AP Physics 1 · Unit 7 lecture · Part 2 of 11 · 8 min

7.1 The pendulum as an approximate SHMWhy a pendulum is (almost) a spring

Mr. Thompkins
A pendulum has no spring at all. So where does its restoring force come from, and is it really proportional to the displacement? Let's look closely, because the answer comes with a catch the exam loves.

A simple pendulum is a small, heavy bob on a light string of length $L$, swinging from a fixed point. In the model we treat the bob as a point mass and the string as massless. Two forces act on the bob: the tension $F_T$ along the string toward the pivot, and gravity $mg$ straight down.

?Wait, how do I split gravity into components on a slope?
On a ramp tilted at angle θ, gravity's component along the ramp is $mg\sin\theta$ and its component into the ramp is $mg\cos\theta$. The pendulum works the same way: tilt the "ramp" so it's tangent to the bob's path, and the angle of the string from vertical plays the role of θ.

The bob moves along a circular arc. The tension always points along the string, perpendicular to the arc, so it doesn't push the bob along the path. Gravity has two parts: one along the string (balanced, together with the tension, by what's needed to keep the bob on its circle) and one along the arc, $mg\sin\theta$, pointing back toward the bottom. That tangential part is the restoring force.

$mg$$mg\sin\theta$$F_T$θLrestoring force:the part of gravityalong the patharc length s = Lθ(θ in radians)
Forces on a pendulum bob pulled aside. The tension points along the string. The part of gravity along the path, mg sin θ, points back toward the bottom: that is the restoring force. (Drawn at 30° so the arrows show.)
?Wait, what's a radian?
A radian measures an angle by arc length: $\theta = \frac{s}{L}$, the arc length divided by the radius. A full circle is $2\pi$ radians, so $180° = \pi$ rad and $1\ \text{rad} \approx 57.3°$. Any formula that mixes an angle with a length, like $s = L\theta$, needs θ in radians.

The bob's displacement from equilibrium, measured along its path, is the arc length $s = L\theta$. For SHM we need the restoring force to be proportional to $s$, which means proportional to θ. But the force is $mg\sin\theta$, and $\sin\theta$ is not proportional to θ. Here's the catch, and here's the rescue: for small angles, $\sin\theta$ is almost exactly equal to θ in radians.

Angleθ (rad)sin θError of sin θ ≈ θ
5°0.0870.0870.1%
10°0.1750.1740.5%
15°0.2620.2591.2%
20°0.3490.3422.1%
30°0.5240.5004.7%
60°1.0470.86621%
How good is sin θ ≈ θ? Under about 15° the error is around 1% or less. By 60° it is off by about a fifth.
00.20.40.60.811.200.20.40.60.811.2θ (rad)restoring force ÷ mgmodel: θreal: sin θ
The real restoring force (blue, sin θ) and the straight-line model (orange, θ), both divided by mg. They agree closely for small angles and peel apart for large ones. The dashed line marks 15°.

So for small angles the restoring force is $F \approx -mg\theta = -\frac{mg}{L}s$. That is exactly the spring law, $F = -kx$, with an "effective spring constant" $k_{eff} = \frac{mg}{L}$ and the arc length $s$ playing the role of $x$. A small-angle pendulum is a simple harmonic oscillator. A big-angle pendulum still swings back and forth, but it is only approximately simple harmonic, and the larger the angle the worse the approximation. The usual rule of thumb is about 15° or less.

Beyond the course, as a bonus: at large angles $\sin\theta$ is smaller than θ, so the real restoring force is weaker than the model's, and the pendulum takes a little longer per swing than the small-angle formula predicts. At 60° the real period is about 7% longer.

Pause and think
Why does the "small angles only" warning apply to a pendulum but not to an ideal spring?
I thought about it. Show me
An ideal spring's force is exactly proportional to its stretch, $F = -kx$, at any amplitude, so it is exactly SHM. A pendulum's restoring force is $mg\sin\theta$, which is only close to proportional when θ is small. The spring is SHM by design; the pendulum is SHM by approximation.
How close is the small-angle model?
A 0.50 kg bob hangs on a 1.2 m string and is pulled 12° from vertical. (a) Find the restoring force exactly. (b) Find the bob's displacement along its arc. (c) Use the small-angle model, $F \approx \frac{mg}{L}s$, to estimate the restoring force, and compare.
  1. (a) $F = mg\sin\theta = (0.50)(9.8)\sin 12° = 1.02\ \text{N}$, toward the bottom.
    Why?
    Only the component of gravity along the path restores. The tension is perpendicular to the path.
  2. (b) Convert the angle: $12° \times \frac{\pi}{180°} = 0.209\ \text{rad}$. Then $s = L\theta = (1.2)(0.209) = 0.251\ \text{m}$.
    Why?
    $s = L\theta$ works only in radians. Plugging in 12 would give an arc of 14.4 m on a 1.2 m string, which is a good sign something's off.
  3. (c) $k_{eff} = \frac{mg}{L} = \frac{(0.50)(9.8)}{1.2} = 4.08\ \text{N/m}$, so $F \approx (4.08)(0.251) = 1.03\ \text{N}$.
  4. Compare: 1.03 N versus 1.02 N, a difference under 1%. At 12° the pendulum behaves like a mass on a spring.
    Why?
    This is the justification the exam wants when it asks why a pendulum can be modeled as SHM: the restoring force is very nearly proportional to the displacement for small angles.

Answer: (a) 1.02 N. (b) 0.251 m. (c) About 1.03 N, within 1% of the exact value, so the small-angle model works well at 12°.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Which force, or which part of a force, points along the arc?
  2. Convert 12° to radians before using $s = L\theta$.
  3. Multiply $\frac{mg}{L}$ by the arc length and compare with $mg\sin\theta$.
Check yourself
A pendulum is pulled back 40° and released. Which statement is most accurate?
  1. AIt does not oscillate, because there is no spring.
  2. BIt oscillates, but its restoring force is not close to proportional to its displacement, so it is only roughly simple harmonic and the small-angle period formula is less accurate.
  3. CIt is exactly simple harmonic, because gravity is constant.
  4. DIt is simple harmonic only if the bob is heavy enough.
Show the answer

B. At 40°, $\sin\theta$ is about 8% smaller than θ in radians, so the restoring force is noticeably less than proportional. The motion still repeats, but it is not well modeled as SHM. "Gravity is constant" is the trap: gravity is constant, but the part of it along the path, $mg\sin\theta$, changes with angle.

  • Pendulum restoring force: $mg\sin\theta$, the part of gravity along the path. Tension does not restore.
  • Small angles (about 15° or less): $\sin\theta \approx \theta$ in radians, so $F \approx -\frac{mg}{L}s$. The pendulum is SHM with $k_{eff} = \frac{mg}{L}$.
  • Large angles: still periodic, but not simple harmonic.
  • Arc length $s = L\theta$, with θ in radians.