AP Physics 1 · Unit 5 lecture · Part 8 of 11 · 10 min

5.5 Static equilibrium of beams and signsPick the axis that kills an unknown

Mr. Thompkins
Here's the secret of statics problems: an object at rest has zero net torque about every axis, not just the obvious one. So you get to choose the axis. Choose it where an unknown force acts, and that unknown vanishes from your equation.

The routine: draw a force diagram, choose an axis at the point where an unknown force you don't need acts, write $\Sigma\tau = 0$ about that axis, and then use $\Sigma F = 0$ for anything left over. One clever axis often solves the problem in one line.

The statics routine

  1. Draw the extended object and every force where it acts: weights at centers, supports where they touch, cables along the cable.
  2. Choose the axis at the point of an unknown force (often a hinge or a support).
  3. Write Στ = 0 about that axis, with a sign for each torque.
  4. Use ΣF = 0 (vertical and horizontal) for the remaining unknowns.
  5. Check: are the support forces positive? A negative support push means the object would tip.
$F_1$$F_2$plank 196 Npainter 490 N2.5 m3.0 m4.0 maxis for torques
A uniform 5.0 m, 20 kg plank on two supports, one at its left end and one 4.0 m from it. A 50 kg painter stands 3.0 m from the left end.
?Wait, what's a normal force from a support?
A support pushes up on whatever rests on it, perpendicular to the contact surface. It's a normal force, and its size is whatever it needs to be to keep the object from sinking into the support, from zero up to the support's limit. It can't pull down.

Find the support forces on the plank. The weights are $(20)(9.8) = 196$ N at the plank's center (2.5 m) and $(50)(9.8) = 490$ N at 3.0 m. Choose the axis at the left support, so $F_1$ drops out. Then $\Sigma\tau = 0$: $F_2(4.0) - (196)(2.5) - (490)(3.0) = 0$, so $F_2 = \dfrac{490 + 1470}{4.0} = 490$ N. Now forces: $F_1 + F_2 = 196 + 490$, so $F_1 = 686 - 490 = 196$ N.

Pause and think
The painter walks to the right, past the right support, onto the overhang. As she walks, what happens to $F_1$, the force from the left support?
I thought about it. Show me
It decreases. Taking torques about the right support, the painter's torque grows as she moves out, and only $F_1$ (and the plank's weight) can balance it on the other side. At some point $F_1$ reaches zero, and beyond that the plank tips.
When does it tip?
For the plank above: how far from the left end can the painter stand before the plank starts to tip over the right support?
  1. At the tipping point, the plank is about to lift off the left support, so $F_1 = 0$.
    Why?
    This is the condition that defines "about to tip". Write it explicitly.
  2. Choose the axis at the right support (4.0 m). The plank's weight is 1.5 m to its left (counterclockwise); the painter at position $x$ is $x - 4.0$ to its right (clockwise).
  3. $\Sigma\tau = 0$: $(196)(1.5) - (490)(x - 4.0) = 0$, so $x - 4.0 = \dfrac{294}{490} = 0.60$ m.
  4. $x = 4.6$ m. The plank is 5.0 m long, so she can stand up to 4.6 m from the left end, 0.4 m short of the far end.
    Why?
    Sanity check: the overhang is 1.0 m, and the plank's weight is not enough to hold her at the very end.

Answer: 4.6 m from the left end (0.60 m past the right support).

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. What is F₁ at the moment the plank starts to tip?
  2. Take torques about the right support.
  3. $196 \times 1.5 = 490 \times (x - 4.0)$.

Hinges and cables

The other classic is a beam held by a hinge at a wall and a cable. The hinge force is unknown in both size and direction, so put the axis at the hinge and it disappears. Only the cable's perpendicular part makes torque.

$F_T$30°78.4 Nsign117.6 Nhingebeam: 2.0 m, 8.0 kgsign at 1.5 m
A uniform 2.0 m, 8.0 kg beam hinged to a wall and held by a cable at 30° to the beam. A 12 kg sign hangs 1.5 m from the wall.
?Wait, how do I split a force into components?
For a force $F$ at angle $\theta$ to a line, the part along the line is $F\cos\theta$ and the part perpendicular to it is $F\sin\theta$. For the cable at 30° to the beam: $F_T\cos 30°$ along the beam toward the wall and $F_T\sin 30°$ perpendicular to it, upward.
Mathematical routine: the cable tension
For the beam and sign shown: (a) find the tension in the cable; (b) find the horizontal and vertical components of the force from the hinge on the beam.
  1. Axis at the hinge, counterclockwise positive. Weights: beam $(8.0)(9.8) = 78.4$ N at 1.0 m; sign $(12)(9.8) = 117.6$ N at 1.5 m. Both turn the beam clockwise.
  2. The cable acts at 2.0 m and its perpendicular part is $F_T\sin 30°$, which turns the beam counterclockwise.
    Why?
    The part of the tension along the beam points at the hinge, so it makes no torque.
  3. (a) $\Sigma\tau = 0$: $F_T\sin 30°(2.0) - (78.4)(1.0) - (117.6)(1.5) = 0$, so $F_T = \dfrac{78.4 + 176.4}{(0.50)(2.0)} = 255$ N.
    Why?
    Write the symbolic equation first, then substitute. That earns the setup point even if arithmetic slips.
  4. (b) Horizontal: the cable pulls toward the wall with $F_T\cos 30° = 221$ N, so the hinge pushes the beam away from the wall with 221 N.
  5. Vertical: $F_{hinge,y} + F_T\sin 30° = 78.4 + 117.6$, so $F_{hinge,y} = 196 - 127.4 = 68.6$ N, upward.
    Why?
    Check the sign: positive means up, which makes sense because the cable alone doesn't hold up all the weight.

Answer: (a) About 255 N. (b) 221 N horizontally away from the wall and 68.6 N upward.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Put the axis at the hinge so the hinge force drops out.
  2. Cable torque: $F_T\sin 30° \times 2.0$ m.
  3. Then ΣF_x = 0 and ΣF_y = 0 for the hinge components.
Check yourself
A uniform beam is held horizontally by a hinge at a wall and a cable from its far end to the wall. The cable is reattached higher on the wall, so it makes a larger angle with the beam. What happens to the tension needed?
  1. AIt increases, because the cable is longer.
  2. BIt decreases, because a larger part of the tension is perpendicular to the beam.
  3. CIt stays the same, because the weights haven't changed.
  4. DIt decreases to zero, because the cable becomes vertical.
Show the answer

B. The torque needed from the cable is fixed by the weights. The cable's torque is $F_T\ell\sin\theta$, so a larger $\theta$ (larger $\sin\theta$) needs a smaller $F_T$. Cable length doesn't matter.

Exam tip from Mr. T

"Choose the axis at the hinge" is the single most useful move in Unit 5 free response. Say it in words ("taking torques about the hinge, so the hinge force exerts no torque"), and graders will follow your whole solution.

  • Static equilibrium: ΣF = 0 and Στ = 0 about any axis you choose.
  • Put the axis where an unknown force acts to remove it from the torque equation.
  • About to tip: the support on the far side pushes with zero force.
  • A cable's torque comes only from its perpendicular part: $F_T$ sin θ × lever distance.