AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 4 lecture · Part 5 of 11 · 9 min

4.3 Conservation of linear momentumChoose the system, and momentum stays put

Mr. Thompkins
Now the big one. Momentum is one of the few quantities in physics that is conserved, and it's conserved in situations where you have no idea what the forces are doing: crashes, explosions, a skater pushing off a wall. The trick is choosing the right system.
?Wait, what's the difference between internal and external forces?
First you choose a system: the objects you're studying (Unit 2). Internal forces are forces that objects inside the system exert on each other. External forces are exerted on the system by objects outside it. The same force can be either, depending on where you draw the line.
?Wait, what does Newton's third law say exactly?
If object 1 pushes on object 2, then object 2 pushes back on object 1 with a force of the same size in the opposite direction, at the same instant: $\vec F_{1\,on\,2} = -\vec F_{2\,on\,1}$. The two forces act on different objects, which is why they don't cancel for either object alone.

Here's the argument. Take two objects that push on each other. By the second law, $\frac{d\vec p_1}{dt} = \vec F_{2\,on\,1} + \vec F_{ext,1}$ and $\frac{d\vec p_2}{dt} = \vec F_{1\,on\,2} + \vec F_{ext,2}$. Add the two equations. By the third law the internal forces cancel exactly, at every instant, so $\frac{d\vec p_{sys}}{dt} = \Sigma\vec F_{ext}$. Only external forces can change a system's total momentum. If the net external force is zero, the total momentum is constant: $\Sigma m_i\vec v_i = \Sigma m_i\vec v_i'$.

system: both skaters50 kg75 kg$F_{on\,1}$$F_{on\,2}$equal size, opposite directioninternal: they cancel in the totalgravity and the ice cancel vertically
Two skaters push apart. Draw the system boundary around both of them. The pushes are internal, equal and opposite, so they cancel in the total. Vertically, gravity and the ice's normal force cancel. Nothing external acts horizontally.
00.250.50.751-80-60-40-20020406080t (s)p (kg·m/s)75 kg skater50 kg skatertotal
Their momenta during a 0.50 s push of 120 N. Each skater gets an impulse of 60 N·s, in opposite directions, so the total stays exactly zero the whole time.

Notice what conservation does not say. It doesn't say each object keeps its momentum. Momentum flows from one object to the other through the internal forces. It's the total that stays put. And it works one component at a time: if the external forces are all vertical, horizontal momentum is conserved even though vertical momentum isn't.

Recoil in space
An 80 kg astronaut floats at rest next to a space station. She throws a 2.0 kg wrench away from her at 6.0 m/s. (a) Find her velocity afterward. (b) Find the kinetic energy of each object afterward, and say where the energy came from.
  1. Name the system and justify: astronaut plus wrench. During the throw, the only forces between them are internal, and no external force acts, so the system's momentum is conserved.
    Why?
    On free-response questions, "momentum is conserved because there is no net external force on the astronaut-wrench system" is often a point by itself.
  2. Take the wrench's direction as $+$. Before: total momentum 0. After: $(2.0)(6.0) + (80)v_a = 0$.
  3. (a) $v_a = -\frac{12}{80} = -0.15\ \text{m/s}$: 0.15 m/s, opposite to the wrench.
    Why?
    The minus sign is the physics: she recoils backward. Report it as a direction in words.
  4. (b) $K_{wrench} = \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(6.0)^2 = 36\ \text{J}$ and $K_{astro} = \tfrac{1}{2}(80)(0.15)^2 = 0.90\ \text{J}$. Both started at zero, so the system gained about 37 J. It came from chemical energy in her muscles: internal energy of the system.
    Why?
    Momentum is conserved here but kinetic energy is not. Internal forces can create kinetic energy (pushes) or destroy it (crashes), but they can't change total momentum.

Answer: (a) 0.15 m/s, opposite to the wrench (b) wrench 36 J, astronaut 0.90 J, from her muscles' chemical energy.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Total momentum before the throw is zero.
  2. $m_w v_w + m_a v_a = 0$.
  3. The lighter object gets the bigger speed; their momenta are equal and opposite.
Pause and think
A cart rolls along a level track at 3.0 m/s. Through a hole in its floor it drops a sandbag, which falls straight down relative to the cart. Does the cart speed up, slow down, or keep its speed?
I thought about it. Show me
It keeps its speed. When the bag leaves, it still has the cart's horizontal velocity, 3.0 m/s, so it carries away exactly its own share of the horizontal momentum. The cart keeps its share, and the same mass times the same velocity means the same speed. A cart that throws the bag backward is a different story.

In real collisions there are usually some external forces: friction from the road, gravity. Momentum is still very nearly conserved during the collision itself, because the collision is short. Two 1200 kg cars collide at 15 m/s. Even if road friction on one car were as big as $0.7mg \approx 8200\ \text{N}$, over a 0.10 s crash it delivers only about $820\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}$, around 5% of the car's $18{,}000\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}$, and real tire friction during a crash is usually far smaller. So you conserve momentum from just before to just after, and you deal with friction separately, before and after.

Pause and think
You drop a ball. Is the ball's momentum conserved as it falls? Is there a system whose momentum is conserved?
I thought about it. Show me
The ball's momentum is not conserved: gravity is an external force on the ball, and its momentum grows downward. But the ball-Earth system has no external force on it. The Earth gains an equal upward momentum, far too small to notice, so the total stays constant.
Check yourself
For which system is the total momentum conserved?
  1. AA ball, as a bat hits it
  2. BA car, as its brakes bring it to a stop
  3. CTwo ice skaters, as they push apart on frictionless ice
  4. DA falling apple, before it hits the ground
Show the answer

C. The skaters' pushes are internal to the two-skater system, and nothing external acts horizontally. In the other choices the system is a single object with a large outside force on it: the bat, the road's friction, or gravity. Choose a bigger system (ball and bat, apple and Earth) and conservation works again.

Exam tip from Mr. T

Start every conservation answer with the system and the reason: "For the system of ___ and ___, the net external force is zero (or negligible during the short collision), so momentum is conserved." Then write the equation in symbols with signs.

  • $\Sigma\vec F_{ext} = \frac{d\vec p_{sys}}{dt}$. Internal forces cancel in pairs (third law).
  • No net external force: total momentum is constant. Each object's momentum can change.
  • Conservation works component by component.
  • Short collisions: external impulses are tiny, so momentum is conserved from just before to just after.
  • Internal forces can change kinetic energy but never total momentum.