2.10 Origins of cell compartmentalizationThe guest that stayed

Prokaryotes generally lack internal membrane-bound organelles, though they do have internal regions with specialized structures and functions. Eukaryotic cells keep internal membranes that split the cell into specialized regions. So where did the organelles come from?
The endosymbiotic theory says that membrane-bound organelles evolved from previously free-living prokaryotic cells. An ancestral host cell engulfed an aerobic prokaryote, one that could use oxygen to make ATP, and did not digest it. The two lived together, the guest providing ATP and the host providing shelter and food, and over many generations the guest became the mitochondrion. Later, in the line that led to algae and plants, a cell with mitochondria engulfed a photosynthetic prokaryote, which became the chloroplast.
?Wait, how do prokaryotes divide?
Here is the evidence. Mitochondria and chloroplasts have a double membrane, which fits the idea of a cell wrapped in the host's membrane as it was engulfed. They have their own DNA, which is circular like a bacterial chromosome. They have their own ribosomes, which resemble bacterial ribosomes more than the ribosomes in the cytosol. And they divide on their own, by a process much like binary fission. A cell can't build a new mitochondrion from scratch: every mitochondrion comes from one that divided.
?Wait, why do ribosomes count as evidence again?
I thought about it. Show me
- Evidence 1: chloroplasts have their own circular DNA, like a bacterial chromosome.
Why?
Free-living prokaryotes carry their genes on circular DNA, so a chloroplast keeping its own circular DNA fits a prokaryotic ancestor. - Evidence 2: chloroplasts have their own ribosomes that resemble prokaryotic ribosomes, and they divide by a process like binary fission.
Why?
The organelle builds some of its own proteins and reproduces itself the way bacteria do. - Optional third: the double membrane, consistent with a prokaryote being engulfed and wrapped in the host's membrane.
Why?
Give exactly the number of pieces the question asks for. Extra ones won't add points, and a wrong one can cost you.
Answer: Circular DNA of their own and bacteria-like ribosomes (or division like binary fission, or a double membrane), each matching a free-living prokaryote.
Stuck? Get a hint
- What do bacteria have that most organelles don't?
- Think DNA, ribosomes, membranes and how it divides.
- Pick two, and say how each matches a free-living prokaryote.
- AMitochondria are found in nearly all eukaryotic cells.
- BMitochondria have their own circular DNA and bacteria-like ribosomes.
- CMitochondria are connected to the ER by vesicles.
- DMitochondria make ATP.
Show the answer
B. Circular DNA and bacteria-like ribosomes link mitochondria to a prokaryotic ancestor. Being common or making ATP doesn't say where they came from, and mitochondria aren't part of the endomembrane shipping line.
Endosymbiosis is a favorite “support a claim with evidence” question. Memorize four pieces of evidence (double membrane, circular DNA, bacteria-like ribosomes, division like binary fission) so you can pick the ones that fit the prompt.
- Mitochondria and chloroplasts evolved from once free-living prokaryotes by endosymbiosis.
- Evidence: double membranes, their own circular DNA, bacteria-like ribosomes, and division like binary fission.
- Prokaryotes usually lack membrane-bound organelles; eukaryotes partition their cells with internal membranes.