AP Biology · Unit 4 lecture · Part 5 of 11 · 8 min

4.3 Changes in signal transduction pathwaysWhen a pathway breaks

Mrs. Otero
This is the section the exam loves most in Unit 4. A pathway is a chain, and a chain can break in two ways: stuck off, or stuck on. If you can trace a chain link by link, you can answer any of these questions.

Because each component passes the signal to the next, a change anywhere can change the response. A mutation in any domain of the receptor protein (the ligand-binding domain, the part that crosses the membrane, or the intracellular domain) or in any relay protein can alter how the signal is passed downstream. Chemicals that interact with any part of the pathway can activate it or inhibit it. That's how many drugs, toxins and diseases work.

Think about two kinds of breaks. Stuck off: a component can no longer be activated, so the response doesn't happen even when the ligand is present. A receptor that can't bind its ligand, or whose intracellular domain can't change shape, gives a stuck-off pathway. Stuck on: a component stays active all the time, so everything downstream runs even with no ligand. A relay protein that can't switch off gives a stuck-on pathway.

?Wait, what is a mutation?
A mutation is a change in the DNA sequence of a gene. It can change the amino acid sequence of the protein the gene codes for, which can change the protein's shape and function (Unit 1, structure and function). You'll study mutations in Unit 6.
?Wait, what does "downstream" mean?
Downstream means later in the pathway, closer to the response. Upstream means earlier, closer to the receptor. A break affects everything downstream of it but not the steps upstream.

Real examples. In one form of insulin resistance, insulin binds its receptor normally, but the signal isn't relayed, so cells don't take up glucose and blood glucose stays high: stuck off. The toxin made by cholera bacteria keeps a G protein in intestinal cells permanently active, so cAMP stays high and the cells pump out salt and water, causing severe diarrhea: stuck on. And many cancers start with a growth-signal pathway stuck on, telling cells to divide with no growth factor present.

normal receptor4%no signal30%signalmutant receptor28%no signal31%signal
Invented data: percent of cells in S phase (copying DNA, getting ready to divide). Normal cells respond to the growth signal; cells with a mutant receptor act as if signaled all the time.
Pause and think
Look at the mutant receptor data. Is that pathway stuck on or stuck off? Which bar is the strongest evidence?
I thought about it. Show me
Stuck on. The strongest evidence is the "no signal" bar for the mutant: 28% of cells are in S phase without any growth signal, close to the 30% of normal cells that got the signal. The pathway runs whether or not the ligand is present.
Predict and justify (the classic Unit 4 FRQ)
A growth factor binds a surface receptor, which starts a relay that leads cells past the G₁ checkpoint and into division. A mutation makes one relay protein in the middle of the pathway stay permanently active. (a) Describe the normal role of the growth factor. (b) Explain how the mutation affects the pathway when no growth factor is present. (c) Predict the effect on cell division and justify. (d) Would a drug that blocks the receptor fix the problem? Explain.
  1. (a) The growth factor is the ligand. It binds the receptor, which changes shape and starts transduction, so cells divide only when the signal is present.
  2. (b) The mutant relay protein is active on its own, so it passes the signal to every downstream component even though no ligand is bound. The pathway is stuck on.
    Why?
    Mechanism: a downstream component active without input from upstream.
  3. (c) The cells get a divide signal all the time, pass the G₁ checkpoint when they shouldn't, and divide repeatedly. A mass of cells (a tumor) could form.
    Why?
    Justify with the principle: a change in any component changes everything downstream of it.
  4. (d) No. The receptor is upstream of the mutant protein. Blocking it stops nothing, because the mutant protein is already active without any input from the receptor.
    Why?
    Upstream fixes can't repair a downstream break. A drug would need to block the mutant protein itself or something after it.

Answer: (a) It is the ligand that starts the pathway. (b) The pathway runs without the ligand. (c) Uncontrolled division. (d) No: the break is downstream of the receptor.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Is the broken protein before or after the receptor?
  2. Active all the time means the steps after it always run.
  3. Can blocking something upstream turn off a protein that's already stuck on?
Check yourself
A drug blocks the enzyme that breaks down cAMP in liver cells. After one dose of epinephrine, compared with untreated cells, glycogen breakdown will
  1. Astop completely
  2. Bbe unchanged
  3. Clast longer and release more glucose
  4. Dhappen only without epinephrine
Show the answer

C. cAMP isn't removed, so the kinase cascade stays active longer after the signal, and more glycogen is broken down. The pathway still needs epinephrine to start it, which rules out the last choice.

Exam tip from Mrs. O

For any "a component is changed" question, answer in three sentences: where the component is in the pathway, whether the change makes it stuck on or stuck off, and what happens to everything downstream (and to the cell).

  • A mutation in any domain of the receptor or in any relay protein can change the downstream signal.
  • Stuck off: no response even with ligand. Stuck on: response even with no ligand.
  • Drugs and toxins can activate or block a pathway (cholera toxin keeps a G protein on).
  • A break affects only the steps downstream of it.