AP Physics 1 · Unit 6 lecture · Part 7 of 11 · 9 min

6.5 Rolling without slippingRacing down the ramp

Mr. Thompkins
Here's a race you can run at home: a solid ball, a soup can and a ring, all released together at the top of the same ramp. Which wins? Mass doesn't matter, radius doesn't matter. Only the shape does. Let's see why.

A wheel rolls without slipping when its contact point with the ground doesn't skid. Each turn, the wheel moves forward exactly one circumference. That ties its forward motion to its spin: $v_{cm} = R\omega$ and $a_{cm} = R\alpha$. At any instant the contact point is at rest, the center moves at $v$, and the top moves at $2v$.

$v$$2v$contact point: speed 0$v_{cm} = R\omega$no slipping
A wheel rolling without slipping. The contact point is momentarily at rest, the center moves at v, and the top moves at 2v.
?Wait, how does static friction fit in?
Static friction acts where surfaces touch without sliding. For a rolling object on a ramp, static friction at the contact point supplies the torque that makes the object spin. Because the contact point doesn't slide, static friction does no work: it takes no energy out.

So for an object rolling without slipping down a ramp, mechanical energy is conserved. But the gravitational energy now splits into two kinds of kinetic energy: $Mgh = \tfrac12Mv^2 + \tfrac12I\omega^2$. Write $I = \beta MR^2$ ($\beta$ is $\tfrac25$ for a solid sphere, $\tfrac12$ for a solid cylinder, 1 for a hoop) and $\omega = v/R$: $Mgh = \tfrac12Mv^2(1 + \beta)$, so $v = \sqrt{\dfrac{2gh}{1 + \beta}}$. Mass and radius cancel. Only $\beta$, the shape, matters.

Object (mass M, radius R)ISpeed after a drop hShare of K that is spin
Block sliding, no frictionno spin√(2gh) = 1.41√(gh)0
Solid sphere⅖MR²√(10gh/7) = 1.20√(gh)2/7 (29%)
Solid cylinder or disk½MR²√(4gh/3) = 1.15√(gh)1/3 (33%)
Thin hoopMR²√(gh) = 1.00√(gh)1/2 (50%)
The rolling race. The smaller the share of energy that goes into spin, the faster the object. Sphere, then cylinder, then hoop.
?Wait, what was $v = \sqrt{2gh}$ for?
It's the speed of something that drops a height $h$ with all of its gravitational energy turning into translational kinetic energy: a free-falling ball or a block sliding down a frictionless ramp. A rolling object is slower, because some energy goes into spin.
Mathematical routine: a rolling sphere
A 3.0 kg solid sphere ($I = \tfrac25MR^2$) rolls without slipping from rest down a ramp, dropping 1.4 m vertically. (a) Derive an expression for its speed at the bottom. (b) Calculate it. (c) How much of its kinetic energy is rotational?
  1. (a) System: sphere + Earth. Static friction does no work and there's no air resistance, so mechanical energy is conserved: $Mgh = \tfrac12Mv^2 + \tfrac12I\omega^2$.
    Why?
    Name the system and say why energy is conserved. Then write the equation in symbols.
  2. Rolling without slipping: $\omega = v/R$. So $\tfrac12\left(\tfrac25MR^2\right)\dfrac{v^2}{R^2} = \tfrac15Mv^2$, and $Mgh = \tfrac12Mv^2 + \tfrac15Mv^2 = \tfrac{7}{10}Mv^2$.
  3. Solve: $v = \sqrt{\dfrac{10gh}{7}}$.
    Why?
    Mass and radius cancel. Any solid sphere reaches the bottom at this speed.
  4. (b) $v = \sqrt{\dfrac{10(9.8)(1.4)}{7}} = \sqrt{19.6} = 4.4$ m/s.
  5. (c) Total kinetic energy at the bottom: $Mgh = (3.0)(9.8)(1.4) = 41.2$ J. Translational: $\tfrac12(3.0)(4.43)^2 = 29.4$ J. Rotational: $\tfrac15(3.0)(4.43)^2 = 11.8$ J, which is $\tfrac27$ of the total.

Answer: (a) $v = \sqrt{10gh/7}$. (b) About 4.4 m/s. (c) 11.8 J of the 41.2 J (2/7) is rotational.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Energy: Mgh = translational KE + rotational KE.
  2. Replace $\omega$ with $v/R$ and $I$ with $\tfrac25MR^2$.
  3. $\tfrac12 + \tfrac15 = \tfrac{7}{10}$.
Top41.2$U_g$$K_{trans}$$K_{rot}$Halfway down20.6$U_g$14.7$K_{trans}$5.9$K_{rot}$Bottom$U_g$29.4$K_{trans}$11.8$K_{rot}$
Energy bar charts for the rolling sphere, in joules. At every point, 5/7 of the kinetic energy is translational and 2/7 is rotational.
Pause and think
A solid sphere and a hollow sphere of the same mass and radius race down a ramp, rolling without slipping. Which wins, and why?
I thought about it. Show me
The solid sphere. The hollow one has its mass farther from the center, so a larger $I$ ($\tfrac23MR^2$, beyond the course as a bonus). More of its energy goes into spinning and less into moving forward, so it's slower at every point.
Check yourself
A solid cylinder and a hoop roll without slipping down the same ramp from rest. The hoop has twice the mass of the cylinder and a larger radius. Which reaches the bottom first?
  1. AThe hoop, because it's heavier.
  2. BThe cylinder, because a smaller fraction of its energy goes into rotation.
  3. CThey tie, because they start at the same height.
  4. DThe hoop, because its larger radius covers more ground per turn.
Show the answer

B. Speed depends only on the shape factor: $v = \sqrt{2gh/(1 + \beta)}$, with $\beta = \tfrac12$ for the cylinder and 1 for the hoop. Mass and radius cancel. They'd tie only if both slid without friction.

  • Rolling without slipping: $v_{cm} = R\omega$, $a_{cm} = R\alpha$. Contact point at rest, top at 2v.
  • Total kinetic energy: $K = \tfrac12Mv^2 + \tfrac12I\omega^2$.
  • Static friction makes it roll but does no work, so mechanical energy is conserved.
  • Down a ramp, only the shape matters: sphere beats cylinder beats hoop.