6.4 Conservation of angular momentumThe figure skater, explained

If the net external torque on a system is zero, its angular momentum doesn't change: $\Delta L = \tau\Delta t = 0$. That's conservation of angular momentum. For a system whose rotational inertia can change, it means $I_1\omega_1 = I_2\omega_2$: if $I$ goes down, $\omega$ goes up by the same factor.
?Wait, how did pulling in her arms change $I$?
Numbers: a student on a spinning stool holds two weights. Arms out, $I = 2.4$ kg·m² and $\omega = 3.0$ rad/s, so $L = 7.2$ kg·m²/s. She pulls them in to $I = 0.80$ kg·m². The stool's bearing is frictionless and gravity and the floor act along the axis, so there's no external torque about the axis: $\omega_2 = \dfrac{(2.4)(3.0)}{0.80} = 9.0$ rad/s.
Now the energy. Before: $\tfrac12(2.4)(3.0)^2 = 10.8$ J. After: $\tfrac12(0.80)(9.0)^2 = 32.4$ J. Kinetic energy tripled. That's not a mistake: her arm muscles pulled the weights inward against their tendency to fly outward, and that work, 21.6 J, came from chemical energy in her body. Angular momentum is conserved; kinetic energy is not.
?Wait, can $K$ be written with $L$?
I thought about it. Show me
- (a) In the air the only external force is gravity, which acts at her center of mass. A force through the axis makes no torque, so the net external torque about her center of mass is zero and $L$ is conserved.
Why?
The justification names the force and why its torque is zero. That's the scoring point. - (b) $I_1\omega_1 = I_2\omega_2$: $\omega_2 = \dfrac{(12)(2.0)}{3.5} = 6.9$ rad/s.
- (c) Tucking brings her mass closer to the axis, lowering $I$. With $L$ fixed, $\omega$ must rise, so she turns through more angle in the same time in the air.
Why?
Claim, principle, and what changes versus what stays fixed: that's the paragraph graders want.
Answer: (a) Gravity acts at her center of mass, so no external torque. (b) About 6.9 rad/s. (c) Smaller I, same L, larger ω, more rotation per second.
Stuck? Get a hint
- What external force acts in the air, and where does it act?
- $\omega_2 = I_1\omega_1 / I_2$.
- Fixed L, smaller I: what must ω do?
- AHer angular momentum and kinetic energy both stay the same.
- BHer angular momentum stays the same and her kinetic energy increases.
- CHer angular momentum increases and her kinetic energy stays the same.
- DHer angular velocity decreases because her rotational inertia decreases.
Show the answer
B. No external torque about the axis, so $L$ is constant. $K = L^2/2I$ rises as $I$ falls, because her muscles do positive work. The first choice is the classic trap: assuming energy is conserved just because momentum is.

Every "conserved" claim on an FRQ needs its reason: "angular momentum of the system is conserved because the net external torque about the axis is zero." For orbits, add "because gravity points toward the planet's center, so it exerts no torque about that point."
- No net external torque: $L$ is constant, so $I_1\omega_1 = I_2\omega_2$.
- Pull mass inward: I down, ω up.
- $K_{rot} = L^2/2I$: with L fixed, kinetic energy rises when I falls (work done by internal forces, like muscles).
- Forces that act through the axis, like gravity at the center of mass, make no torque.