AP Biology · Unit 4 lecture · Part 6 of 11 · 9 min

4.4 FeedbackStaying near the set point

Mrs. Otero
Your body temperature stays within about a degree of 37 °C whether you're in a snowstorm or a sauna. That's feedback at work, the most common control system in biology. There are only two kinds, and their names tell you exactly what they do.

Organisms use feedback mechanisms to keep their internal environments steady despite internal and external changes. In negative feedback, the response reduces the original stimulus. If a variable moves away from its set point, the response pushes it back toward the set point, and as it returns, the response shrinks. Negative feedback maintains homeostasis, and it works at the molecular, cellular and organismal levels.

?Wait, what's homeostasis?
Homeostasis is keeping internal conditions (temperature, blood glucose, water, pH) within a narrow, steady range even when conditions outside change. The target value is the set point.

Blood glucose is the classic example. After a meal, glucose rises. The pancreas senses it and releases insulin. Insulin signals liver, muscle and fat cells to take up glucose, and the liver stores the extra as glycogen. Glucose falls back toward the set point, and insulin release drops. If glucose falls too low, the pancreas releases a second hormone, glucagon, which signals the liver to break glycogen down and release glucose. Two hormones with opposite effects keep the level in a narrow range.

glucose highinsulin releasedcells take up glucoseglucose back to normalstimulus removedpancreas sensesliver stores glycogennegative feedback: the response cancels the stimulusglucose too low: glucagon does the opposite
A negative feedback loop. High glucose triggers insulin release; cells take up glucose; glucose returns to normal, which removes the stimulus for more insulin.
060120180240050100150200250300time after meal (min)blood glucose (mg/dL)set pointinsulin signaling worksno insulin responsepeak 150
Blood glucose after a meal (teaching model). With working insulin signaling, glucose peaks at 150 mg/dL at 40 minutes and returns toward the set point. Without an insulin response, it climbs and stays high.

Positive feedback does the opposite: the response amplifies the change. The variable moves further from where it started, which triggers more response, which pushes it further still. Positive feedback is used for processes that need to build to a big finish and then stop, ended by some outside event. In childbirth, the baby pressing on the cervix triggers oxytocin release, oxytocin causes stronger contractions, stronger contractions trigger more oxytocin, and the loop ends with birth. Lactation and fruit ripening are positive feedback too.

ExampleTypeWhat happens
Blood glucose (insulin, glucagon)NegativeThe hormone's effect pushes glucose back toward the set point
Body temperature (sweating, shivering)NegativeToo hot: sweat cools you. Too cold: shivering warms you
Plants short of waterNegativeStomata close, so less water is lost
Childbirth (oxytocin)PositiveContractions trigger more oxytocin, which triggers stronger contractions, until birth
LactationPositiveNursing stimulates milk release, which continues while nursing continues
Fruit ripening (ethylene)PositiveRipening fruit releases ethylene, which ripens more fruit
Negative and positive feedback examples from the course.
?Wait, how is a hormone part of a feedback loop?
A hormone is the signal that carries the message from the sensor (like the pancreas) to the effector cells (like liver cells). The effect of the hormone changes the variable the sensor is watching, which closes the loop.

When feedback fails, the results are usually harmful. In diabetes mellitus, either the pancreas makes too little insulin or cells don't respond to it, so blood glucose stays high after meals: the loop no longer brings it back. In Graves' disease, antibodies switch on the thyroid without the normal signal, so thyroid hormone stays high even though the loop should shut it off.

Pause and think
Is a fever-reducing shiver-and-sweat response an example of negative or positive feedback? What would happen if body temperature control were positive feedback instead?
I thought about it. Show me
Negative: when you're too hot you sweat, which cools you; too cold, you shiver, which warms you. Each response reverses the change. If it were positive feedback, getting warmer would trigger responses that made you warmer still, and temperature would spiral out of the safe range.
Analyze data (rate from a graph)
Use the glucose graph. (a) For the person with working insulin signaling, calculate the average rate of change in blood glucose from 40 to 180 minutes (glucose is 98.2 mg/dL at 180 minutes). (b) Identify the type of feedback shown and explain the shape of the curve. (c) Explain the curve for the person with no insulin response.
  1. (a) Rate = ΔY ÷ Δt = (98.2 − 150) ÷ (180 − 40) = −51.8 ÷ 140 ≈ −0.37 mg/dL per minute.
    Why?
    The negative sign tells you glucose is decreasing. Keep the units.
  2. (b) Negative feedback. The meal raises glucose above the set point; insulin is released and cells take up glucose, so the level falls back toward 90 mg/dL, and the fall slows as it gets close.
    Why?
    Name the type, then say how the response reverses the stimulus.
  3. (c) Without an insulin response, cells don't take up glucose in response to the signal, so nothing brings the level back: glucose climbs as the meal is absorbed and stays high. The negative feedback loop is broken.
    Why?
    This is the pattern in diabetes: the stimulus is never removed.

Answer: (a) About −0.37 mg/dL per minute. (b) Negative feedback returns glucose to its set point. (c) The broken loop leaves glucose high.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Read the two glucose values and the two times.
  2. Divide the change in glucose by the change in time.
  3. Does the response push glucose back toward 90, or further away?
Check yourself
Ethylene released by a ripening apple causes nearby apples to ripen and release more ethylene. This is an example of
  1. Anegative feedback, because it returns fruit to a set point
  2. Bpositive feedback, because the response amplifies the stimulus
  3. Cquorum sensing in bacteria
  4. Da steroid hormone pathway
Show the answer

B. More ripening produces more ethylene, which produces more ripening: the response amplifies the stimulus. Positive doesn't mean "good" and negative doesn't mean "bad"; the names describe what the response does to the stimulus.

  • Negative feedback reduces the stimulus and returns a variable to its set point (blood glucose with insulin and glucagon, body temperature, plant water balance).
  • Positive feedback amplifies the change until an outside event ends it (childbirth, lactation, fruit ripening).
  • Broken feedback causes disease, for example diabetes when insulin signaling fails.