) = 0.10$, so $0.50v_1' = -0.10$ and $v_1' = -0.20\ \text{m/s}$. Then $v_2' = +0.80\ \text{m/s}$.
- Check: $K_i = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.30)(0.36) + \tfrac{1}{2}(0.20)(0.16) = 0.054 + 0.016 = 0.070\ \text{J}$. $K_f = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.30)(0.04) + \tfrac{1}{2}(0.20)(0.64) = 0.006 + 0.064 = 0.070\ \text{J}$. Equal, as an elastic collision must be.
Why?
If your check fails, the usual culprit is a sign on one of the starting velocities.
Answer: The 0.30 kg glider moves at 0.20 m/s backward (−0.20 m/s) and the 0.20 kg glider at +0.80 m/s.
Stuck? Get a hint
- Write momentum with signs: the 0.20 kg glider starts at −0.40 m/s.
- Elastic means $v_2' - v_1' = v_1 - v_2 = 1.0\ \text{m/s}$.
- Substitute $v_2' = v_1' + 1.0$ into the momentum equation.
?Wait, is there a faster way using the center of mass?
- ABoth move forward at v/2.
- BThe first ball stops and the second moves at v.
- CThe first ball bounces back at v and the second stays at rest.
- DThey stick and move at v/2.
Show the answer
B. Equal masses: $v_1' = \frac{m - m}{2m}v = 0$ and $v_2' = \frac{2m}{2m}v = v$. They trade velocities, which is the Newton's cradle. Choice A conserves momentum but keeps only half of the kinetic energy, so it can't be elastic. Choice D is the perfectly inelastic result.
- A1.0 kg: +1.2 m/s; 4.0 kg: +1.2 m/s
- B1.0 kg: −3.6 m/s; 4.0 kg: +2.4 m/s
- C1.0 kg: −6.0 m/s; 4.0 kg: +3.0 m/s
- D1.0 kg: 0; 4.0 kg: +1.5 m/s
Show the answer
B. $v_1' = \frac{1.0 - 4.0}{5.0}(6.0) = -3.6\ \text{m/s}$ and $v_2' = \frac{2(1.0)}{5.0}(6.0) = +2.4\ \text{m/s}$. Check the shortcut: they approached at 6.0 m/s and separate at $2.4 - (-3.6) = 6.0\ \text{m/s}$. Choice A is the sticky result. Choice C does conserve momentum ($-6.0 + 12 = 6.0$), but its kinetic energy, 36 J, is twice the 18 J you started with, so it creates energy from nothing.
Beyond the course, as a bonus: spacecraft use the "heavy ball hits light ball" idea in reverse. A probe swinging around a moving planet behaves like a light ball bouncing elastically off a massive moving one, and it leaves with extra speed taken from the planet's orbital motion. Engineers call it a gravity assist.
- 1-D elastic: the relative velocity reverses, $v_1 - v_2 = -(v_1' - v_2')$. Use it with momentum.
- Target at rest: $v_1' = \frac{m_1 - m_2}{m_1 + m_2}v_1$ and $v_2' = \frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2}v_1$.
- Equal masses swap velocities. Light on heavy bounces back. Heavy on light keeps going, and the light one leaves at up to $2v_1$.
- Always check: kinetic energy before = kinetic energy after.