AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 3 lecture · Part 7 of 9 · 10 min

3.4 Conservation of energy, with friction and far from EarthFriction, and energy at the scale of planets

Mr. Thompkins
Two extensions turn energy conservation into a tool for almost any problem: friction, which turns mechanical energy into thermal energy, and gravity far from Earth, where $mgh$ quietly stops being true.

Friction and thermal energy

Kinetic friction converts mechanical energy into thermal energy: the surfaces warm up. For an object sliding a path length $d$ against kinetic friction $f_k$, the thermal energy created is $\Delta E_{th} = f_kd$. So the energy equation becomes

$$K_i + U_i = K_f + U_f + f_kd$$

Total energy is still conserved. It's just that some of it is now in a form you can't easily get back. Notice $d$ is the path length, not the displacement: slide back and forth and friction keeps converting energy on every pass.

?Wait, why do I use the normal force to find the friction on a slope?
Kinetic friction is $f_k = \mu_kF_N$, and on an incline the normal force is $mg\cos\theta$, not $mg$. Find it from the forces perpendicular to the slope, just as in Unit 2. Energy methods don't replace the FBD for friction: you still need it to get $f_k$.
Up a rough ramp
A 3.0 kg box is launched at 6.0 m/s up a 30° incline. The coefficient of kinetic friction is 0.20. (a) How far up the incline does it slide? (b) How much thermal energy is produced?
Start54KUgEthHighest pointK40.1Ug13.9Eth
Where the 54 J went: 40.1 J into gravitational energy, 13.9 J into thermal energy.
  1. Energy at the start: $K = \frac12(3.0)(6.0)^2 = 54\ \text{J}$. At the highest point, $K = 0$ and the box has risen $d\sin 30°$.
    Why?
    Choose the bottom as the zero of Ug, and d as the distance along the slope.
  2. Friction: $F_N = mg\cos 30°$, so $f_k = \mu_kmg\cos 30°$ and $\Delta E_{th} = \mu_kmg\cos 30°\,d$.
  3. (a) $\frac12 mv^2 = mgd\sin 30° + \mu_kmgd\cos 30°$, so $d = \frac{v^2}{2g(\sin 30° + \mu_k\cos 30°)} = \frac{36}{19.6(0.500 + 0.173)} = 2.7\ \text{m}$.
    Why?
    Solve symbolically first. The mass cancels, and the expression shows that more friction means a shorter slide.
  4. (b) $\Delta E_{th} = (0.20)(3.0)(9.8)(0.866)(2.73) = 13.9\ \text{J}$. Check: $U_g = (3.0)(9.8)(2.73)(0.50) = 40.1\ \text{J}$, and $40.1 + 13.9 = 54\ \text{J}$.
    Why?
    The check closes the books: every joule of the starting K is accounted for.

Answer: (a) about 2.7 m along the incline (b) about 13.9 J

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Start: ½mv². End: mg d sin 30°. Friction loss: μk mg cos 30° d.
  2. Set start equal to the sum of the other two and solve for d.
  3. Thermal energy = $f_k$ times the distance slid.

Gravity far from Earth

For heights that aren't small compared with Earth's radius, use $U_g = -\frac{GMm}{r}$. The energy equation is the same, $\frac12 mv_i^2 - \frac{GMm}{r_i} = \frac12 mv_f^2 - \frac{GMm}{r_f}$. The most famous result: the escape speed, the launch speed that just barely lets an object get infinitely far away and stop there. Then $K_f = 0$ and $U_f = 0$, so

$$\tfrac12 mv_{esc}^2 - \frac{GMm}{R} = 0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad v_{esc} = \sqrt{\frac{2GM}{R}}$$

For Earth that's about 11.2 km/s, in any direction that misses the ground (ignoring air). If the total energy $K + U$ is negative, the object is bound and will come back down. If it's zero or positive, it escapes.

?Wait, why does total energy below zero mean "bound"?
Far away, $U \to 0$, and $K$ can never be negative. So to reach infinity the total energy must be at least zero. If $E = K + U < 0$, there's some distance where $U$ alone would equal $E$: a turning point. The object stops there and falls back. It's the same turning-point idea as on any U graph.
How high does it go?
A probe is launched straight up from Earth's surface at 5.0 km/s. Ignore air resistance and Earth's rotation. Use $GM = 3.99\times10^{14}\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}^2$ and $R = 6.37\times10^6\ \text{m}$. (a) How high above the surface does it rise? (b) Compare with the estimate from $mgh$.
  1. (a) Energy: $\frac12 mv^2 - \frac{GMm}{R} = 0 - \frac{GMm}{r}$, where $r$ is the top of the climb. The $m$ cancels: $\frac1r = \frac1R - \frac{v^2}{2GM}$.
    Why?
    At the highest point K = 0. Divide every term by m and by GM to isolate 1/r.
  2. $\frac1r = 1.570\times10^{-7} - \frac{(5.0\times10^3)^2}{2(3.99\times10^{14})} = 1.570\times10^{-7} - 3.13\times10^{-8} = 1.257\times10^{-7}\ \text{m}^{-1}$.
  3. $r = 7.96\times10^6\ \text{m}$, so the height is $r - R = 1.59\times10^6\ \text{m}$, about 1,590 km.
  4. (b) $mgh$ estimate: $h = \frac{v^2}{2g} = \frac{(5000)^2}{19.6} = 1.28\times10^6\ \text{m}$, about 1,280 km: 20 percent too low.
    Why?
    mgh assumes gravity stays at 9.8 m/s² all the way up. It actually weakens, so the probe climbs higher than the estimate.

Answer: (a) about 1,590 km (b) the mgh estimate, about 1,280 km, is too low because g weakens with height.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. At the top, K = 0. Write ½v² − GM/R = −GM/r.
  2. Solve for 1/r first, then flip it.
  3. Subtract Earth's radius to get the height.
MethodHeight reached at 5.0 km/sWhy
ΔU = mgΔhabout 1,280 kmAssumes g stays 9.8 m/s² all the way up
U = −GMm/rabout 1,590 kmGravity weakens with height, so it climbs farther
Differencemgh is about 20 percent lowmgh is only good for small heights
Same launch, two models. For big heights, only −GMm/r gets it right.
Pause and think
Why does $mgh$ work so well for a ball thrown in your backyard, if it's "wrong"?
I thought about it. Show me
Because over a few meters, $r$ barely changes, so $g$ is essentially constant. Expanding $-\frac{GMm}{R + h}$ for small $h$ gives $-\frac{GMm}{R} + mgh$: a constant plus $mgh$. Since only changes in $U$ matter, $mgh$ is the exact small-height version.
Check yourself
A planet has four times Earth's mass and the same radius. How does its escape speed compare with Earth's?
  1. AThe same
  2. BTwice as large
  3. CFour times as large
  4. DHalf as large
Show the answer

B. $v_{esc} = \sqrt{\frac{2GM}{R}}$, so four times the mass gives $\sqrt4 = 2$ times the escape speed. Choice C forgets the square root.

  • With friction: $K_i + U_i = K_f + U_f + f_kd$, with d the path length.
  • Far from Earth: $U_g = -\frac{GMm}{r}$. $mgh$ is its small-height version.
  • Escape speed $v_{esc} = \sqrt{\frac{2GM}{R}}$, from setting the total energy to zero.
  • E < 0: bound, it turns around. E ≥ 0: it escapes.