AP Biology · Unit 7 lecture · Part 3 of 12 · 5 min

7.3 Artificial selectionWhen people do the choosing

Mrs. Otero
Kale, cabbage, broccoli, cauliflower, Brussels sprouts and kohlrabi look like six plants. They're one species, wild mustard, reshaped by farmers who chose which plants got to make seeds.

In artificial selection, humans decide which individuals reproduce, based on traits humans want. Through artificial selection, humans affect variation in other species: dog breeds from wolves, corn from a wild grass called teosinte, cows that give more milk. It works fast, because only the chosen individuals breed at all. It also tends to shrink genetic variation, since breeders keep crossing a few similar individuals. That's why many dog breeds carry inherited diseases and why uniform crops are easy targets for one pathogen.

VegetablePart people selectedWhat got bigger
KaleLeavesLarge, many leaves
CabbageBud at the tip of the stemA tight head of leaves
Brussels sproutsSide budsMany small heads
BroccoliFlower clusters and stemBig green flower heads
CauliflowerFlower clustersA dense white head
KohlrabiStemA swollen, round stem
Six vegetables, one species (Brassica oleracea). Farmers selected different parts of the same wild plant.
?Wait, what does heritable mean?
A heritable trait is at least partly set by genes, so offspring tend to resemble their parents. If a trait comes only from the environment, like muscles from lifting weights, selecting parents for it won't change the next generation.

In the AP lab version, students grow Wisconsin Fast Plants, count the hairs (trichomes) on a leaf, cross only the hairiest plants, and count hairs on the offspring. Here's a class data set.

PlantGen 1 hairsGen 2 hairs
11829
22233
32527
42035
53031
61526
72438
82730
91934
102128
112632
121729
Total264372
Hairs on the first true leaf of 12 plants per generation (illustrative). Only the three hairiest generation 1 plants (30, 27 and 26 hairs) were crossed to make generation 2.
?Wait, how do I calculate a percent change?
Percent change = (new − old) ÷ old × 100. From 20 to 25: the change is 5, and 5 ÷ 20 × 100 = 25%. Always divide by the starting value.
Calculate and describe
Use the table. (a) Calculate the mean hairs per leaf in each generation. (b) Calculate the percent change. (c) What does the result show about the trait?
mean hairs per leaf22gen 131gen 2
  1. (a) Generation 1 adds to 264, so the mean is 264 ÷ 12 = 22.0 hairs. Generation 2 adds to 372, so its mean is 31.0 hairs.
    Why?
    Mean = sum of values ÷ n, from the formula sheet.
  2. (b) (31.0 − 22.0) ÷ 22.0 × 100 ≈ 40.9%, an increase of about 41%.
    Why?
    Divide by the starting value and say 'increase'.
  3. (c) Selecting hairy parents raised the offspring's mean, so hairiness is at least partly heritable.
    Why?
    A response to selection is evidence of a genetic basis. A purely environmental trait would stay near 22.

Answer: (a) 22.0 and 31.0 hairs. (b) About a 41% increase. (c) The trait is heritable.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Add the 12 counts in a row and divide by 12.
  2. Use (new − old) ÷ old × 100.
  3. Would an environmental trait respond to choosing parents?
Pause and think
A student also grew generation 2 seeds from randomly chosen parents in the same room. Why is that group useful, and what would you predict for it?
I thought about it. Show me
It's a control: same conditions, no selection. Any extra change in the selected group can then be credited to selection, not the room or the soil. Its mean should stay near 22.
Check yourself
Breeders select chickens for rapid growth for 30 generations. Which outcome is most likely?
  1. AEvery chicken becomes genetically identical after one generation.
  2. BGrowth rate increases, and genetic variation for other traits may decrease.
  3. CNothing changes, because artificial selection only changes phenotypes, not genes.
  4. DThe chickens become better at surviving in the wild.
Show the answer

B. Selecting a heritable trait shifts it, and breeding from a small, similar group tends to reduce variation. Artificial selection does change allele frequencies. Fast-growing farm chickens usually do worse in the wild.

  • Artificial selection: humans choose who reproduces, so the traits humans want become more common.
  • It changes allele frequencies and shows that the selected trait is heritable.
  • It often reduces genetic variation.
  • Lab skills: means, percent change, and a control group.