AP Biology · Unit 5 lecture · Part 4 of 12 · 6 min

5.2 Nondisjunction and chromosome inheritanceWhen chromosomes don't separate

Mrs. Otero
Meiosis usually runs perfectly, but not always. When it slips, a gamete ends up with one chromosome too many or too few. Working out where the slip happened is a favorite exam puzzle, and it's very solvable once you see the pattern.

Nondisjunction is a failure of chromosomes to separate properly. In meiosis I, it means a pair of homologs moves to the same pole instead of opposite poles. In meiosis II, it means two sister chromatids fail to separate. Either way, the gametes no longer carry exactly one of each chromosome.

?Wait, what does n + 1 mean?
It means one chromosome more than the normal haploid number: the gamete has two copies of one chromosome. n − 1 means one fewer: one chromosome is missing. A cell with the wrong number of chromosomes is called aneuploid.
error in meiosis I6424422n + 1, n + 1n − 1, n − 1error in meiosis II6334233n + 1, n − 1n, n (normal)
Numbers are chromosomes per cell for a species with 2n = 6 (n = 3). An error in meiosis I makes all four gametes abnormal. An error in one cell in meiosis II leaves two normal gametes.

Notice the pattern. If homologs fail to separate in meiosis I, both cells that come out of meiosis I are already wrong, one with an extra chromosome and one missing it, and meiosis II passes that error on to all four gametes: two n + 1 and two n − 1. If meiosis I goes fine but sisters fail to separate in one cell during meiosis II, only that cell's two gametes are abnormal (one n + 1 and one n − 1), and the other two are normal.

When an abnormal gamete is fertilized by a normal one, the zygote is 2n + 1 (trisomy, three copies of one chromosome) or 2n − 1 (monosomy, one copy). In humans that's 47 or 45 chromosomes instead of 46. Most such embryos do not survive, but some do, with effects on development. A well-known example is trisomy 21, which causes Down syndrome. The AP exam does not ask you to memorize specific disorders, but it does expect you to connect a disorder to a chromosome error.

?Wait, what's a karyotype?
A karyotype is a picture of a cell's chromosomes, arranged in homologous pairs from largest to smallest. Doctors use it to count chromosomes, so an extra or missing chromosome shows up as a set of three or a lone single.

All of this is evidence that genes really are carried on chromosomes. When chromosomes go missing or come in extra copies, the traits controlled by their genes change in predictable ways. The idea that chromosomes carry genes and that their movement in meiosis explains inheritance is the chromosomal basis of inheritance, and the rest of this unit is built on it.

Pause and think
Why does a nondisjunction in meiosis I affect all four gametes, while one in meiosis II affects only two?
I thought about it. Show me
Meiosis I comes first, so its error is inherited by both cells that go on to meiosis II, and they pass it to all four gametes. A meiosis II error happens in only one of the two cells, so the other cell still makes two normal gametes.
Trace the error
A species has 2n = 8. A sperm with 5 chromosomes fertilizes a normal egg. (a) How many chromosomes does the zygote have, and what is this condition called? (b) If the error happened in meiosis I, what were the chromosome numbers of the other three sperm from the same meiosis? (c) If it happened in meiosis II, what were they?
  1. (a) Normal egg: n = 4. Zygote: 5 + 4 = 9 chromosomes, which is 2n + 1, a trisomy.
    Why?
    The extra copy of one chromosome came from the sperm.
  2. (b) Meiosis I error: one cell after meiosis I has 5, the other 3. Each splits its sisters normally in meiosis II, so the four sperm are 5, 5, 3, 3. The other three: 5, 3, 3.
    Why?
    All four gametes from a meiosis I error are abnormal.
  3. (c) Meiosis II error: meiosis I gave two normal cells of 4. One divided normally (4 and 4); the other failed to separate one pair of sisters (5 and 3). The other three sperm: 3, 4, 4.
    Why?
    A meiosis II error leaves two normal gametes from the other cell.

Answer: (a) 9 chromosomes, a trisomy (2n + 1). (b) 5, 3 and 3. (c) 3, 4 and 4.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Add the sperm and egg counts to get the zygote.
  2. In a meiosis I error, both cells after meiosis I are wrong: one has n + 1, one has n − 1.
  3. In a meiosis II error, the other cell from meiosis I is untouched and makes two normal gametes.
Check yourself
In a species with 2n = 6, one meiosis produces gametes with 4, 2, 3 and 3 chromosomes. What most likely happened?
  1. ANondisjunction of one pair of homologs in meiosis I
  2. BNondisjunction of one pair of sister chromatids in meiosis II
  3. CCrossing over between non-sister chromatids
  4. DDNA replication happened twice before meiosis
Show the answer

B. Two gametes are normal (n = 3), so meiosis I worked and the error was in one cell during meiosis II. A meiosis I error would make all four gametes abnormal (4, 4, 2, 2). Crossing over changes alleles, not chromosome number.

  • Nondisjunction: homologs (meiosis I) or sister chromatids (meiosis II) fail to separate.
  • Meiosis I error: all four gametes abnormal (two n + 1, two n − 1). Meiosis II error in one cell: one n + 1, one n − 1, two normal.
  • Fertilization with a normal gamete gives trisomy (2n + 1) or monosomy (2n − 1), which can cause genetic disorders.
  • Chromosome errors that change traits are evidence that genes ride on chromosomes.