AP Biology · Unit 7 lecture · Part 9 of 12 · 9 min

7.9 PhylogenyFamily trees for species

Mrs. Otero
Is a frog more closely related to a shark or to a mouse? Most people say shark, because both swim. The tree we're about to build says mouse, and you'll be able to prove it.

Phylogenetic trees and cladograms show hypotheses about evolutionary relationships that can be tested. Each tip is a group. Each branch point, a node, is the most recent common ancestor of the groups that branch from it. The root is the common ancestor of everything on the tree. The exam's favorite difference: a phylogenetic tree shows the amount of change over time, calibrated by fossils or a molecular clock, while a cladogram shows only the branching order, with no time scale.

?Wait, how can DNA be a clock?
If mutations build up at a roughly steady rate, the number of differences between two species tracks the time since they split. Calibrate with fossils of known age, and differences become millions of years.

Trees are built from traits gained or lost during evolution. The useful ones are shared derived characters: traits that evolved in an ancestor and are shared by its descendants, like hair in mammals. A trait every group has can't separate them. The out-group is the lineage least closely related to the rest, and it shows the ancestral state.

?Wait, ancestral or derived?
An ancestral trait was present in the common ancestor of the whole group. A derived trait evolved later, along one branch. For vertebrates, a backbone is ancestral and hair is derived.
AnimalJawsFour limbsAmniotic eggHair
Lampreynononono
Sharkyesnonono
Frogyesyesnono
Lizardyesyesyesno
Mouseyesyesyesyes
A character table for five vertebrates. The lamprey has none of the derived traits, so it is the out-group.
Build a cladogram
Use the character table to build a cladogram for the five animals, and mark where each trait appeared.
  1. Count derived traits: lamprey 0, shark 1, frog 2, lizard 3, mouse 4.
    Why?
    More shared derived traits, later branching.
  2. The lamprey, with none, is the out-group on the first branch.
    Why?
    Least closely related to the others.
  3. Mark jaws after the lamprey branches, then four limbs after the shark, the amniotic egg after the frog, and hair after the lizard.
    Why?
    Each trait goes where it first appeared, and everything above the mark has it. The traits nest inside each other.

Answer: Branching order: lamprey, shark, frog, lizard, mouse, with jaws, four limbs, amniotic egg and hair marked in that order.

lampreysharkfroglizardmousejawsfour limbsamniotic egghairoutgrouproot
The cladogram from the table. Each colored mark is where a derived trait first appeared; every group above a mark has it.
Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Count the 'yes' traits for each animal.
  2. Zero traits means out-group.
  3. Place each trait just before the first group that has it.
Pause and think
On this tree, is the frog closer to the shark or the mouse?
I thought about it. Show me
The mouse. Trace back: the frog and mouse meet at the four-limb node, which is more recent than the node the frog shares with the shark. The most recent shared node decides relatedness, not looks or habitat.

Two warnings. A tree can be rotated at any node without changing what it says, so the order of the tips means nothing; only the nodes matter. And don't read across the tips: living groups are cousins, not ancestors of each other.

ABCCBAsame treeorange node: A and B share it
The same tree drawn two ways. A and B still share the orange node, so the relationships are identical.

Trees can be built from the morphology of living or fossil species, or from DNA and protein similarities. Molecular data usually give more reliable trees, because similar bodies can evolve independently. And trees are hypotheses, constantly revised with new evidence.

Tree from molecules
The table gives nucleotide differences in one gene among species W, X, Y and Z. (a) Which two are most closely related? (b) Describe the tree. (c) Which is the best out-group?
WXYZ
W-31528
X3-1427
Y1514-26
Z282726-
  1. (a) W and X: only 3 differences.
    Why?
    Fewest differences, most recent split.
  2. (b) Y is 14 to 15 from W and X, so it joins that pair at an older node. Z is 26 to 28 from everyone, so it branches first: (Z, (Y, (W, X))).
    Why?
    Join the closest pair, then add the next closest.
  3. (c) Z, the least closely related to the others.

Answer: (a) W and X. (b) Z first, then Y, then W and X. (c) Z.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Find the smallest number.
  2. Which species is about equally far from W and X?
  3. The one far from everyone branches first.
Check yourself
On a cladogram, P and Q share a node more recent than the node either shares with R. Which statement is supported?
  1. AR is the ancestor of P and Q.
  2. BP and Q share a more recent common ancestor with each other than with R.
  3. CP evolved from Q.
  4. DR has changed less over time than P and Q.
Show the answer

B. A node is a most recent common ancestor. Living species aren't each other's ancestors, and cladogram branch lengths say nothing about how much a lineage changed.

Exam tip from Mrs. O

Put a finger on each of two tips, trace back to where they meet, and say 'they share a more recent common ancestor'. That's the language that earns the point.

  • Trees and cladograms are testable hypotheses, revised with new evidence.
  • Phylogenetic trees show change over time (fossils, molecular clock); cladograms show only branching order.
  • A node is a most recent common ancestor. Relatedness comes from the most recent shared node, not tip order.
  • Shared derived characters build trees; the out-group is least related. Molecular data are usually more reliable than morphology.