AP Biology · Unit 7 lecture · Part 10 of 12 · 8 min

7.10 SpeciationHow one species becomes two

Mrs. Otero
Apple trees came to North America with European settlers. Since then, some fruit flies that laid eggs only on hawthorn fruit have switched to apples, and apple flies and hawthorn flies are splitting into separate groups in the same orchards. Let's see how a species is born.

The biological species concept defines a species, for sexually reproducing organisms, as a group capable of interbreeding and exchanging genetic information to produce viable, fertile offspring. Viable means the offspring survive; fertile means they can reproduce. Speciation happens when two populations become reproductively isolated, so gene flow stops and mutation, drift and selection act on each one separately.

?Wait, why does stopping gene flow matter?
From Topic 7.4: gene flow keeps populations alike by mixing their alleles. Without it, each population's allele frequencies change on their own, and they grow apart.

Allopatric speciation happens in populations that are geographically isolated: a river changes course, mountains rise, a few individuals reach an island. Sympatric speciation happens in populations with geographic overlap. Something other than distance blocks gene flow: a switch to a new host (the apple maggot fly mates on its host fruit), a different breeding season, or, often in plants, polyploidy.

allopatricsympatricone populationgroup 1group 2species 1species 2river splits themone populationsame areaspecies 1species 2no physical barrier
Allopatric speciation (a physical barrier splits the population) and sympatric speciation (groups in the same area stop interbreeding).
?Wait, what's polyploidy?
Having more than two sets of chromosomes, often from nondisjunction (Unit 5). A tetraploid plant crossed with its diploid parent gives sterile triploid offspring, so the tetraploid is instantly isolated.

Prezygotic and postzygotic mechanisms maintain reproductive isolation. A zygote is the fertilized egg. Prezygotic barriers stop mating or fertilization; postzygotic barriers act after a hybrid zygote forms, which fails to develop or grows into an adult that can't reproduce well.

BarrierWhen it actsExample
Habitat isolationPrezygoticOne frog breeds in ponds, the other in streams
Temporal isolationPrezygoticOne flower opens in April, the other in June
Behavioral isolationPrezygoticFemales answer only their own species' song
Mechanical isolationPrezygoticReproductive parts do not fit together
Gametic isolationPrezygoticSperm cannot bind to and fuse with the egg
Reduced hybrid viabilityPostzygoticHybrid embryos die before birth
Reduced hybrid fertilityPostzygoticA mule (horse × donkey) is healthy but sterile
Hybrid breakdownPostzygoticHybrids are fertile, but their offspring are weak or sterile
Reproductive barriers, before and after fertilization.
Pause and think
A horse and a donkey produce a mule, which is healthy but sterile. Same species? Which barrier?
I thought about it. Show me
Different species, because the offspring isn't fertile. The barrier is postzygotic: reduced hybrid fertility.
Classify the barrier
Classify each and name it. (a) Two crickets in the same field sing different songs, and females approach only their own. (b) Two pines release pollen in different months. (c) Two salamanders mate, but hybrid embryos die early. (d) One sea urchin's sperm can't bind another species' eggs.
  1. (a) Prezygotic, behavioral isolation.
    Why?
    The song stops mating before it starts.
  2. (b) Prezygotic, temporal isolation.
  3. (c) Postzygotic, reduced hybrid viability.
    Why?
    A zygote formed, so it's after fertilization.
  4. (d) Prezygotic, gametic isolation.
    Why?
    Gametes meet but can't fuse, so no zygote forms.

Answer: (a) Behavioral, (b) temporal, (d) gametic: all prezygotic. (c) Reduced hybrid viability: postzygotic.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. First ask: did a zygote form?
  2. If not, what stopped it: place, time, behavior, body parts or gametes?
  3. If yes, did the hybrid die, or was it sterile?

Tempo and pattern

Gradualism is evolution occurring slowly over hundreds of thousands or millions of years. Punctuated equilibrium is evolution occurring rapidly after a long period of stasis. Divergent evolution happens when adaptation to new habitats causes phenotypic diversification, and speciation can be especially fast during an adaptive radiation, when new habitats open up, as with Hawaii's hundreds of fruit fly species or the Caribbean's Anolis lizards. Convergent evolution happens when similar selective pressures produce similar adaptations in different species, like the same leg-length body forms evolving separately in Anolis on different islands.

0123456789100123456time (millions of years)trait sizegradualismpunctuated
Two tempos. Gradualism: slow, steady change. Punctuated equilibrium: long stasis, short bursts.
Check yourself
A canyon splits a mouse population. Generations later, mice from the two sides meet but don't mate, because their courtship differs. This is
  1. Asympatric speciation with a postzygotic barrier
  2. Ballopatric speciation with a prezygotic barrier
  3. Callopatric speciation with a postzygotic barrier
  4. Dgene flow preventing speciation
Show the answer

B. A canyon is a geographic barrier (allopatric), and different courtship stops mating before fertilization (prezygotic, behavioral). No hybrids formed, so postzygotic is the trap.

Check yourself
Dolphins (mammals) and sharks (fish) both have streamlined bodies and fins. This is best explained by
  1. Aa recent common ancestor
  2. Bconvergent evolution under similar selective pressures
  3. Cgene flow between the groups
  4. Dadaptive radiation from a shark ancestor
Show the answer

B. Similar pressures in water produced similar shapes in unrelated lineages. Their skeletons and DNA place dolphins with mammals.

  • Biological species concept: can interbreed and produce viable, fertile offspring.
  • Speciation needs reproductive isolation. Allopatric: geographic separation. Sympatric: same area (host shift, timing, polyploidy).
  • Prezygotic: habitat, temporal, behavioral, mechanical, gametic. Postzygotic: reduced hybrid viability, reduced hybrid fertility, hybrid breakdown.
  • Gradualism versus punctuated equilibrium. Divergent evolution and adaptive radiation diversify; convergent evolution makes unrelated species similar.