AP Physics 1 · Unit 4 lecture · Part 9 of 11 · 8 min

4.3 and 4.4 Collisions in bigger problemsMomentum for the bang, energy for the rest

Mr. Thompkins
The hardest Unit 4 questions glue a collision to a Unit 3 energy problem. The trick is to cut the story into stages and use the right law in each one.

Inside a quick collision, momentum is conserved but kinetic energy usually isn't, so use momentum. Before and after the collision, when forces like gravity, springs or friction act over a distance, use energy. Never use energy conservation straight through a sticky collision: the kinetic energy that turns into internal energy breaks the chain.

?Wait, how do I get a speed from a height with energy?
If only gravity does work, mechanical energy is conserved: $\tfrac12mv^2 = mgh$ for something that rises to height $h$ and stops, so $v = \sqrt{2gh}$. The mass cancels. You used this all through Unit 3.

The ballistic pendulum is the famous example. A 0.020 kg dart hits and sticks in a 0.98 kg block hanging from strings. The block (now 1.00 kg with the dart) swings up until it is 0.20 m higher than where it started. How fast was the dart going?

block · 0.98 kg$v_0$dart · 0.020 kgh = 0.20 mstage 1: stick (momentum)stage 2: swing up (energy)
A ballistic pendulum. Stage 1, the dart sticks: momentum. Stage 2, the block swings up: energy.

Work backward. Stage 2, the swing, is all energy: $v' = \sqrt{2gh} = \sqrt{2(9.8)(0.20)} = 1.98$ m/s just after the collision. Stage 1, the collision, is all momentum: $m_dv_0 = (m_d + m_b)v'$, so $v_0 = \dfrac{(1.00)(1.98)}{0.020} = 99$ m/s.

Dart flying (J)98.0$K$$U_g$$\Delta E_{int}$Just after (J)1.96$K$$U_g$96.0$\Delta E_{int}$Top of swing (J)$K$1.96$U_g$96.0$\Delta E_{int}$
Energy bar charts for the ballistic pendulum, in joules. The collision turns 96 J of the dart's 98 J into internal energy. The swing then turns the remaining 1.96 J into gravitational potential energy.

Those bars are startling. The dart brought 98.0 J of kinetic energy. Just after it stuck, only 1.96 J was left, 2% of it. The other 96.0 J went into heating and tearing the block. If you'd used energy conservation from the flying dart to the top of the swing, you'd have found a dart speed of about 14 m/s, wrong by a factor of 7.

Pause and think
Why is it fine to say the block's momentum is conserved during the collision, even though the strings and gravity act on it?
I thought about it. Show me
During the very short collision, the block barely moves, so the strings are still vertical and they balance gravity. There's no net horizontal external force on the dart + block system, so horizontal momentum is conserved during the collision. Afterward, as the block swings, the strings and gravity are no longer balanced and momentum is not conserved, which is why stage 2 uses energy.
?Wait, how does kinetic friction take energy away?
Kinetic friction has size $f_k = \mu_kF_N$ and points against the sliding. Over a sliding distance $d$ it does negative work $-f_kd$ on the object, turning kinetic energy into internal energy of the surfaces. On a level floor, $F_N = mg$.
Collision, then friction
A 1.5 kg cart moving right at 4.0 m/s hits and sticks to a 0.50 kg block at rest on a level floor. Together they slide on a rough patch where the coefficient of kinetic friction is 0.20. (a) Find their speed just after the collision. (b) Find how far they slide before stopping. (c) Explain why you can't use energy conservation from the cart's original speed to the stop without the collision step.
  1. Stage 1, collision. System: cart + block. The collision is brief, so friction's impulse is negligible and momentum is conserved: $(1.5)(4.0) = (2.0)v'$, giving $v' = 3.0$ m/s.
    Why?
    The collision step always comes first, and it's always momentum.
  2. Stage 2, sliding. Friction does work $-f_kd = -\mu_k(m_1 + m_2)gd$, which removes all the kinetic energy: $\tfrac12(m_1 + m_2)v'^2 = \mu_k(m_1 + m_2)gd$.
    Why?
    Work-energy theorem from Unit 3. The mass cancels.
  3. Solve: $d = \dfrac{v'^2}{2\mu_kg} = \dfrac{(3.0)^2}{2(0.20)(9.8)} = 2.3$ m.
  4. (c) The collision is perfectly inelastic: kinetic energy drops from $\tfrac12(1.5)(4.0)^2 = 12$ J to $\tfrac12(2.0)(3.0)^2 = 9.0$ J. Those 3.0 J become internal energy in the collision, not friction work on the floor, so skipping stage 1 would give the wrong sliding distance.
    Why?
    A full justification names what is lost and where.

Answer: (a) 3.0 m/s. (b) About 2.3 m. (c) 3.0 J of kinetic energy becomes internal energy in the sticky collision, so energy alone can't bridge it.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Do the collision first with momentum: 6.0 kg·m/s shared by 2.0 kg.
  2. Then use energy: $\tfrac12Mv'^2 = \mu_kMgd$.
  3. $d = 9.0 / (2 \times 0.20 \times 9.8)$.
Check yourself
A bullet passes completely through a block of wood resting on a frictionless table and comes out slower. For the bullet + block system during the passage, which is true?
  1. AMomentum and kinetic energy are both conserved.
  2. BMomentum is conserved, and kinetic energy decreases.
  3. CKinetic energy is conserved, and momentum decreases.
  4. DNeither is conserved, because the bullet doesn't stick.
Show the answer

B. No net horizontal external force acts, so momentum is conserved. Plowing through wood heats and tears it, so the collision is inelastic and kinetic energy decreases, even though the objects don't stick. "They didn't stick, so nothing is conserved" mixes up perfectly inelastic with inelastic.

Exam tip from Mr. T

Label your stages in writing: "Stage 1: collision, momentum conserved because...", "Stage 2: swing, mechanical energy conserved because...". Readers grade what they can follow, and naming the law for each stage is often worth points on its own.

  • Cut the story into stages. Collision: momentum. Swing, slide, spring or fall: energy.
  • Never use energy conservation straight through a collision unless you know it is elastic.
  • During a brief collision, slow forces like friction or unbalanced string tension give negligible impulse.