AP Biology · Unit 2 lecture · Part 10 of 12 · 6 min

2.9 Cell compartmentalizationWhy walls inside the cell help

Mrs. Otero
Imagine cooking a stew and washing dishes with bleach in the same pot. That's a cell without compartments. Eukaryotic cells solved that problem with internal membranes.

In eukaryotic cells, internal membranes and membrane-bound organelles divide the cell into compartments, so specific metabolic processes and enzyme reactions happen in separate places. Compartmentalization helps the cell in two big ways.

First, it minimizes competing interactions. The hydrolytic enzymes inside a lysosome would digest the cell's own proteins if they were loose in the cytosol, so the lysosome membrane keeps them in. Reactions that build a molecule and reactions that break it down can run in different compartments without canceling each other out. Each compartment can also keep its own conditions, like the acidic interior of a lysosome.

Second, internal membranes add surface area where reactions can happen. Many enzymes and transport proteins work only while sitting in a membrane. The folded inner membrane of the mitochondrion and the stacked thylakoids of the chloroplast pack a lot of membrane into a small space, and a membrane is also what lets a compartment hold a gradient of H⁺, which both organelles use to make ATP (Unit 3).

?Wait, what does pH have to do with this?
pH measures H⁺ concentration: lower pH, more H⁺, more acidic. Lysosome enzymes work best at an acidic pH of about 5, while the cytosol is close to neutral. A membrane lets the lysosome keep a different pH from the rest of the cell.
CompartmentWhat it holds togetherWhat the membrane does for the cell
LysosomeHydrolytic enzymes in an acidic interiorKeeps them from digesting the rest of the cell
MitochondrionRespiration enzymes, ETC, ATP synthaseFolded inner membrane adds surface; holds an H⁺ gradient
ChloroplastPhotosynthesis enzymes and pigmentsThylakoid stacks add surface; hold an H⁺ gradient
NucleusDNA and the enzymes that read itSeparates gene reading from protein building
ER and GolgiProteins being folded and modifiedKeeps proteins for export on a sealed route out
What each membrane-bound compartment keeps together, and what its membrane does for the cell.
?Wait, how does the SA:V idea connect here?
In Topic 2.2 you saw that a cell needs enough membrane surface for its volume. A big eukaryotic cell can't rely on its outer membrane alone, so its internal membranes add the surface it needs for reactions inside. That's one reason eukaryotic cells can be larger than prokaryotic ones.
Pause and think
Prokaryotes have no lysosomes and no mitochondria. Does that mean they have no internal organization at all?
I thought about it. Show me
No. Prokaryotes usually lack membrane-bound organelles, but they have internal regions with specialized structures and functions: their DNA is concentrated in one region, they have ribosomes, and many make ATP using proteins in their plasma membrane, which works as their energy membrane.
Predict a disruption (Conceptual Analysis style)
A mutation makes lysosome membranes leaky, so their hydrolytic enzymes slowly escape into the cytosol. (a) Describe the normal role of the lysosome membrane. (b) Predict the effect of the mutation on the cell. (c) Justify using compartmentalization.
  1. (a) The membrane keeps the hydrolytic enzymes, and the acidic conditions they need, inside the lysosome, separate from the rest of the cell.
    Why?
    Describe what the compartment keeps apart. That's the setup for the prediction.
  2. (b) The escaped enzymes digest proteins, lipids and other molecules in the cytosol, damaging the cell and possibly killing it.
    Why?
    Hydrolytic enzymes break polymers; they can't tell "food" from "cell".
  3. (c) Compartmentalization minimizes competing interactions. When the barrier fails, digestion mixes with the cell's other processes, and the cell loses molecules it needs.
    Why?
    Name the principle in your justification, then connect it to this case.

Answer: (a) It keeps hydrolytic enzymes separate from the cytosol. (b) The enzymes digest the cell's own molecules, damaging or killing the cell. (c) The compartment that kept competing processes apart has failed.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. What do lysosome enzymes do?
  2. What normally keeps them away from the rest of the cell?
  3. Barrier fails, enzymes mix with the cytosol, the cell's own molecules get digested.
Check yourself
Which is an advantage of compartmentalization in eukaryotic cells?
  1. AIt lets all enzymes mix freely so reactions go faster.
  2. BIt keeps competing reactions apart and adds membrane surface area for reactions.
  3. CIt removes the need for ribosomes.
  4. DIt makes the cell permeable to all ions.
Show the answer

B. Those are the two advantages the course names: minimizing competing interactions and increasing surface area for reactions. Mixing everything is exactly what compartments prevent.

Exam tip from Mrs. O

For a “predict the effect of a disruption” question about an organelle, write two sentences: what the compartment normally keeps apart, and what goes wrong when the two things mix.

  • Internal membranes divide eukaryotic cells into compartments with their own conditions.
  • Compartmentalization minimizes competing interactions (for example, lysosome enzymes kept away from the cytosol).
  • Internal membranes increase surface area where reactions and gradients happen (mitochondrial folds, thylakoids).