4.2 Average force, stopping and bouncingSame change in momentum, different force

When something stops, its change in momentum is fixed by how fast it was going: from $mv$ to zero. You can't change that. What you can change is how long the stop takes. Stretch the stopping time and the same change in momentum needs a smaller average force. Airbags, crumple zones, gym mats, bike helmets and bent knees all work the same way: they make the stop last longer.
I thought about it. Show me
?Wait, the floor pushes on the phone, but does the phone push on the floor too?
Bouncing beats stopping
Now let the object bounce. A ball that hits a wall and comes back has to be stopped and then sent back the other way. Its momentum changes by more than if it had just stopped. In symbols, with toward the wall as positive: stopping gives $\Delta p = 0 - mv_i = -mv_i$, but bouncing back at speed $v_f$ gives $\Delta p = m(-v_f) - mv_i = -m(v_i + v_f)$. The speeds add. That's why the wall has to push harder on a ball that bounces.
- Pick a direction: away from the wall is $+$. Then $v_i = -20\ \text{m/s}$ and $v_f = +15\ \text{m/s}$.
Why?
Choosing the final direction as positive makes the impulse come out positive, but any choice works if you keep it. - (a) $J = \Delta p = m(v_f - v_i) = 0.057(15 - (-20)) = 0.057(35) \approx 2.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}$, away from the wall.
Why?
The minus signs are the whole problem. $15 - 20$ would give 0.29 N·s, about seven times too small. - (b) $F_{avg} = \frac{J}{\Delta t} = \frac{1.995}{0.0050} \approx 400\ \text{N}$, away from the wall.
- (c) Stopping: $J = 0.057(0 - (-20)) = 1.14\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}$, so $F_{avg} = \frac{1.14}{0.0050} \approx 230\ \text{N}$.
Why?
Same time, smaller change in momentum, smaller force. The bounce needs about 1.75 times the force.
Answer: (a) About 2.0 N·s, away from the wall (b) about 400 N (c) about 230 N.
Stuck? Get a hint
- Write both velocities with signs before you subtract.
- $\Delta v = v_f - v_i = (+15) - (-20)$.
- Multiply by the mass for the impulse, then divide by 0.0050 s for the average force.
- AX gets the larger impulse, because it stops completely.
- BThey get equal impulses, because they hit at the same speed.
- CY gets the larger impulse, because its momentum reverses.
- DNeither gets an impulse, because the floor doesn't move.
Show the answer
C. Both hit with the same downward momentum. X ends with zero momentum, but Y ends with upward momentum, so Y's momentum changes more and so does its impulse. Choice B looks only at the arrival speed and forgets the rebound.
This is also how the course measures impulse in the lab, and it's a favorite for the Experimental Design and Analysis free-response question. A force sensor records F(t) many times per second during a collision, and the software finds the area under the curve. A motion detector records the velocity just before and just after. If impulse equals change in momentum, a graph of impulse against $m\,\Delta v$ is a straight line through the origin with slope 1.
?Wait, how do I find an area from data points instead of a formula?
- A$1.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}$
- B$2.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}$
- C$4.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}$
- D$1600\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}$
Show the answer
B. Triangle area: $\tfrac{1}{2}(80)(0.050) = 2.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}$. Choice C multiplies the peak force by the whole time, which is the area of a rectangle around the triangle and twice too big. Choice D divides by the time instead of multiplying.
- Same $\Delta p$, longer $\Delta t$, smaller $F_{avg}$: that's every safety device.
- A bounce has a bigger $\Delta p$ than a stop: the speeds add, $|\Delta p| = m(v_i + v_f)$.
- Third law: two objects in contact give each other equal and opposite impulses.
- In the lab, impulse is the area under the force-sensor curve; compare it with $m\,\Delta v$.