AP Biology · Unit 5 lecture · Part 3 of 12 · 8 min

5.2 Meiosis and genetic diversityWhy no two gametes match

Mrs. Otero
Think about brothers and sisters with the same two parents. They can look surprisingly different. Meiosis is the reason: it shuffles your parents' chromosomes so thoroughly that every gamete you make is a new combination.

When meiosis works correctly, each gamete gets exactly one chromosome from every homologous pair, a complete haploid set. But which ones it gets is left to chance. Three processes make every gamete, and every child, genetically unique.

1. Independent assortment of homologs

At metaphase I, each homologous pair lines up at the plate on its own. Whether the maternal homolog of one pair faces the left pole has nothing to do with how the next pair lines up. Picture a cell with two pairs: a long pair carrying alleles A and a, and a short pair carrying B and b. There are two equally likely ways to line them up, and together they make four kinds of gametes.

AaBbAabBABabAbaBarrangement 1gametes AB and abarrangement 2gametes Ab and aBequally likely:4 kinds of gametes
Two pairs of homologs can line up in two ways at metaphase I. Each way gives two kinds of gametes, so the cell can make AB, ab, Ab and aB gametes in equal numbers.

With n pairs of homologs, the number of possible combinations is $2^n$, because each pair has 2 orientations and the choices multiply. Humans have 23 pairs, so one person can make $2^{23} = 8{,}388{,}608$ different combinations of chromosomes in their gametes, before crossing over adds even more.

?Wait, why multiply the choices?
When two independent choices are made one after the other, the number of combinations is the product. Two shirts and three pairs of pants make $2 \times 3 = 6$ outfits. Each homologous pair is a two-way choice, so n pairs give $2 \times 2 \times \dots \times 2 = 2^n$.
gamete combinations = 2 to the n2n = 14n = 28n = 316n = 432n = 564n = 6
Combinations of chromosomes in gametes from independent assortment alone. The number doubles with every extra pair.

2. Crossing over

In prophase I, while homologs are paired, non-sister chromatids can break at matching spots and swap segments. The result is a recombinant chromatid: part maternal, part paternal, carrying a combination of alleles that neither parent's chromosome had. Crossing over mixes alleles on the same chromosome, while independent assortment mixes whole chromosomes.

prophase I: one chiasmaAaBbnon-sister chromatidsswap matching piecesABAbaBabparentalrecombinantrecombinantparentaltwo old combinations, two new
One crossover between the genes A and B. Two chromatids keep the parental combinations (AB and ab); two are recombinant (Ab and aB).
?Wait, what's an allele again?
An allele is one version of a gene. A gene for seed color might have a yellow allele and a green allele. Each diploid cell has two alleles for each gene, one on each homolog, and they can be the same or different.
Pause and think
Crossing over happens between non-sister chromatids. Why wouldn't a swap between two sister chromatids add any variation?
I thought about it. Show me
Sister chromatids are identical copies, so swapping matching pieces between them changes nothing: the chromatids end up with exactly the alleles they started with. Only swaps between homologs, which can carry different alleles, create new combinations.

3. Random fertilization

Finally, any one of a father's millions of sperm combinations can fertilize any one of a mother's. Ignoring crossing over, two human parents can produce $2^{23} \times 2^{23} = 2^{46}$, about $7.0 \times 10^{13}$ (70 trillion) chromosome combinations in a child. That's why siblings, other than identical twins, are never genetically the same.

Count the combinations
A plant species has 2n = 6. Ignoring crossing over: (a) How many genetically different gametes can one plant make? (b) What is the probability that a gamete gets all three chromosomes that came from the plant's mother? (c) How many chromosome combinations are possible in the offspring of two such plants?
  1. (a) n = 3 pairs. Each pair can line up 2 ways, so $2^3 = 8$ kinds of gametes.
    Why?
    Use n, the number of pairs, not 2n. Using 6 would give 64, a common error.
  2. (b) For each pair, the chance the maternal homolog goes into a given gamete is 1/2. Three independent pairs: $\frac12 \times \frac12 \times \frac12 = \frac18$.
    Why?
    Only one of the 8 combinations is all maternal.
  3. (c) Any of 8 egg types can meet any of 8 sperm types: $8 \times 8 = 64$ combinations.
    Why?
    Random fertilization multiplies the possibilities from each parent.
  4. Crossing over would make the real numbers much larger, because it creates new chromosome versions that neither parent had.

Answer: (a) 8. (b) 1/8. (c) 64, before crossing over adds more.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. How many homologous pairs are there when 2n = 6?
  2. Each pair is a coin flip at metaphase I.
  3. Gametes: 2 to the n. Offspring: gametes from one parent times gametes from the other.
Check yourself
A species has 2n = 10. Ignoring crossing over, how many genetically different gametes can one individual produce?
  1. A10
  2. B25
  3. C32
  4. D1,024
Show the answer

C. n = 5 pairs, so $2^5 = 32$. 1,024 is $2^{10}$: it uses 2n instead of n, the most common trap. 25 squares the number of pairs, which is not how independent choices combine.

Check yourself
Which pairing of process and phase correctly explains how meiosis produces genetic variation?
  1. ACrossing over between sister chromatids in anaphase II
  2. BIndependent assortment of homologous pairs in metaphase I
  3. CReplication of DNA in prophase I
  4. DSeparation of sister chromatids in metaphase I
Show the answer

B. Homologous pairs orient independently at metaphase I, which shuffles whole chromosomes. Crossing over is real, but it happens between non-sister chromatids in prophase I, not between sisters in anaphase II. DNA replicates in S phase, before meiosis starts.

Exam tip from Mrs. O

If an FRQ asks how sexual reproduction increases variation, name the process and its phase: "crossing over between homologs in prophase I" and "independent assortment of homologous pairs in metaphase I", plus random fertilization. The phase is often part of the point.

  • Three sources of variation: crossing over (prophase I), independent assortment (metaphase I), random fertilization.
  • Independent assortment gives 2 to the n combinations; humans: 2 to the 23 = 8,388,608 per person.
  • Crossing over swaps segments between non-sister chromatids of homologs, making recombinant chromosomes.
  • Correct meiosis gives every gamete a complete haploid set; which homolog of each pair it gets is random.