AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 1 lecture · Part 7 of 10 · 8 min

1.4 Reference frames and relative motionIt depends on who is watching

Mr. Thompkins
Ever walked on one of those moving walkways at an airport? You pass people who are walking just as hard as you are, but on the floor. Your speed depends on what you measure it against. That's a reference frame.

A reference frame is the point of view you measure motion from: an origin, a set of axes, and a clock. The ground is one frame. A train moving past is another. The same ball can have different positions and velocities in different frames, and both descriptions are correct.

Velocities in different frames are connected by vector addition. If $A$ is an object, $B$ is a moving frame (like a train or a river), and $G$ is the ground:

$$\vec v_{A/G} = \vec v_{A/B} + \vec v_{B/G}$$

Read it as "A relative to G equals A relative to B plus B relative to G". The inside letters match up and cancel, which is a nice check. If you walk at 1.5 m/s forward on a walkway that moves at 1.0 m/s, you move at 2.5 m/s relative to the floor. Walk backward on it and you move at $-1.5 + 1.0 = -0.5\ \text{m/s}$.

?Wait, how do I subtract a vector?
Subtracting a vector is adding its opposite: $\vec A - \vec B = \vec A + (-\vec B)$, where $-\vec B$ has the same size as $\vec B$ but points the other way. So the velocity of A relative to B is $\vec v_{A/B} = \vec v_{A/G} - \vec v_{B/G}$: take A's ground velocity and add the reverse of B's.
?Wait, how do I add vectors that aren't on one line?
Draw them head to tail: put the tail of the second arrow at the head of the first. The sum goes from the tail of the first to the head of the last. Or add components: $x$ with $x$, $y$ with $y$. If the two vectors are perpendicular, the size of the sum comes from the Pythagorean theorem.
boat rel. water4.0 m/scurrent 3.0 m/sboat rel. ground5.0 m/s36.9°river bank
A boat points straight across a river at 4.0 m/s relative to the water. The current carries it 3.0 m/s downstream, so relative to the ground it moves at 5.0 m/s, 36.9° downstream from straight across.

The river picture shows why perpendicular motions don't interfere. The crossing time depends only on the across component: for a river 120 m wide, $t = \frac{120}{4.0} = 30\ \text{s}$, current or no current. In those 30 s the current carries the boat $(3.0)(30) = 90\ \text{m}$ downstream.

Pause and think
A passenger on a smooth train moving at constant velocity drops a ball. She sees it fall straight down. What path does someone standing beside the track see?
I thought about it. Show me
A parabola, like a projectile, because in the ground frame the ball also has the train's horizontal velocity. Both observers measure the same acceleration, $g$ downward. Frames moving at constant velocity relative to each other always agree on accelerations.
Flying in a crosswind
A pilot wants to fly due north. The plane's airspeed (its speed relative to the air) is 250 km/h, and a wind blows toward the east at 50 km/h. (a) Which way must the plane point? (b) What is its speed relative to the ground?
plane rel. air250 km/hwind 50plane rel. ground245 km/h north11.5°N
The plane aims 11.5° into the wind. Head to tail, its velocity relative to the air plus the wind gives a ground velocity straight north.
  1. Write the relation: $\vec v_{P/G} = \vec v_{P/A} + \vec v_{A/G}$, where $\vec v_{A/G}$ is the wind, 50 km/h east, and $\vec v_{P/G}$ must point due north.
    Why?
    Name each velocity with its two letters before you draw anything. Mixing up "relative to the air" and "relative to the ground" is where this problem goes wrong.
  2. The east components must cancel, so the plane points partly west: $250\sin\theta = 50$, giving $\sin\theta = 0.20$ and $\theta = 11.5°$ west of north.
    Why?
    The ground velocity has no east-west part, so the plane must aim into the wind exactly enough to cancel it.
  3. (b) The north components are all that's left: $v_{P/G} = \sqrt{250^2 - 50^2} = 245\ \text{km/h}$.
    Why?
    The airspeed is the hypotenuse here, because the plane-relative-to-air vector is the one that is slanted.

Answer: (a) 11.5° west of north (b) about 245 km/h, due north

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Write v(plane, ground) = v(plane, air) + v(air, ground).
  2. The east-west parts must add to zero, so the plane aims west of north.
  3. The 250 km/h vector is the hypotenuse of the triangle.
Check yourself
Rain falls straight down at 8.0 m/s relative to the ground. You drive at 6.0 m/s. Relative to you, how fast does the rain move?
  1. A2.0 m/s
  2. B6.0 m/s
  3. C10 m/s
  4. D14 m/s
Show the answer

C. $\vec v_{R/C} = \vec v_{R/G} - \vec v_{C/G}$: 8.0 m/s down plus 6.0 m/s backward, which are perpendicular, so $\sqrt{8.0^2 + 6.0^2} = 10\ \text{m/s}$, slanting toward you at 36.9° from vertical. Choices A and D treat perpendicular vectors as if they lay on one line.

  • $\vec v_{A/G} = \vec v_{A/B} + \vec v_{B/G}$: the inner letters match.
  • Draw relative velocities head to tail, or add components.
  • Perpendicular motions are independent: the crossing time depends only on the across component.
  • Frames moving at constant velocity relative to each other measure the same acceleration.