AP Physics 1 · Unit 8 lecture · Part 5 of 11 · 9 min

8.3 Fluids and Newton's laws: floating and sinkingFloat, sink, or pop up

Mr. Thompkins
Now for the payoff: the buoyant force is just a force. Draw it on a free-body diagram next to gravity and use Newton's laws exactly the way you did in Unit 2. Every floating and sinking question becomes a force-balance question.
?Wait, what's Newton's second law in a form I can use?
$F_{net} = ma$: add the forces with signs (pick up as positive, say), and set the sum equal to mass times acceleration. If the object is at rest or floating steadily, $a = 0$ and the forces balance.

A floating object is at rest at the surface, so it's in equilibrium: the buoyant force exactly balances its weight. It sinks just deep enough to displace its own weight of fluid. That gives you a beautiful result. With $F_b = mg$: $\rho_{fluid}V_{sub}g = \rho_{obj}V_{obj}g$, so $\frac{V_{sub}}{V_{obj}} = \frac{\rho_{obj}}{\rho_{fluid}}$. The fraction of a floating object that's under the surface equals its density divided by the fluid's.

$F_b$$mg$
Floating at rest: the buoyant force balances the weight.
$F_b$$F_{hand}$$mg$$F_b = 19.6$ N$F_{hand} = 6.9$ N$mg = 12.7$ Nup = down:$F_b = mg + F_{hand}$
The wood block held fully under by a hand: the buoyant force balances the weight plus the push.

That's also the proof of the floating rule from Section 1. If the object's density is less than the fluid's, the fraction is less than 1: it can find a waterline where the forces balance. If its density is greater, even fully submerged it can't displace enough fluid to hold itself up, so it sinks. Ice is 917 kg/m³, so in fresh water about 92% of an iceberg is under the surface, and in seawater about 89%.

?Wait, what makes an object speed up from rest?
A nonzero net force. Released from rest, an object accelerates in the direction of the net force, with $a = \frac{F_{net}}{m}$. Equal and opposite forces mean no acceleration.

Push a floating object all the way under and you're adding a third force. Now the displaced volume is the whole object, so the buoyant force is bigger than the weight, and you supply the difference: $F_{hand} = F_b - mg$. Let go, and the net upward force makes it accelerate up (until drag and the surface take over).

Pause and think
A block floats in fresh water. It's moved to salt water, which is denser. Does it float higher or lower? Does the buoyant force on it change?
I thought about it. Show me
It floats higher, with less of it under the surface, because the fraction submerged is $\frac{\rho_{obj}}{\rho_{fluid}}$ and the fluid is denser. The buoyant force does not change: floating means it equals the weight, and the weight hasn't changed. Denser fluid, same force, less volume needed.
A wooden block, three ways
A wooden block has a density of 650 kg/m³ and a volume of $2.0 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3$. (a) It floats in fresh water. What volume is submerged? (b) How hard must a hand push down to hold it completely under? (c) If the hand lets go, what is the block's initial acceleration? Ignore drag.
  1. Mass: $m = \rho V = (650)(2.0 \times 10^{-3}) = 1.30\ \text{kg}$. Weight: $(1.30)(9.8) = 12.7\ \text{N}$.
  2. (a) Floating: $F_b = mg$, so $V_{sub} = \frac{\rho_{obj}}{\rho_{fluid}}V = (0.65)(2.0 \times 10^{-3}) = 1.3 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3$: 65% of the block.
    Why?
    Start from the force balance in symbols; the density ratio drops right out of it.
  3. (b) Fully under: $F_b = (1000)(2.0 \times 10^{-3})(9.8) = 19.6\ \text{N}$. Up equals down: $F_b = mg + F_{hand}$, so $F_{hand} = 19.6 - 12.7 = 6.9\ \text{N}$.
  4. (c) Without the hand: $F_{net} = 19.6 - 12.7 = 6.9\ \text{N}$ up, so $a = \frac{6.9}{1.30} = 5.3\ \text{m/s}^2$ up.
    Why?
    In symbols, $a = g\left(\frac{\rho_{fluid}}{\rho_{obj}} - 1\right)$: a check you can do in your head. Real water adds drag, so the real acceleration drops quickly.

Answer: (a) $1.3 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3$ (65%). (b) About 6.9 N. (c) About 5.3 m/s² upward at the instant of release.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Find the block's mass and weight from its density and volume.
  2. Floating: buoyant force = weight. Fully held under: buoyant force = weight + push.
  3. After release, the push is gone: $a = \frac{F_b - mg}{m}$.
Check yourself
A block floats in water with 40% of its volume above the surface. What is its density?
  1. A$400\ \text{kg/m}^3$
  2. B$600\ \text{kg/m}^3$
  3. C$1400\ \text{kg/m}^3$
  4. D$1667\ \text{kg/m}^3$
Show the answer

B. 40% above means 60% below, and the fraction submerged equals $\frac{\rho_{obj}}{\rho_{water}}$, so $\rho = 0.60 \times 1000 = 600\ \text{kg/m}^3$. Choosing 400 uses the part above the water instead of the part below.

  • Floating at rest: $F_b = mg$. Fraction submerged $= \frac{\rho_{obj}}{\rho_{fluid}}$.
  • Held under: $F_b = mg + F_{hand}$. Released: $a = (F_b - mg)/m$.
  • Denser fluid: a floating object rides higher, with the same buoyant force.
  • Every buoyancy problem: free-body diagram first, then Newton's second law.