6.4 Collisions with rotating objectsWhen the axle steals your momentum

Picture a child running along a line that just grazes the rim of a merry-go-round at rest, then jumping on. During the landing, the merry-go-round's axle holds it in place: the axle pushes on the merry-go-round with a large external force. So linear momentum of the child + merry-go-round system is not conserved. But the axle force acts at the axis, so it makes no torque about the axis. Angular momentum about the axle is conserved.
?Wait, why does the axle force make no torque?
?Wait, what's the rotational inertia of the child on the rim?
- System: child + merry-go-round. Axis: the axle. The axle force acts at the axis and the vertical forces are parallel to it, so the net external torque about the axle is zero and $L$ is conserved.
- Before: the child's $L = mvr_\perp = (40)(4.0)(1.5) = 240$ kg·m²/s. The disk's is zero.
Why?
The child's line of motion is tangent to the rim, so r⊥ is the radius. - After: $I = \tfrac12(200)(1.5)^2 + (40)(1.5)^2 = 225 + 90 = 315$ kg·m². $\omega = \dfrac{240}{315} = 0.76$ rad/s.
- (b) $K_{before} = \tfrac12(40)(4.0)^2 = 320$ J. $K_{after} = \tfrac12(315)(0.762)^2 = 91$ J. About 229 J is lost, to internal energy, as in any sticking collision.
Why?
A child landing and sticking is a perfectly inelastic rotational collision. - (c) Before: $p = (40)(4.0) = 160$ kg·m/s. After: the disk's center doesn't move, so its momentum is zero, and the child moves at $(0.762)(1.5) = 1.14$ m/s, so $p = 46$ kg·m/s. Not equal: the axle supplied an external impulse.
Answer: (a) About 0.76 rad/s. (b) About 229 J lost. (c) 160 kg·m/s before vs 46 kg·m/s after: the axle's impulse changed it.
Stuck? Get a hint
- Use angular momentum about the axle; the axle force has no torque.
- Child's $L = mvR$ with $R = 1.5$ m.
- Total $I$ after: $\tfrac12MR^2 + mR^2$.
I thought about it. Show me
- A0.33 rad/s
- B1.4 rad/s
- C1.7 rad/s
- D2.8 rad/s
Show the answer
B. $L = mvr_\perp = (0.050)(6.0)(0.60) = 0.18$ kg·m²/s. After: $I = 0.108 + (0.050)(0.60)^2 = 0.126$ kg·m², so $\omega = 0.18/0.126 = 1.4$ rad/s. 1.7 rad/s forgets to add the clay's own rotational inertia. Linear momentum would be the wrong tool: the pin exerts an external force.

If an object is pinned, on an axle or hinged, linear momentum is not conserved in the collision. Say so, and switch to angular momentum about the pin. That one sentence is often a scoring point.
- A pin or axle exerts an external force, so linear momentum isn't conserved, but that force has no torque about the pin, so angular momentum is.
- A point mass's angular momentum before the collision is $mvr_\perp$; after sticking, add its $mr^2$ to the total $I$.
- Sticking rotational collisions lose kinetic energy, just like perfectly inelastic linear ones.