AP Physics 1 · Unit 5 lecture · Part 10 of 11 · 9 min

5.6 Pulleys with mass and linked systemsWhen the pulley fights back

Mr. Thompkins
In Unit 2 your pulleys were massless, so the tension was the same on both sides. Real pulleys have mass. To spin one up you need a net torque, which means the tensions on its two sides can't be equal. This is the problem where rotation and Unit 2 shake hands.

The method: write $\Sigma F = ma$ for each block, $\Sigma\tau = I\alpha$ for the pulley, and link them with $a = R\alpha$ (the cord doesn't slip on the pulley). Three equations, three unknowns: usually $a$, $\alpha$ and the tension.

0.20 m2.0 kg$F_T$ on disk$a$$\alpha$disk: 3.0 kg$I = \tfrac12MR^2$
A 2.0 kg block hangs from a cord wrapped around a 3.0 kg disk pulley of radius 0.20 m. As the block falls, the cord turns the pulley.
$F_g$ = 19.6 N$F_T$ = 8.4 N
Free-body diagram of the falling block. Gravity is bigger than the tension, so the block accelerates down.
?Wait, why is the tension smaller than the block's weight here?
The block accelerates downward, so the net force on it must point down: $mg - F_T = ma$. If the tension equaled the weight, the net force would be zero and the block wouldn't accelerate. Tension equals weight only when the block hangs still or moves at constant velocity.
Mathematical routine: block on a massive pulley
For the block and pulley shown, with the pulley a uniform disk on a frictionless axle: (a) derive an expression for the block's acceleration; (b) calculate the acceleration, the tension and the pulley's angular acceleration.
  1. Block, down positive: $mg - F_T = ma$.
    Why?
    Choose positive the way the block accelerates, so a comes out positive.
  2. Pulley, about its axle: only the tension makes torque (the axle force and the pulley's weight act at the axis). $F_TR = I\alpha = \tfrac12MR^2\alpha$.
  3. Link: the cord doesn't slip, so $a = R\alpha$. Then $F_TR = \tfrac12MR^2(a/R)$, so $F_T = \tfrac12Ma$.
    Why?
    The radius cancels: the pulley acts like an extra mass of M/2 that has to be accelerated.
  4. (a) Substitute into the block's equation: $mg - \tfrac12Ma = ma$, so $a = \dfrac{mg}{m + \tfrac12M}$.
    Why?
    Check limits: if M = 0 (massless pulley), a = g, which is right for a block on a cord with nothing resisting. A heavy pulley makes a small.
  5. (b) $a = \dfrac{(2.0)(9.8)}{2.0 + 1.5} = 5.6$ m/s². $F_T = \tfrac12(3.0)(5.6) = 8.4$ N. $\alpha = a/R = 5.6/0.20 = 28$ rad/s².
    Why?
    Check: m(g − a) = 2.0(9.8 − 5.6) = 8.4 N, the same tension.

Answer: (a) $a = \dfrac{mg}{m + \tfrac12M}$. (b) 5.6 m/s², 8.4 N, 28 rad/s².

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Three equations: block (forces), pulley (torques), and the link a = Rα.
  2. For the disk, $F_TR = \tfrac12MR^2\alpha$, which simplifies to $F_T = \tfrac12Ma$.
  3. Then $mg - \tfrac12Ma = ma$.
?Wait, what's an Atwood machine?
Two masses hang on either side of a pulley from one cord. The heavier side goes down and the lighter side goes up, with the same size of acceleration. In Unit 2 the pulley was massless and the tension was the same on both sides.

Now put two blocks on a massive pulley, one on each side. If the heavier block is on the right, the pulley speeds up clockwise, so the net torque on it must be clockwise: the tension on the right side has to be bigger than the tension on the left. The tensions differ by exactly enough to spin the pulley up: $(F_{T,right} - F_{T,left})R = I\alpha$. With a massless pulley, $I = 0$ and the tensions are equal again, which is why Unit 2 could treat them as one.

Pause and think
In an Atwood machine with a massive pulley, the system is released from rest. Will the blocks accelerate faster, slower, or the same as with a massless pulley?
I thought about it. Show me
Slower. The same weight difference now has to accelerate the blocks and spin up the pulley, which acts like extra mass ($\tfrac12M$ for a disk) to be accelerated.
Check yourself
A block hangs from a cord wrapped around a pulley that is a uniform disk. The block is released from rest. Compared with the block's weight, the cord's tension is
  1. Aequal, because the cord holds the block up
  2. Blarger, because the cord also turns the pulley
  3. Csmaller, because the block accelerates downward
  4. Dzero, because the block is in free fall
Show the answer

C. The block accelerates downward, so the net force on it points down and $F_T < mg$. It isn't zero, because the cord is spinning up the pulley, which takes a torque. "Equal" would mean no acceleration.

Check yourself
In an Atwood machine with a massive pulley, the heavier block is on the right. Which is true about the tensions?
  1. AThey are equal on both sides.
  2. BThe right-side tension is larger.
  3. CThe left-side tension is larger.
  4. DBoth tensions equal the weight of the heavier block.
Show the answer

B. The pulley accelerates clockwise (right side down), so the net torque is clockwise and the right-side tension must be larger. Equal tensions would mean zero net torque, possible only for a massless pulley or no angular acceleration.

Exam tip from Mr. T

For a system of blocks and a massive pulley, always write three things on your page: one $\Sigma F = ma$ per block, one $\Sigma\tau = I\alpha$ for the pulley, and $a = R\alpha$. Each is usually a rubric point, and the derivation follows almost automatically.

  • Massive pulley: tensions on the two sides differ, and the difference provides the net torque.
  • Equations: ΣF = ma for each block, Στ = Iα for the pulley, a = Rα to link them.
  • A disk pulley acts like an extra ½M of mass to be accelerated.
  • Check limits: M → 0 gives back the Unit 2 answer.