7.2 Natural selectionSelection works on what is already there

Natural selection acts on phenotypic variation. No variation, no selection: if every individual were identical, a change in the environment would hit them all the same way. Environments change and apply selective pressures, anything that affects who survives and reproduces: predators, drought, disease, toxins, a warmer spring. A variation can raise fitness in one environment and lower it in another. A thick coat helps in the Arctic and hurts in the desert.
?Wait, where does new variation come from?
Here's how DDT resistance evolved. Before any spraying, a few mosquitoes already carried rare alleles, from random mutations, that let them survive DDT. Spraying killed most of the others. The resistant ones bred, and a few generations later most of the population was resistant. DDT didn't cause the mutations. It selected among variation that was already there.
Beyond the course, as a bonus: this pattern is called directional selection. Stabilizing selection favors the middle, and disruptive selection favors both extremes. The exam asks you to describe the graph and explain the cause, not to name the pattern.
Variation in molecules
Variation in the number and types of molecules within cells can give a population a greater ability to survive and reproduce in different environments. Picture fish with two alleles of an enzyme gene: one version works best in cold water, the other in warm water. A population with both can live across a wider range of temperatures. The course's examples include sickle cell hemoglobin (protective against malaria in carriers) and plants shifting their flowering time as the climate warms.
?Wait, why does an enzyme have an optimum temperature?
I thought about it. Show me
- (a) Need-based reasoning: insects can't make mutations because they need them. Mutations are random.
Why?
The number one trap of the unit. 'Needed to' or 'in order to' loses the point. - (b) Variation: before spraying began, a few insects already carried resistance alleles.
- Selection: each spraying killed most susceptible insects, so resistant insects survived and reproduced more.
- Result: their offspring inherited resistance, so the resistant fraction rose each generation, from 2% to 70%.
Why?
Quote the data to show the change is in the population, over generations.
Answer: (a) Mutations aren't made on demand. (b) Resistant variants already existed; spraying killed the others; survivors passed on resistance, so it rose from 2% to 70%.
Stuck? Get a hint
- Were the resistance alleles there before the first spraying?
- What does the spray do to insects without them?
- Existing variation, selection by the spray, inheritance.
- AIt causes the specific mutations organisms need.
- BIt determines which existing phenotypes have higher fitness.
- CIt has no effect once a trait is inherited.
- DIt makes every individual change in the same way.
Show the answer
B. The environment is the judge, not the inventor: it sets which existing variants survive and reproduce best. The first choice is the need-based trap.

Ban 'in order to', 'needed to' and 'tried to' from your answers. Use the shape: 'individuals that already had... survived and reproduced more, so...'.
- Natural selection acts on phenotypic variation; environments apply selective pressures.
- A variation can raise fitness in one environment and lower it in another.
- Variation in molecules (enzyme versions, hemoglobin) helps populations survive in more environments.
- Mutations are random. Selection sorts the variation that exists.