AP Physics 1 · Unit 8 lecture · Part 10 of 11 · 6 min

8.3 In the labMeasuring a liquid's density

Mr. Thompkins
Time to be the scientist again. The question: what's the density of an unknown liquid, using a force sensor, a metal cylinder and a graduated cylinder? Archimedes hands you a straight-line graph.

Procedure: hang the metal cylinder from the force sensor and record its weight in air. Lower it into the liquid in steps. At each step, record the sensor reading and the submerged volume, either from the cylinder's marked depth and cross-sectional area or from how much the liquid level rises in the graduated cylinder. The buoyant force at each step is the drop in the reading: $F_b = W_{air} - F_{sensor}$.

?Wait, what makes a good linear graph?
Put the quantity you control (here, submerged volume) on the horizontal axis and the one you measure (buoyant force) on the vertical axis. If theory says $y = (\text{something})\,x$, the slope is that something, and you solve for the unknown from the slope.

Archimedes' principle says $F_b = (\rho_{fluid}g)V_{sub}$. That's a straight line through the origin with slope $\rho_{fluid}g$. So graph $F_b$ against $V_{sub}$, draw the best-fit line, and $\rho_{fluid} = \frac{\text{slope}}{g}$.

?Wait, how do I read a slope from a best-fit line?
Use two points on the line itself, far apart, not data points. Slope is rise over run, and it carries units: here newtons per cubic centimeter until you convert. Show the two points you used in your answer.
$V_{sub}$ (cm³)Sensor in air (N)Sensor in liquid (N)$F_b$ (N)
403.002.520.48
803.002.070.93
1203.001.581.42
1603.001.131.87
2003.000.642.36
One group's data. The sensor reads 3.00 N in air.
0408012016020000.40.81.21.622.42.8$V_{sub}$ (cm³)$F_b$ (N)best fit
Buoyant force against submerged volume: a straight line through the origin, as Archimedes' principle predicts.
Pause and think
Why is a graph of five trials better than calculating the density from just one row of the table?
I thought about it. Show me
Every reading has some random error. The best-fit line averages over all five trials, so one bad reading barely moves the slope. The graph also tests the model: if the points weren't on a line through the origin, you'd know something was wrong with the setup.
Density from the slope
Use the table and graph. (a) What is the slope of the best-fit line, in N/m³? (b) Find the density of the liquid. (c) Would using a heavier metal cylinder of the same size change the graph?
  1. (a) Two points on the best-fit line: $(0, 0)$ and $(220\ \text{cm}^3, 2.59\ \text{N})$. Slope $= \frac{2.59\ \text{N}}{220\ \text{cm}^3} = 0.0118\ \text{N/cm}^3$. Convert: $\times 10^6\ \text{cm}^3/\text{m}^3$ gives $1.18 \times 10^4\ \text{N/m}^3$.
    Why?
    The unit conversion is where most students lose this point. One cm³ is a millionth of a m³, so N per cm³ is a million times bigger as N per m³.
  2. (b) Slope $= \rho g$, so $\rho = \frac{1.18 \times 10^4}{9.8} = 1200\ \text{kg/m}^3$.
  3. (c) No. The buoyant force depends on the displaced volume and the liquid's density, not on the object's mass. Every reading would be higher by the same amount, but the differences, the buoyant forces, would be the same.
    Why?
    A heavier object only shifts the weight in air. This is the same "use the fluid's density, not the object's" idea from Section 4.

Answer: (a) About $1.18 \times 10^4\ \text{N/m}^3$. (b) About 1200 kg/m³. (c) No change in the buoyant force graph.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Read two points on the line, far apart, and compute rise over run.
  2. Convert cm³ to m³ before you divide by g.
  3. Slope = $\rho_{fluid} g$, so divide by 9.8.
Check yourself
A student graphs buoyant force (N) against submerged volume (m³) for an object in an unknown liquid and gets a slope of $7800\ \text{N/m}^3$. What is the liquid's density?
  1. A$7800\ \text{kg/m}^3$
  2. B$800\ \text{kg/m}^3$
  3. C$1250\ \text{kg/m}^3$
  4. D$76{,}000\ \text{kg/m}^3$
Show the answer

B. Slope $= \rho g$, so $\rho = \frac{7800}{9.8} \approx 800\ \text{kg/m}^3$, a typical oil. Choosing 7800 treats the slope as the density itself; 76,000 multiplies by g instead of dividing.

  • Buoyant force from data: weight in air minus the reading in the liquid.
  • Graph $F_b$ against $V_{sub}$: slope $= \rho_{fluid}g$.
  • Convert cm³ to m³ (divide by a million) before using the slope.
  • The object's own mass and density do not affect the buoyant force.