5.5 Static equilibrium of beams and signsPick the axis that kills an unknown

The routine: draw a force diagram, choose an axis at the point where an unknown force you don't need acts, write $\Sigma\tau = 0$ about that axis, and then use $\Sigma F = 0$ for anything left over. One clever axis often solves the problem in one line.
The statics routine
- Draw the extended object and every force where it acts: weights at centers, supports where they touch, cables along the cable.
- Choose the axis at the point of an unknown force (often a hinge or a support).
- Write Στ = 0 about that axis, with a sign for each torque.
- Use ΣF = 0 (vertical and horizontal) for the remaining unknowns.
- Check: are the support forces positive? A negative support push means the object would tip.
?Wait, what's a normal force from a support?
Find the support forces on the plank. The weights are $(20)(9.8) = 196$ N at the plank's center (2.5 m) and $(50)(9.8) = 490$ N at 3.0 m. Choose the axis at the left support, so $F_1$ drops out. Then $\Sigma\tau = 0$: $F_2(4.0) - (196)(2.5) - (490)(3.0) = 0$, so $F_2 = \dfrac{490 + 1470}{4.0} = 490$ N. Now forces: $F_1 + F_2 = 196 + 490$, so $F_1 = 686 - 490 = 196$ N.
I thought about it. Show me
- At the tipping point, the plank is about to lift off the left support, so $F_1 = 0$.
Why?
This is the condition that defines "about to tip". Write it explicitly. - Choose the axis at the right support (4.0 m). The plank's weight is 1.5 m to its left (counterclockwise); the painter at position $x$ is $x - 4.0$ to its right (clockwise).
- $\Sigma\tau = 0$: $(196)(1.5) - (490)(x - 4.0) = 0$, so $x - 4.0 = \dfrac{294}{490} = 0.60$ m.
- $x = 4.6$ m. The plank is 5.0 m long, so she can stand up to 4.6 m from the left end, 0.4 m short of the far end.
Why?
Sanity check: the overhang is 1.0 m, and the plank's weight is not enough to hold her at the very end.
Answer: 4.6 m from the left end (0.60 m past the right support).
Stuck? Get a hint
- What is F₁ at the moment the plank starts to tip?
- Take torques about the right support.
- $196 \times 1.5 = 490 \times (x - 4.0)$.
Hinges and cables
The other classic is a beam held by a hinge at a wall and a cable. The hinge force is unknown in both size and direction, so put the axis at the hinge and it disappears. Only the cable's perpendicular part makes torque.
?Wait, how do I split a force into components?
- Axis at the hinge, counterclockwise positive. Weights: beam $(8.0)(9.8) = 78.4$ N at 1.0 m; sign $(12)(9.8) = 117.6$ N at 1.5 m. Both turn the beam clockwise.
- The cable acts at 2.0 m and its perpendicular part is $F_T\sin 30°$, which turns the beam counterclockwise.
Why?
The part of the tension along the beam points at the hinge, so it makes no torque. - (a) $\Sigma\tau = 0$: $F_T\sin 30°(2.0) - (78.4)(1.0) - (117.6)(1.5) = 0$, so $F_T = \dfrac{78.4 + 176.4}{(0.50)(2.0)} = 255$ N.
Why?
Write the symbolic equation first, then substitute. That earns the setup point even if arithmetic slips. - (b) Horizontal: the cable pulls toward the wall with $F_T\cos 30° = 221$ N, so the hinge pushes the beam away from the wall with 221 N.
- Vertical: $F_{hinge,y} + F_T\sin 30° = 78.4 + 117.6$, so $F_{hinge,y} = 196 - 127.4 = 68.6$ N, upward.
Why?
Check the sign: positive means up, which makes sense because the cable alone doesn't hold up all the weight.
Answer: (a) About 255 N. (b) 221 N horizontally away from the wall and 68.6 N upward.
Stuck? Get a hint
- Put the axis at the hinge so the hinge force drops out.
- Cable torque: $F_T\sin 30° \times 2.0$ m.
- Then ΣF_x = 0 and ΣF_y = 0 for the hinge components.
- AIt increases, because the cable is longer.
- BIt decreases, because a larger part of the tension is perpendicular to the beam.
- CIt stays the same, because the weights haven't changed.
- DIt decreases to zero, because the cable becomes vertical.
Show the answer
B. The torque needed from the cable is fixed by the weights. The cable's torque is $F_T\ell\sin\theta$, so a larger $\theta$ (larger $\sin\theta$) needs a smaller $F_T$. Cable length doesn't matter.
"Choose the axis at the hinge" is the single most useful move in Unit 5 free response. Say it in words ("taking torques about the hinge, so the hinge force exerts no torque"), and graders will follow your whole solution.
- Static equilibrium: ΣF = 0 and Στ = 0 about any axis you choose.
- Put the axis where an unknown force acts to remove it from the torque equation.
- About to tip: the support on the far side pushes with zero force.
- A cable's torque comes only from its perpendicular part: $F_T$ sin θ × lever distance.