AP Physics C: E&M · Unit 12 lecture · Part 4 of 10 · 7 min

12.2 Electric and magnetic forces togetherCrossed fields and the velocity selector

Mr. Thompkins
What happens when a charge flies through an electric field and a magnetic field at the same time? Usually a messy curve. But arrange the fields just right and you get a filter that lets through only particles of one exact speed.

The total electromagnetic force on a charge is the sum: $\vec F = q\vec E + q\vec v \times \vec B$. The electric part doesn't care about motion. The magnetic part does. Point $\vec E$ and $\vec B$ perpendicular to each other and to the beam, oriented so the two forces are opposite. Then a particle goes straight through only if the forces balance: $qE = qvB$, so $v = \frac{E}{B}$.

?Wait, what's the field between two parallel plates?
Between large parallel plates the electric field is uniform, pointing from the + plate to the − plate, with size $E = \frac{\Delta V}{d}$ where d is the plate separation. You found that in Units 9 and 10.
+−××××××××$\vec E$$qvB$$qE$$\vec v$straight through only if $v = E/B$
E points down (from the + plate to the − plate), B points into the page. On a positive ion moving right, qE points down and qv × B points up.

Notice what cancelled: the charge. A velocity selector chooses a speed, not a charge or a mass. Particles that are too fast feel a bigger magnetic force and bend toward it; particles that are too slow are bent by the electric force. That's why selectors sit at the front of mass spectrometers: first pick one speed, then let the magnetic field sort by mass.

?Wait, why can we ignore gravity on an ion?
Compare sizes. A proton's weight is $m_pg = (1.67 \times 10^{-27})(9.8) = 1.6 \times 10^{-26}$ N. In a 2.0 × 10⁴ V/m field the electric force is $eE = 3.2 \times 10^{-15}$ N, about $10^{11}$ times bigger. Gravity is far too small to matter for charged particles in these fields.
$F_B = qvB$$F_E = qE$
Free-body diagram of an ion that goes straight through: two equal and opposite forces. No gravity: for ions it is far too small to matter.
Pause and think
In the selector above, an electron enters moving right at exactly v = E/B. Does it go straight?
I thought about it. Show me
Yes. Both forces flip direction for a negative charge (qE now points up, qv × B down), but they still have equal sizes. The balance condition has no q in it.
Design a selector
Two plates 1.5 cm apart have 300 V across them, and a 0.050 T magnetic field is set up perpendicular to the electric field, as in the figure. (a) What speed passes straight through? (b) Past the plates, the protons that made it through enter a region with only the 0.050 T field. Find the radius of their circle. (c) A proton enters the selector a little faster than the speed in (a). Which way does it bend at first, and why?
  1. (a) $E = \frac{\Delta V}{d} = \frac{300}{0.015} = 2.0 \times 10^4$ V/m. Balance: $v = \frac{E}{B} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^4}{0.050} = 4.0 \times 10^5$ m/s.
    Why?
    Write the balance in symbols first, $qE = qvB$, then cancel q. That line is the rubric point.
  2. (b) $r = \frac{m_pv}{eB} = \frac{(1.67 \times 10^{-27})(4.0 \times 10^5)}{(1.6 \times 10^{-19})(0.050)} = 0.084$ m.
  3. (c) Up, toward the magnetic force. The electric force qE doesn't depend on speed, but the magnetic force qvB grows with v, so for a faster proton the upward magnetic force wins.
    Why?
    Name both forces and say which one depends on speed. That's the justification.

Answer: (a) $4.0 \times 10^5$ m/s (b) 8.4 cm (c) It bends up, toward the magnetic force, because qvB > qE when v > E/B.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. E between plates is ΔV/d. Watch the centimeters.
  2. Straight through means $qE = qvB$.
  3. For (c), which force grows if v grows?
Check yourself
In a velocity selector, the magnetic field is doubled and the electric field is left the same. What speed now passes straight through?
  1. AHalf the old speed
  2. BTwice the old speed
  3. CThe same speed
  4. DFour times the old speed
Show the answer

A. $v = E/B$, so doubling B halves the selected speed. The trap is "twice": a bigger magnetic force needs a slower particle to match the same electric force.

  • $\vec F = q\vec E + q\vec v \times \vec B$.
  • Crossed fields, straight path: $qE = qvB$, $v = E/B$, for any charge or mass.
  • Too fast: bends toward the magnetic force. Too slow: toward the electric force.
  • On free-body diagrams for ions and electrons, leave out gravity.