AP Physics 1 · Unit 3 lecture · Part 7 of 10 · 10 min

3.4 Conservation of energyWhen friction joins in: thermal energy and open systems

Mr. Thompkins
A sled slides down a snowy hill and stops at the bottom on the flat. All that energy seems to vanish. It didn't. It went somewhere you can feel: rub your hands together fast and touch your cheek. That warmth is where the energy went.

Kinetic friction turns mechanical energy into internal energy of the rubbing surfaces, which you notice as a temperature rise. We call it thermal energy, $E_{th}$. When both surfaces are inside your system, the energy isn't lost: $\Delta E_{th} = f_k d$, where $d$ is the distance the surfaces slide past each other. The total energy, $K + U + E_{th}$, is still conserved.

The general rule, true for any system you choose: $\Delta E_{system} = W_{external}$. Energy goes up by the work outside forces do on the system and down by the work it does on them. A system with no external work is isolated as far as energy goes. A system where outside forces do work is open, and that work is the energy that crosses its boundary.

?Wait, why is friction's work $-f_k d$ on the sled?
Friction on the sled points against its motion, so $\theta = 180°$ and $\cos 180° = -1$: $W = f_k d\cos 180° = -f_k d$. When the snow is outside the system, that negative work is energy leaving the sled. When the snow is inside, the same amount shows up as thermal energy instead.
SystemGravity shows up asFriction shows up asEquation
Sled aloneExternal work: +mghExternal work: −f d$W_{ext}$ = ΔK
Sled + EarthPotential energy $U_g$External work: −f d$W_{ext}$ = ΔK + $\Delta U_g$
Sled + Earth + snowPotential energy $U_g$Thermal energy: +f d0 = ΔK + $\Delta U_g$ + $\Delta E_{th}$
The same sled, three systems. The physics is identical, but gravity and friction show up in different places in the equation. Never count a force both as work and as energy.
A sled with friction
A 20 kg sled starts from rest at the top of a 5.0 m high snowy hill and reaches the bottom at 8.0 m/s. (a) How much energy was converted to thermal energy on the hill? (b) At the bottom it slides onto level snow with $\mu_k = 0.25$. How far does it slide before stopping?
  1. (a) System: sled + Earth + snow. No external work: $0 = \Delta K + \Delta U_g + \Delta E_{th}$.
    Why?
    Putting the snow in the system turns friction's negative work into a thermal energy term.
  2. $\Delta U_g = -mgh = -(20)(9.8)(5.0) = -980$ J. $\Delta K = \frac12(20)(8.0)^2 - 0 = 640$ J. So $\Delta E_{th} = 980 - 640 = 340$ J.
    Why?
    Of the 980 J released by the drop, 640 J became motion and 340 J warmed the sled and the snow.
  3. (b) On the flat: $\Delta E_{th} = f_k d = \mu_k mgd$ must absorb all 640 J of kinetic energy: $d = \frac{640}{(0.25)(20)(9.8)} = 13.1$ m.
    Why?
    Level ground, so $U_g$ does not change. All the kinetic energy ends up thermal.

Answer: (a) 340 J. (b) About 13 m.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. List the energies at the top and at the bottom of the hill.
  2. Whatever $U_g$ lost that did not become K became thermal energy.
  3. On the flat: $\frac12 mv^2 = \mu_k mgd$.
topK980UgEthbottom640KUg340EthstoppedKUg980Eth
Energy bar charts in joules for the sled-Earth-snow system. The total stays 980 J; friction moves energy into thermal energy until the sled stops.
Pause and think
In the bar charts, the total never changes. But if your system were just the sled and Earth (snow outside), what would the bar charts show, and why?
I thought about it. Show me
The total would drop: from 980 J at the top to 640 J at the bottom to 0 when stopped. Friction from the snow is now an external force doing negative work, which carries energy out of the system. Same physics, different bookkeeping: $W_{ext} = \Delta K + \Delta U_g$.
?Wait, is "thermal energy" the same as heat?
Not quite. Thermal energy is the internal energy stored in the random motion of a material's particles. "Heat" in physics means energy transferred because of a temperature difference. In this unit, friction raises the thermal energy of the rubbing surfaces directly, and that's what $\Delta E_{th}$ tracks.
Check yourself
A 3.0 kg block slides down a 2.0 m high ramp from rest and reaches the bottom at 5.0 m/s. How much mechanical energy did the block-Earth system lose to friction?
  1. A21.3 J
  2. B37.5 J
  3. C58.8 J
  4. D96.3 J
Show the answer

A. $\Delta U_g = -(3.0)(9.8)(2.0) = -58.8$ J and $K_f = \frac12(3.0)(5.0)^2 = 37.5$ J. Loss: $58.8 - 37.5 = 21.3$ J. Choice D adds the two energies instead of subtracting.

Exam tip from Mr. T

Before writing any energy equation, write "System: ..." and decide where gravity and friction go. The rule that saves the most points: a force is either an external force doing work, or a source of potential or thermal energy inside your system. Never both.

  • Any system: $\Delta E_{system} = W_{external}$.
  • Friction inside the system: $\Delta E_{th} = f_k d$, and $K + U + E_{th}$ is conserved.
  • Friction outside the system: it does negative external work, and the mechanical energy decreases.
  • Choosing the system decides the bookkeeping, not the physics. Count each force once.