8.3 Fluids and Newton's laws: scales and stringsApparent weight and the third law

Hang a dense object from a string and lower it until it's fully under water but not touching the bottom. It's at rest, so the upward forces (tension and buoyancy) balance the downward one (weight): $F_T + F_b = mg$. The string tension, which is what a spring scale reads, is $F_T = mg - F_b$. That's the apparent weight: the rock seems lighter by exactly the buoyant force.
?Wait, what does Newton's third law say?
?Wait, what does a spring scale actually read?
Now the beaker. The water pushes up on the rock with $F_b$. By Newton's third law, the rock pushes down on the water with a force of the same size, $F_b$. That push is passed through the water to the beaker and the scale under it. So the bottom scale reading goes up by exactly $F_b$, while the spring scale reading goes down by $F_b$. The two changes are equal and opposite, which makes sense: together the two scales are still holding up the rock, beaker and water.
I thought about it. Show me
- (a) In air: $F_T = mg = (2.0)(9.8) = 19.6\ \text{N}$. The bottom scale reads the beaker and water: $(1.5)(9.8) = 14.7\ \text{N}$.
- (b) The rock's volume: $V = \frac{m}{\rho} = \frac{2.0}{2500} = 8.0 \times 10^{-4}\ \text{m}^3$. Buoyant force: $F_b = (1000)(8.0 \times 10^{-4})(9.8) = 7.8\ \text{N}$.
- Spring scale: $F_T = mg - F_b = 19.6 - 7.8 = 11.8\ \text{N}$. Bottom scale: $14.7 + 7.8 = 22.5\ \text{N}$.
Why?
Newton's third law: the rock pushes down on the water with 7.8 N. Check: 11.8 + 22.5 = 34.3 N, which is the total weight of rock, beaker and water. - (c) Now the bottom scale supports everything: $14.7 + 19.6 = 34.3\ \text{N}$.
Answer: (a) Spring scale 19.6 N (bottom scale 14.7 N). (b) Spring scale 11.8 N, bottom scale 22.5 N. (c) 34.3 N.
Stuck? Get a hint
- Find the rock's volume from its mass and density, then the buoyant force.
- Spring scale = weight − buoyant force.
- Bottom scale goes up by the buoyant force (third law), until the rock rests on the bottom.
- A$1000\ \text{kg/m}^3$
- B$1333\ \text{kg/m}^3$
- C$3000\ \text{kg/m}^3$
- D$4000\ \text{kg/m}^3$
Show the answer
D. The buoyant force is the drop in the reading: $39.2 - 29.4 = 9.8\ \text{N}$. So $V = \frac{F_b}{\rho_w g} = \frac{9.8}{(1000)(9.8)} = 1.0 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3$, and $\rho = \frac{4.0}{1.0 \times 10^{-3}} = 4000\ \text{kg/m}^3$. 1333 comes from dividing the mass by the wrong volume, using the underwater reading as if it were the buoyant force.
- Astays the same, because your finger doesn't touch the beaker
- Bincreases by the weight of the water your finger displaces
- Cdecreases, because the water pushes your finger up
- Dincreases by the weight of your whole hand
Show the answer
B. The water pushes up on your finger with a buoyant force equal to the weight of the water displaced. By Newton's third law, your finger pushes down on the water with the same force, and the scale feels it. "It doesn't touch the beaker" is the trap: the finger touches the water, and the water presses on the beaker.

For any scale question, draw a separate free-body diagram for each object (the hanging object, then the beaker plus water), and connect them with a third-law pair. Say in words: "the water exerts an upward buoyant force on the rock, so the rock exerts an equal downward force on the water."
- Hanging fully under: $F_T = mg - F_b$ (apparent weight).
- Newton's third law: the object pushes down on the fluid with $F_b$, so the scale under the container reads more by $F_b$.
- Resting on the bottom: the bottom scale carries the object's full weight.
- Buoyant force from data: the drop in the spring scale reading. Then $V = \frac{F_b}{\rho_{fluid}g}$.