9.1 Electric potential energy: force from energyReading a potential energy graph

Since $\Delta U = -W$, a small step dx along x changes U by $dU = -F_x\,dx$. So the force is the negative slope of the potential energy curve:
$$F_x = -\frac{dU}{dx}$$
?Wait, how did this work for a ball on a hill?
Read a U(x) graph like a landscape. Where the curve slopes down to the right, the force points right ($+x$). Where it slopes up to the right, the force points left. A minimum is a stable equilibrium: nudge the charge and the force pushes it back. A maximum is an unstable equilibrium: nudge it and it runs away.
Now add the total energy E as a horizontal line. Kinetic energy is the gap, $K = E_{tot} - U$, and it can never be negative. So the charge can only be where the curve is below the line. Where the curve meets the line, K = 0: those are turning points, where the charge stops and reverses.
Here's an example. Two fixed $+2.0\ \mu$C charges sit at $x = \pm 0.10$ m, and a $+1.0\ \mu$C bead of mass 2.0 g can slide without friction along the x-axis between them. Its potential energy is the sum of its energies with each fixed charge (the fixed pair's own energy is a constant, so it doesn't change any forces):
$$U(x) = kqQ\left(\frac{1}{0.10 - x} + \frac{1}{0.10 + x}\right)$$
I thought about it. Show me
- (a) Coulomb: the left charge is 0.15 m away and pushes $+x$ with $\frac{(9.0 \times 10^9)(1.0 \times 10^{-6})(2.0 \times 10^{-6})}{(0.15)^2} = 0.80$ N. The right charge is 0.050 m away and pushes $-x$ with $\frac{0.018}{(0.050)^2} = 7.2$ N. Net: 6.4 N in $-x$.
- Slope rule: $F_x = -\frac{dU}{dx} = -kqQ\left[\frac{1}{(0.10 - x)^2} - \frac{1}{(0.10 + x)^2}\right] = -0.018\left[400 - 44.4\right] = -6.4$ N.
Why?
d/dx of 1/(a − x) is +1/(a − x)², and d/dx of 1/(a + x) is −1/(a + x)². Same answer both ways, as it must be. - (b) Energies: $U(0.050) = 0.018\left(\frac{1}{0.050} + \frac{1}{0.15}\right) = 0.48$ J and $U(0) = 0.018\left(\frac{2}{0.10}\right) = 0.36$ J.
- $K = 0.48 - 0.36 = 0.12$ J, so $v = \sqrt{\frac{2(0.12)}{0.0020}} = 11$ m/s.
Answer: (a) 6.4 N toward the center ($-x$). (b) About 11 m/s.
Stuck? Get a hint
- For (a), find each Coulomb force on the bead and add with signs.
- For (b), use energy: K at the center = U at release − U at the center.
- v = √(2K/m), with m in kilograms.
?Wait, what's the difference between stable and unstable equilibrium?
- A+x
- B−x
- CThere is no force there.
- DIt depends on the sign of the charge.
Show the answer
B. $F_x = -dU/dx$, and a positive slope gives a negative force: $-x$, downhill. The sign of the charge is already built into U, so the last choice is a trap.
If a question gives a graph of U against position, it's really asking two things: slope (force) and height (energy). Draw the total-energy line on the graph yourself before answering anything.
- $F_x = -dU/dx$: the force points downhill on the U(x) graph.
- Minimum of U: stable equilibrium. Maximum: unstable.
- $K = E_{tot} - U$. Turning points are where U equals the total energy.
- Use energy for speeds, slope for forces.