AP Physics C: Mechanics · Unit 4 lecture · Part 2 of 11 · 8 min

4.2 Change in momentum: the second law in momentum formForce is the rate of change of momentum

Mr. Thompkins
In Unit 2 you wrote Newton's second law as $\Sigma F = ma$. Newton himself didn't write it that way. He wrote it with momentum, and his version is the more general one. Let's see why, and what it lets you read off a graph.

Here is the second law the way the course states it: the net force on an object equals the rate at which its momentum changes, $\Sigma\vec F = \frac{d\vec p}{dt}$. If the mass doesn't change, $\frac{d\vec p}{dt} = \frac{d(m\vec v)}{dt} = m\frac{d\vec v}{dt} = m\vec a$, and you're back to the Unit 2 law. So nothing you learned is wrong. The momentum form just says it more directly: forces change momentum, and the bigger the net force, the faster the momentum changes.

?Wait, what does a derivative tell me on a graph?
The derivative $\frac{dy}{dx}$ at a point is the slope of the tangent line to the graph there. In kinematics, $v = \frac{dx}{dt}$ is the slope of an x-t graph, and $a = \frac{dv}{dt}$ is the slope of a v-t graph (Unit 1). Same idea here: $\Sigma F = \frac{dp}{dt}$ is the slope of a p-t graph.
012345604812162024t (s)p (kg·m/s)$p = 8t - t^2$tangent: slope 4.0 Nflat: ΣF = 0
The momentum of a 2.0 kg object, $p(t) = 8t - t^2$. The slope at any instant is the net force. At t = 2 s the tangent has slope 4.0 N. At t = 4 s the graph is flat, so the net force is zero for that instant, and after that the momentum falls, so the net force points backward.

Read the graph like a kinematics graph. Where the curve is steep, a big net force is acting. Where it's flat, the net force is zero at that instant, even though the object is still moving (it has momentum $16\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}$ at the top). Where the curve slopes down, the net force is negative: it points opposite to the positive direction and the object is slowing.

Pause and think
In the graph, what is the net force at t = 5 s? Is the object speeding up or slowing down then?
I thought about it. Show me
$\Sigma F = \frac{dp}{dt} = 8 - 2t = -2.0\ \text{N}$ at t = 5 s. The momentum is still positive (15 kg·m/s) but the force is negative, so force and motion point opposite ways and the object is slowing down.
Differentiate a momentum function
A 2.0 kg object moves along x with momentum $p(t) = 8t - t^2$ (kg·m/s, t in seconds). (a) Find the net force at t = 1.0 s. (b) At what time is the net force zero? (c) Find the velocity at t = 3.0 s. (d) Find the acceleration at t = 1.0 s.
  1. (a) Differentiate: $\Sigma F = \frac{dp}{dt} = 8 - 2t$. At $t = 1.0\ \text{s}$: $\Sigma F = 6.0\ \text{N}$ in the $+x$ direction.
    Why?
    On the exam, write the general derivative first, then substitute. A bare "6 N" with no derivative shown may not earn the method point.
  2. (b) Set $8 - 2t = 0$: $t = 4.0\ \text{s}$. That's the flat top of the graph.
  3. (c) $p(3.0) = 8(3.0) - (3.0)^2 = 15\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}$, so $v = \frac{p}{m} = \frac{15}{2.0} = 7.5\ \text{m/s}$.
    Why?
    Velocity comes from the momentum itself, not from its slope. The slope gives force.
  4. (d) $a = \frac{\Sigma F}{m} = \frac{6.0}{2.0} = 3.0\ \text{m/s}^2$ at t = 1.0 s.
    Why?
    Or differentiate $v(t) = \frac{p}{m} = 4t - 0.5t^2$ to get $a = 4 - t$, which is 3.0 at t = 1.0 s. Two routes, same answer: a good self-check.

Answer: (a) 6.0 N in +x (b) t = 4.0 s (c) 7.5 m/s (d) 3.0 m/s².

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Force comes from the slope of p(t). Velocity comes from p itself.
  2. $\frac{d}{dt}(8t - t^2) = 8 - 2t$.
  3. For (c), find $p(3.0)$ and divide by the mass.
?Wait, what counts as the "net" force?
The net force is the vector sum of every force acting on the object: gravity, normal forces, friction, tension, pushes. In the momentum form of the second law it's the net force, not any one force, that sets $\frac{dp}{dt}$.

Beyond the course, as a bonus: the momentum form also handles systems whose mass changes. Sand pours at 2.0 kg/s onto a conveyor belt moving at a steady 1.5 m/s. The belt keeps a constant speed, yet the motor must push, because every second it gives 2.0 kg of new sand a speed of 1.5 m/s. That's a momentum change of $3.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}$ every second, so the extra force is $F = v\frac{dm}{dt} = 3.0\ \text{N}$. You won't be asked this on the exam, but it shows why Newton liked the momentum form.

Check yourself
An object's momentum graph is a straight line that starts at $+12\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}$ at t = 0 and falls to 0 at t = 4.0 s. What is the net force on it during this time?
  1. AZero, because the graph is a straight line
  2. BA constant −3.0 N
  3. CA constant +3.0 N
  4. DA force that grows from 0 to 12 N
Show the answer

B. The slope is $\frac{0 - 12}{4.0} = -3.0\ \text{N}$, and a straight line has a constant slope. Choice A confuses a straight line with a flat line: only a horizontal p-t graph means zero net force. Choice C loses the sign: falling momentum means a backward force.

Exam tip from Mr. T

If the problem gives you $p(t)$ or asks for the force at an instant, differentiate. If it gives you $F(t)$ and asks for a change in motion, integrate (next section). Deciding which one before you start is half the problem.

  • Second law, momentum form: $\Sigma\vec F = \frac{d\vec p}{dt}$. With constant mass it becomes $\Sigma\vec F = m\vec a$.
  • On a p-t graph, the slope is the net force. Flat means zero net force at that instant.
  • Falling momentum means the net force points opposite the motion.