AP Physics 1 · Unit 7 lecture · Part 9 of 11 · 8 min

7.4 Energy of simple harmonic oscillators: over timeEnergy graphs, pendulums and friction

Mr. Thompkins
Same energy story, three new angles: what the energy looks like against time, how it works when gravity is the spring, and what happens when friction sneaks in.

Plot the spring energy and the kinetic energy of the oscillator from Section 8 against time. Both curves stay between 0 and 0.60 J, and they're mirror images: when one is full, the other is empty, and at every instant they add up to the flat total line. Both reach their peaks twice per period, because the block is at an end twice per cycle (once at $+A$, once at $-A$) and at equilibrium twice per cycle (once moving each way).

00.250.50.7511.251.51.75200.10.20.30.40.50.60.7t ÷ Tenergy (J)E$U_s$$K$
Spring energy and kinetic energy against time, in units of the period. Each peaks twice per period, they are never negative, and they always add to 0.60 J.
Pause and think
An oscillator has a period of 2.0 s. How much time passes between one moment of maximum kinetic energy and the next?
I thought about it. Show me
1.0 s. Kinetic energy is largest at every pass through equilibrium, and there are two passes per period. So the energy graphs repeat with half the period of the position graph.

When gravity is the spring

?Wait, how high does a pendulum bob rise?
A bob on a string of length $L$ pulled to angle θ from vertical rises a height $h = L - L\cos\theta = L(1 - \cos\theta)$ above its lowest point. Draw the right triangle: the vertical leg below the pivot is $L\cos\theta$, which is shorter than $L$ by exactly $h$.

For a pendulum, the system is the bob plus Earth, and the potential energy is gravitational: $U_g = mgh$, measured from the bottom of the swing. At the ends, the bob is momentarily at rest at its highest point: all the energy is $U_g$. At the bottom, it's moving fastest: all kinetic. The tension does no work, because it's always perpendicular to the bob's motion. So $mgh = \tfrac12 mv_{max}^2$, and the mass cancels: $v_{max} = \sqrt{2gh}$.

A pendulum's top speed
A pendulum 1.5 m long is pulled 12° from vertical and released from rest. (a) How high above the bottom of its swing is the bob at release? (b) How fast is it moving at the bottom? (c) Would a heavier bob be faster at the bottom?
  1. (a) $h = L(1 - \cos\theta) = 1.5(1 - \cos 12°) = 1.5(1 - 0.978) = 0.033\ \text{m}$, about 3.3 cm.
    Why?
    Here the angle goes into a cosine, so degree mode is fine as long as your calculator agrees with the unit you type. Only formulas like s = Lθ and 2πft need radians.
  2. (b) Energy is conserved for the bob-Earth system (tension does no work): $mgh = \tfrac12 mv^2$, so $v = \sqrt{2gh} = \sqrt{2(9.8)(0.0328)} = 0.80\ \text{m/s}$.
  3. (c) No. The mass cancels from $mgh = \tfrac12 mv^2$. A heavier bob has more energy, but it also needs more energy for each m/s.

Answer: (a) About 0.033 m. (b) About 0.80 m/s. (c) No, the speed at the bottom does not depend on the mass.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Draw the triangle: the bob is $L\cos\theta$ below the pivot when pulled aside, and $L$ below it at the bottom.
  2. Set the gravitational energy at release equal to the kinetic energy at the bottom.
  3. Cancel m and solve for v.

A vertical spring has both kinds of potential energy at once: spring energy and gravitational energy. The exam usually keeps vertical-spring energy questions simple, and you can always write the full equation, $K + U_s + U_g = \text{constant}$, with $x$ measured from the spring's natural length. Beyond the course, as a bonus: if you measure position from the new equilibrium instead, the two potential energies combine into a single $\tfrac12 ky^2$ (plus a constant), which is why the vertical oscillator behaves exactly like a horizontal one.

When friction joins in

Real oscillators slow down. Friction or air drag does negative work on the system, and mechanical energy turns into thermal energy. With less energy, $\tfrac12 kA^2$ is smaller, so the amplitude shrinks swing by swing. For a little friction, the period barely changes, because the period depends on $m$ and $k$, not on the amplitude.

0123456-0.12-0.08-0.0400.040.080.12t (s)x (m)peaks still 1.0 s apart
Beyond the course, as a bonus: a lightly damped oscillator. The amplitude (gray envelope) shrinks as energy is lost, but the peaks stay 1.0 s apart.
?Wait, where does the "lost" energy go?
It isn't destroyed. Friction converts mechanical energy into internal (thermal) energy of the surfaces and the air. If you include those in your system, total energy is conserved. Mechanical energy alone is not.
Check yourself
A cart on a spring oscillates on a track with a small amount of friction. Over many cycles, which is true?
  1. AThe amplitude decreases, and the period stays about the same.
  2. BThe amplitude stays the same, and the period decreases.
  3. CBoth the amplitude and the period decrease in proportion.
  4. DThe amplitude decreases, and the frequency drops to zero.
Show the answer

A. Friction removes mechanical energy, and since $E = \tfrac12 kA^2$, less energy means a smaller amplitude. The period depends on $m$ and $k$, not on $A$, so it stays about the same. Expecting the period to shrink with the amplitude is the amplitude trap in disguise.

Check yourself
On a graph of kinetic energy against time for a mass-spring oscillator, the kinetic energy peaks every 0.30 s. What is the period of the oscillation?
  1. A0.15 s
  2. B0.30 s
  3. C0.60 s
  4. D1.2 s
Show the answer

C. Kinetic energy peaks twice per period (once per pass through equilibrium in each direction), so the period is $2 \times 0.30 = 0.60\ \text{s}$. Picking 0.30 s treats the energy graph as if it repeated with the same period as the position graph.

  • Energy against time: K and U are never negative, mirror each other, sum to a constant, and peak twice per period.
  • Pendulum: $U_g = mgh$ with $h = L(1 - \cos\theta)$. At the bottom $v_{max} = \sqrt{2gh}$, independent of mass. Tension does no work.
  • Vertical spring: include both spring and gravitational energy.
  • Friction: energy leaves, the amplitude shrinks, the period stays about the same.