AP Biology · Unit 7 lecture · Part 1 of 12 · 6 min

7.1 Introduction to natural selectionWhy some birds win

By the end: Explain how natural selection, genetic drift, gene flow and mutation change the allele frequencies of populations, use Hardy-Weinberg as a null hypothesis, read the evidence and the trees that show common ancestry, and explain how new species arise.
Mrs. Otero
Welcome to Unit 7, the unit that ties biology together. Here's the puzzle: a drought kills most of an island's seed-eating birds, and a year later the chicks have deeper beaks on average. No bird grew a new beak. So what changed?

Evolution is a change in the genetic makeup of a population over generations, measured as a change in allele frequencies. Notice the word population. One bird can't evolve during its life: it survives or it doesn't, it reproduces or it doesn't. The population is what changes, from one generation to the next.

?Wait, what's an allele again?
An allele is one version of a gene. A gene for beak depth might have alleles that make the beak a little deeper or shallower. You got one allele of each gene from each parent (Unit 5).
?Wait, genotype or phenotype?
The genotype is the alleles an organism carries, like Aa. The phenotype is the trait you can see or measure, like a deep beak. Selection 'sees' phenotypes, but what gets passed on is genotypes.

Natural selection is a major mechanism of evolution, and Darwin described its logic. Populations produce more offspring than the environment can support, so individuals compete for limited resources. Individuals vary, and some of that variation is inherited. Those with more favorable phenotypes are more likely to survive and produce more offspring, so they pass those traits on. Over generations, the favorable traits become more common.

traits varypassed ontoo many youngcompetitionuneven successtrait spreadsvariationheritableoverproductionmore offspringnext generationrepeats every generation
Darwin's argument as a loop. Inherited variation plus more offspring than can survive leads to competition and uneven reproductive success, so the favored trait spreads.

Evolutionary fitness is measured by reproductive success: how many surviving, fertile offspring an individual leaves compared with others. A huge deer that dies before mating has a fitness of zero. A small deer that raises five fawns that go on to breed is fitter. Fitness is about passing on genes, not strength.

Fitness also depends on the environment, and both the biotic environment (predators, parasites, competitors) and the abiotic one (rain, temperature, soil) fluctuate. When they do, the rate and even the direction of selection can change, so different variations can be favored in different generations.

0123456789108.899.29.49.69.81010.2yearmean beak depth (mm)droughtwet years
Illustrative data for an island seed-eater. After the drought, mostly large, hard seeds were left, and deep-beaked birds survived and bred. In the wet years, when small seeds are plentiful again, the mean drifts back down.
Pause and think
In the wet years (7 to 10) the mean beak depth falls back toward 9.3 mm. Did the birds 'undo' their evolution?
I thought about it. Show me
No bird changed. With plenty of small, soft seeds, deep beaks no longer help and cost energy to grow, so shallower-beaked birds do as well or better and leave more offspring. The environment changed, so the direction of selection reversed.
Explain data, AP style
Use the beak graph. (a) Describe the change in mean beak depth from year 3 to year 4. (b) Explain how natural selection caused it, using variation, heritable and reproductive success.
  1. (a) It rose from 9.2 mm to 9.9 mm, an increase of 0.7 mm.
    Why?
    A description gives a direction and a size, with units.
  2. (b) Variation: before the drought, birds varied in beak depth.
    Why?
    Selection can only act on variation that already exists.
  3. Selection: in the drought, most seeds left were large and hard, so deep-beaked birds were more likely to survive and had greater reproductive success.
  4. Inheritance: beak depth is heritable, so the survivors' chicks inherited deeper beaks and the mean shifted up.
    Why?
    The exam wants all three links: variation, selection, inheritance.

Answer: (a) An increase of 0.7 mm, from 9.2 to 9.9 mm. (b) Birds varied; the drought favored deep beaks; the trait is heritable, so the next generation's mean rose.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Read the points for year 3 and year 4.
  2. What did the drought do to the food supply?
  3. Variation, then selection, then inheritance.
Check yourself
Which individual has the highest evolutionary fitness?
  1. AA male lizard that wins every fight but leaves no offspring
  2. BA female that lives 9 years and has 1 offspring that survives to breed
  3. CA female that lives 3 years and has 6 offspring that survive to breed
  4. DThe largest male in the population
Show the answer

C. Fitness is reproductive success, so six breeding offspring beats one. The top trap is choosing strength or size: a fighter with no offspring has a fitness of zero.

  • Evolution: a change in a population's allele frequencies over generations. Populations evolve; individuals don't.
  • Natural selection: competition for limited resources leads to differential survival and reproduction of individuals with favorable heritable traits.
  • Fitness is reproductive success, relative to others in the population.
  • Environments fluctuate, so the rate and direction of selection can change.