AP Physics C: E&M · Unit 12 lecture · Part 7 of 10 · 8 min

12.3 Superposition and forces between currentsTwo wires: adding fields, feeling forces

Mr. Thompkins
Two wires side by side. Each makes a field, and each sits in the other's field. So we get two questions: what's the total field somewhere, and what force does each wire feel? Fields add as vectors, so direction is everything here.

Magnetic fields obey superposition: the field of several currents is the vector sum of their separate fields. With long straight wires, find each wire's field at the point with $B = \frac{\mu_0 I}{2\pi r}$, give each its direction with the right-hand grip rule, then add as vectors.

?Wait, how do I find the direction of a wire's field at a point?
The field is tangent to a circle around the wire. Use the right-hand grip rule, or the cross product: the direction of $\hat I \times \hat r$, where $\hat r$ points from the wire to the point. For a current out of the page ($\hat z$) and a point to its right ($\hat x$): $\hat z \times \hat x = \hat y$, up the page.
8.0 A out4.0 A inM$B_1$$B_2$Q6.0 cm3.0 cm
Two long wires seen end on, 6.0 cm apart. Between them, at M, both fields point up the page and add. At Q, beyond the 4.0 A wire, they point opposite ways.
Fields and forces of two wires
Two long parallel wires are 6.0 cm apart. The left one carries 8.0 A out of the page and the right one 4.0 A into the page. Find (a) the field at the midpoint M, (b) the field at Q, 3.0 cm to the right of the right wire, (c) the force per meter on each wire, with directions, and (d) the point on the line through the wires where the field is zero.
  1. (a) At M each wire is 3.0 cm away. $B_1 = \frac{(4\pi \times 10^{-7})(8.0)}{2\pi(0.030)} = 53\ \mu$T and $B_2 = \frac{(4\pi \times 10^{-7})(4.0)}{2\pi(0.030)} = 27\ \mu$T. Left wire, out of the page, point to its right: up. Right wire, into the page, point to its left: $(-\hat z) \times (-\hat x) = \hat z \times \hat x = +\hat y$, also up. Total: 80 μT up.
    Why?
    Opposite currents make fields that add between the wires. That surprises a lot of students, so check it with the cross product.
  2. (b) At Q: $B_1 = \frac{\mu_0(8.0)}{2\pi(0.090)} = 17.8\ \mu$T up (still to the right of the left wire). $B_2 = \frac{\mu_0(4.0)}{2\pi(0.030)} = 26.7\ \mu$T, and for a point to the right of an into-the-page current, $(-\hat z) \times \hat x = -\hat y$: down. Net: 8.9 μT down.
  3. (c) Wire 2 sits in wire 1's field $B_1 = \frac{\mu_0(8.0)}{2\pi(0.060)} = 26.7\ \mu$T (up). $\frac{F}{L} = I_2B_1 = (4.0)(2.67 \times 10^{-5}) = 1.1 \times 10^{-4}$ N/m. Direction: $I_2$ along $-\hat z$, B along $+\hat y$: $(-\hat z) \times \hat y = +\hat x$, away from wire 1. They repel, and wire 1 feels the same $1.1 \times 10^{-4}$ N/m to the left.
    Why?
    The forces are a Newton's third law pair: equal and opposite even though the currents differ.
  4. (d) The fields can only cancel where they point opposite ways, outside the pair, and nearer the weaker wire: to the right of the 4.0 A wire at distance x from the 8.0 A wire. $\frac{8.0}{x} = \frac{4.0}{x - 6.0}$ gives $x = 12$ cm, 6.0 cm beyond the right wire.

Answer: (a) 80 μT up (b) 8.9 μT down (c) $1.1 \times 10^{-4}$ N/m, repulsive (d) 12 cm from the 8.0 A wire, on the far side of the 4.0 A wire.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Find each wire's field size first with μ₀I/(2πr).
  2. Then the direction of each: Î × r̂, with r̂ from the wire to the point.
  3. For the force, put wire 2 in wire 1's field and use F/L = I₂B₁.
012345604080120160200x (cm from the 8.0 A wire)B (μT, up the page)M: 80 μTweakest
The field between the two wires (both parts point up). It is never zero between them, and is weakest a little right of the middle, nearer the smaller current.

The general result for two long parallel wires a distance d apart: $\frac{F}{L} = \frac{\mu_0 I_1 I_2}{2\pi d}$. Currents in the same direction attract; currents in opposite directions repel. That's backwards from charges, so don't trust the analogy: trust the cross product.

$I_1$ out$I_2$ outattractsame direction: attract(opposite directions would repel)$\frac{F}{L} = \frac{\mu_0 I_1 I_2}{2\pi d}$
Same-direction currents attract; opposite currents repel. The force per length is the same on both wires.
Pause and think
Two parallel wires carry currents in the same direction. The current in one is tripled. By what factor does the force on the other wire change? On the first?
I thought about it. Show me
Both forces triple. $\frac{F}{L} = \frac{\mu_0 I_1I_2}{2\pi d}$ is proportional to the product of the currents, and the two forces are a third-law pair, so they're always equal in size.
?Wait, what does Newton's third law say again?
If object A pushes on object B, then B pushes on A with a force of the same size in the opposite direction. The two forces act on different objects. Here wire 1 pushes on wire 2 and wire 2 pushes back equally, whatever their currents.
Check yourself
Two long parallel wires 2.0 cm apart each carry 10 A in the same direction. What is the force per meter between them, and is it attractive or repulsive?
  1. A$1.0 \times 10^{-3}$ N/m, attractive
  2. B$1.0 \times 10^{-3}$ N/m, repulsive
  3. C$2.0 \times 10^{-3}$ N/m, attractive
  4. D$5.0 \times 10^{-4}$ N/m, attractive
Show the answer

A. $\frac{F}{L} = \frac{(4\pi \times 10^{-7})(10)(10)}{2\pi(0.020)} = 1.0 \times 10^{-3}$ N/m, and same-direction currents attract. Choice B carries over the "like charges repel" rule, which is backward for currents.

  • Fields add as vectors: find each size, each direction, then add.
  • Parallel wires: $\frac{F}{L} = \frac{\mu_0 I_1I_2}{2\pi d}$. Same direction attract, opposite repel.
  • The two forces are a third-law pair: equal sizes even with unequal currents.
  • Between opposite currents the fields add; a zero field can only sit outside, nearer the weaker current.