AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 3 lecture · Part 5 of 9 · 10 min

3.3 Force from potential energyReading a U(x) graph like a map

Mr. Thompkins
Flip the last section around. If $U$ comes from integrating $F$, then $F$ comes from differentiating $U$. That one idea lets you read a potential energy graph like a topographic map: where the slopes go, where things roll, and where they get trapped.

$$F_x = -\frac{dU}{dx}$$

The force is the negative slope of the $U(x)$ graph. Where $U$ slopes down to the right, the force points right. Where it slopes up, the force points left. In short: the force always points downhill on a $U$ graph, like a marble rolling on a curved track.

Equilibrium positions are where the force is zero, so $\frac{dU}{dx} = 0$: the flat spots. At the bottom of a valley (a minimum of $U$), a small push sends the particle back: stable equilibrium. At the top of a hill (a maximum), a small push sends it rolling away: unstable equilibrium.

?Wait, how do I tell a minimum from a maximum?
Use the second derivative. If $\frac{d^2U}{dx^2} > 0$ at a flat spot, the curve is concave up there: a valley, stable. If $\frac{d^2U}{dx^2} < 0$, it's concave down: a hilltop, unstable. Or simply look at the graph.
-3-2-101230246810x (m)U (J)E = 6 Jstableunstableunstableturnturn
U(x) = 4x² − ½x⁴. A valley at x = 0 (stable) and hilltops at x = ±2 m, where U = 8 J (unstable). A particle with E = 6 J (orange) is trapped between the turning points at ±1.41 m.

Now add the total energy. With only conservative forces, $E = K + U$ stays constant, so draw it as a flat horizontal line. At any position, the gap between the line and the curve is the kinetic energy, $K = E - U$. Since $K$ can't be negative, the particle can only be where the line is at or above the curve. Where they meet, $K = 0$: the particle stops for an instant and turns around. Those are the turning points.

?Wait, what's the difference between a turning point and an equilibrium point?
At a turning point the kinetic energy is zero, but the force usually isn't: the particle stops and gets pushed back. At an equilibrium point the force is zero, but the particle may be moving through it at top speed. Valley bottoms are where a trapped particle moves fastest.
Read the U(x) graph
A 0.50 kg particle moves along the x-axis with $U(x) = 4x^2 - \frac12 x^4$ (J, m), shown above. (a) Find the force on it at $x = 1.0\ \text{m}$. (b) Find and classify the equilibrium positions. (c) It has $E = 6.0\ \text{J}$ and is near $x = 0$. Find its speed at $x = 0$ and its turning points. (d) What changes if $E = 10\ \text{J}$?
  1. (a) $\frac{dU}{dx} = 8x - 2x^3$, so $F = -(8x - 2x^3)$. At $x = 1.0$: $F = -(8 - 2) = -6.0\ \text{N}$, pointing toward $-x$, back toward the origin.
    Why?
    Write F = −dU/dx before differentiating. The sign of the answer is the direction, and the minus sign in the definition is the part graders check.
  2. (b) $8x - 2x^3 = 2x(4 - x^2) = 0$ at $x = 0$ and $x = \pm2.0\ \text{m}$. $x = 0$ is a minimum of $U$ (stable). $x = \pm2.0\ \text{m}$ are maxima, $U = 8.0\ \text{J}$ (unstable).
    Why?
    Second-derivative check: d²U/dx² = 8 − 6x² is +8 at 0 and −16 at ±2.
  3. (c) At $x = 0$, $U = 0$, so $K = 6.0\ \text{J}$ and $v = \sqrt{\frac{2(6.0)}{0.50}} = 4.9\ \text{m/s}$.
    Why?
    The valley bottom is where U is lowest, so K and speed are greatest there.
  4. Turning points: $4x^2 - \frac12 x^4 = 6$, or $x^4 - 8x^2 + 12 = 0$, so $x^2 = 2$ or 6. Inside the well, $x = \pm1.41\ \text{m}$.
    Why?
    Treat it as a quadratic in x². The roots at ±2.45 m are outside the hills, on the far side, and this particle can never get there.
  5. (d) With $E = 10\ \text{J}$, the energy line is above both hilltops (8 J). The particle is no longer trapped: it passes over a hill with $K = 2\ \text{J}$ and moves off toward large $|x|$, where $U$ keeps dropping.
    Why?
    Compare E with the barrier height. Above it: free. Below it: trapped between turning points.

Answer: (a) −6.0 N (b) stable at 0; unstable at ±2.0 m (c) 4.9 m/s; turns at ±1.41 m (d) It escapes over a hilltop.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. F = −dU/dx: differentiate, then flip the sign.
  2. Equilibria: set 8x − 2x³ = 0. Valleys are stable.
  3. Turning points: set U(x) = E and solve the quadratic in x².
-3-2-10123-25-20-15-10-50510152025x (m)F (N)$F = -\frac{dU}{dx} = -8x + 2x^3$x = 1: F = −6 N
The force from that U(x). It crosses zero at the three equilibria, and near x = 0 it points back toward the origin, like a spring.
Pause and think
At the turning point $x = 1.41\ \text{m}$, the particle is momentarily at rest. Is the force on it zero there?
I thought about it. Show me
No. $F = -(8x - 2x^3) = -(11.3 - 5.7) = -5.7\ \text{N}$, pointing back toward the origin. That's exactly why it turns around. Zero speed is not zero force.
Check yourself
On a graph of U(x), at a point where the graph slopes upward to the right (positive slope), which way does the force on the particle point?
  1. A+x
  2. B−x
  3. CThere is no force there
  4. DIt depends on which way the particle moves
Show the answer

B. $F = -\frac{dU}{dx}$, so a positive slope gives a negative force, toward $-x$: downhill. Choice A forgets the minus sign. Choice D is the second trap: the force depends only on position, not on the direction of motion.

Exam tip from Mr. T

For a U(x) FRQ, mark the special points before you sketch or answer anything: the minima, the maxima, and where the energy line crosses the curve. Most parts of the question are about those points. And write $F = -\frac{dU}{dx}$ as your first line every time.

  • $F = -\frac{dU}{dx}$: the force points downhill on the U graph.
  • Equilibrium where dU/dx = 0. Minimum: stable. Maximum: unstable.
  • Draw E as a flat line. K = E − U is the gap. Turning points where U = E.
  • Turning point: K = 0, F usually not 0. Equilibrium: F = 0, K usually not 0.