AP Physics 1 · Unit 4 lecture · Part 10 of 11 · 7 min

4.3 In the labTesting conservation with real data

Mr. Thompkins
One of the four free-response questions is always about an experiment. For momentum, that usually means carts on a track, motion sensors, and a graph you have to straighten out. Let's do one together.

The setup: a 0.50 kg cart A is launched at the same speed $v_0$ every trial into cart B, at rest, with hook-and-loop pads so they stick. You change B's mass and measure the speed $v_f$ of the pair just after the collision with a motion sensor. The question: use the data to find $v_0$.

Start from the physics. Momentum conservation for sticking carts: $m_Av_0 = (m_A + m_B)v_f$, so $v_f = v_0\left(\dfrac{m_A}{m_A + m_B}\right)$. If you graph $v_f$ on the vertical axis against the mass ratio $\dfrac{m_A}{m_A + m_B}$ on the horizontal axis, the theory predicts a straight line through the origin, with slope $v_0$.

?Wait, why do we straighten graphs?
A straight line is easy to judge by eye and its slope is easy to measure. If the theory says $y = (\text{constant})\cdot x$, plotting $y$ against $x$ makes a line through the origin, and the slope is the constant. Choosing what to plot so the graph is a line is called linearizing.
?Wait, what's the difference between random and systematic error?
Random error scatters measurements above and below the true value from trial to trial, like a shaky launch. Repeating trials and averaging reduces it. Systematic error pushes every measurement the same way, like a sensor that always reads low or friction you forgot. Repeating doesn't fix it; you have to find and remove its cause.
$m_B$ (kg)$\frac{m_A}{m_A + m_B}$$v_f$ (m/s)
0.250.6670.78
0.500.5000.61
1.000.3330.39
1.500.2500.29
2.000.2000.24
Data for five trials. Cart A is 0.50 kg every time.
00.20.40.60.800.20.40.60.81mass ratio $m_A/(m_A + m_B)$$v_f$ (m/s)best fit: slope 1.18 m/s
The pair's speed against the mass ratio, with a best-fit line drawn through the data.
Experimental design and analysis
Use the data and graph above. (a) Determine $v_0$ from the best-fit line. (b) The line doesn't pass exactly through every point. Give one reason. (c) A student says friction on the track would make the measured $v_f$ too small. Would that make the experimental $v_0$ too big or too small?
  1. (a) Pick two points on the best-fit line, not data points: for example (0, 0) and (0.75, 0.888). Slope $= \dfrac{0.888 - 0}{0.75 - 0} = 1.18$ m/s.
    Why?
    Rubrics specifically require points from the line. Using two data points can give a different slope and loses the point.
  2. Since the slope equals $v_0$, $v_0 \approx 1.2$ m/s.
    Why?
    Connect the slope to the physics in words: "the slope of $v_f$ versus the mass ratio is $v_0$".
  3. (b) Random measurement uncertainty: the launch speed varies a little from trial to trial, and the sensor reading of $v_f$ has some scatter.
    Why?
    Any specific, physical source of random error is fine. "Human error" by itself is too vague to score.
  4. (c) If friction slows the pair before $v_f$ is measured, every $v_f$ is a bit low, so the slope, and the experimental $v_0$, comes out too small.
    Why?
    Trace the error through the analysis: measured quantity, then graph, then result.

Answer: (a) About 1.2 m/s (slope 1.18 m/s). (b) Random scatter in the launch speed and in the sensor readings. (c) Too small.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. What does the theory say the slope of this graph equals?
  2. Read two far-apart points on the line itself.
  3. Slope = rise / run = 0.888 / 0.75.
Pause and think
Why measure $v_f$ just after the collision instead of a second later?
I thought about it. Show me
Conservation of momentum is only safe across the short collision, when friction's impulse is negligible. A second later, friction has had time to remove some momentum from the system, so $v_f$ would be smaller than what the collision itself produced.
Check yourself
To test whether a collision between two carts is elastic, which set of measurements is enough?
  1. AThe masses of both carts only
  2. BThe velocities of both carts before and after, and both masses
  3. CThe time the collision lasts and the force between the carts
  4. DThe total momentum before and after
Show the answer

B. Kinetic energy is $\tfrac12mv^2$ for each cart, so you need both masses and all four velocities to compare the totals before and after. Momentum totals alone can't tell you about kinetic energy, since momentum is conserved either way.

Exam tip from Mr. T

When an FRQ asks you to design an experiment, list the measuring tool for every quantity ("a motion sensor for velocity, a balance for mass"), say what you vary and what you keep the same, and say how you'll use a graph. Repeat trials. Those are the scoring points.

  • Linearize: rearrange the theory to y = (constant)·x, plot y against x, and read the constant from the slope.
  • Take the slope from two points on the best-fit line, far apart.
  • Measure velocities just before and just after a collision.
  • Trace a systematic error through to its effect on the final answer.