8.3 Fluids and Newton's laws: the buoyant forceWhere the upward push comes from

Put a cube in water. The water pushes on all six faces. The four side forces cancel in pairs, because each pair is at the same depths. But the bottom face is deeper than the top face, so the pressure on the bottom is larger. The water pushes up on the bottom harder than it pushes down on the top. The difference is an upward net force from the fluid: the buoyant force, $F_b$.
?Wait, why don't I need atmospheric pressure here?
?Wait, what's the pressure at a depth again?
Work it out in symbols for a block of height $H$ and face area $A$, top at depth $d$. Force on the bottom minus force on the top: $F_b = \rho g(d + H)A - \rho gdA = \rho gHA$. But $HA$ is the block's volume, which is exactly the volume of water it pushes aside. So $F_b = \rho_{fluid}V_{disp}g$. In words: the buoyant force equals the weight of the fluid the object displaces. That's Archimedes' principle.
Look at what's in that formula and what isn't. The density is the fluid's, not the object's. The volume is the displaced volume: the part of the object that's under the surface. And the depth $d$ cancelled out, so once an object is completely under, the buoyant force is the same at any depth. (Real water compresses a tiny bit at great depth, but the ideal fluid doesn't.)
I thought about it. Show me
- (a) Face area: $A = (0.20)^2 = 0.040\ \text{m}^2$. Top, at 0.30 m: $P = (1000)(9.8)(0.30) = 2940\ \text{Pa}$, so $F = (2940)(0.040) = 118\ \text{N}$ down.
- Bottom, at 0.50 m: $P = (1000)(9.8)(0.50) = 4900\ \text{Pa}$, so $F = (4900)(0.040) = 196\ \text{N}$ up.
- (b) The side forces cancel. Net: $196 - 118 = 78.4\ \text{N}$ up.
Why?
The buoyant force is not an extra force on top of the pressure forces. It IS the net pressure force. - (c) $\rho_{fluid}V_{disp}g = (1000)(0.20)^3(9.8) = (1000)(0.0080)(9.8) = 78.4\ \text{N}$. Same answer.
- (d) $F_b = (1000)(1.2 \times 10^{-3})(9.8) = 11.8\ \text{N}$ up, but the weight is $(3.0)(9.8) = 29.4\ \text{N}$ down. The net force is down, so it sinks.
Why?
Compare the forces with Newton's second law. Or compare densities: 3.0 / 0.0012 = 2500 kg/m³, more than water.
Answer: (a) 118 N down on the top, 196 N up on the bottom. (b) 78.4 N up. (c) $\rho Vg = 78.4$ N, the same. (d) It sinks: 11.8 N up is less than 29.4 N down.
Stuck? Get a hint
- Find the depth of each face and use $P = \rho gh$, then $F = PA$.
- Subtract the top force from the bottom force.
- $V_{disp}$ is the whole cube's volume, since it's fully under.
- A4.9 N
- B2.0 N
- C0.20 N
- D9.8 N
Show the answer
B. $F_b = \rho_{fluid}V_{disp}g = (1000)(2.0 \times 10^{-4})(9.8) = 1.96 \approx 2.0\ \text{N}$. 4.9 N is the object's weight, the trap of mixing up the object with the fluid it displaces.
- Buoyant force: the net upward push of the fluid, because the bottom is deeper than the top.
- $F_b = \rho_{fluid}V_{disp}g$: the weight of the displaced fluid (Archimedes' principle).
- Use the fluid's density and the submerged volume.
- Once fully submerged, $F_b$ does not change with depth. A sinking object still feels a buoyant force.