AP Physics 1 · Unit 4 lecture · Part 7 of 11 · 9 min

4.4 Elastic and inelastic collisionsWhere did the energy go?

Mr. Thompkins
Momentum is conserved in every collision of an isolated system. Kinetic energy isn't. So the question that sorts collisions into types is: did the system keep its kinetic energy, or did some turn into something else?

In an elastic collision, the total kinetic energy of the system is the same before and after. Nothing gets dented, warmed or made to ring. Real elastic collisions are rare at everyday sizes, but hard steel balls, billiard balls and carts with magnetic bumpers come close. In an inelastic collision, some kinetic energy turns into other forms: internal energy (the objects get a bit warmer or deform), and sound. When the objects stick together and move as one, the collision is perfectly inelastic, and the system loses the most kinetic energy it can while still conserving momentum.

TypeMomentum of systemKinetic energy of systemWhat you see
ElasticConservedConservedObjects bounce apart, nothing dented or warmed
InelasticConservedSome becomes internal energyObjects bounce apart, with a dent, sound or heat
Perfectly inelasticConservedThe most possible is lostObjects stick and move together
Momentum is conserved in all three types. Only the kinetic energy sorts them.
?Wait, what's internal energy?
Internal energy is the energy stored in the jiggling and stretching of the particles inside an object: its thermal energy and the energy in its bonds. When a car crumples or clay squishes, kinetic energy of the whole object becomes internal energy. Total energy is still conserved. It just changed form.

Let's check the car and truck from Section 5. Before: $K = \tfrac12(1200)(15)^2 + \tfrac12(1800)(10)^2 = 135{,}000 + 90{,}000 = 225{,}000$ J. After, moving together at 12 m/s: $K = \tfrac12(3000)(12)^2 = 216{,}000$ J. The system lost 9,000 J of kinetic energy, which became internal energy in crumpled metal and warmed bumpers, plus some sound. Perfectly inelastic, as expected for objects that stick.

Before (kJ)135$K_{car}$90$K_{truck}$$\Delta E_{int}$After (kJ)216$K_{both}$9$\Delta E_{int}$
Energy bar charts for the rear-end collision, in kJ. Kinetic energy drops from 225 to 216; the missing 9 kJ shows up as internal energy. The total energy is the same.

Why "the most possible"? Even when objects stick, they can't lose all their kinetic energy if the system has momentum, because the center of mass has to keep moving at $v_{cm}$. The leftover kinetic energy is $\tfrac12Mv_{cm}^2$. Only when the total momentum is zero can a sticking collision bring everything to rest.

Pause and think
Look back at the head-on collision: A (3.0 kg) at +4.0 m/s and B (2.0 kg) at −3.0 m/s, ending at −1.6 m/s and +5.4 m/s. Was it elastic? Predict, then check the kinetic energy.
I thought about it. Show me
Before: $\tfrac12(3.0)(4.0)^2 + \tfrac12(2.0)(3.0)^2 = 24 + 9.0 = 33$ J. After: $\tfrac12(3.0)(1.6)^2 + \tfrac12(2.0)(5.4)^2 = 3.84 + 29.16 = 33.0$ J. Same, so it was elastic. Those after-velocities were exactly what an elastic collision produces.
?Wait, why do I square before multiplying in $\tfrac12mv^2$?
Order of operations: exponents come before multiplication. For $\tfrac12(2.0)(5.4)^2$, first $5.4^2 = 29.16$, then $\tfrac12(2.0)(29.16) = 29.16$ J. Squaring also wipes out the sign, which is why kinetic energy is never negative.

Equal masses: the swap

One special case is worth remembering. When two equal masses collide head-on elastically and one starts at rest, they swap velocities: the moving one stops dead and the resting one leaves with the first one's velocity. A cue ball hitting another ball straight on, or the end balls of a Newton's cradle, shows it. Both momentum and kinetic energy come out right only with a full swap.

Classify a collision from data
Cart A (0.50 kg) rolls right at 2.0 m/s into cart B (0.30 kg) at rest. Afterward, A moves right at 0.50 m/s and B moves right at 2.5 m/s. (a) Show that the data are consistent with conservation of momentum. (b) Is the collision elastic? Justify with a calculation.
  1. (a) Right positive. Before: $(0.50)(2.0) + 0 = 1.0$ kg·m/s. After: $(0.50)(0.50) + (0.30)(2.5) = 0.25 + 0.75 = 1.0$ kg·m/s. Equal, so momentum is conserved.
    Why?
    "Show that" means write both totals with numbers and compare them.
  2. (b) Kinetic energy before: $\tfrac12(0.50)(2.0)^2 = 1.0$ J.
  3. Kinetic energy after: $\tfrac12(0.50)(0.50)^2 + \tfrac12(0.30)(2.5)^2 = 0.0625 + 0.9375 = 1.0$ J.
    Why?
    Keep extra digits in the middle of the calculation. Rounding 0.0625 to 0.06 makes the energies look unequal.
  4. Claim: the collision is elastic, because the total kinetic energy of the system is the same before and after (1.0 J).
    Why?
    A claim plus a comparison of numbers is a complete justification. "It bounced, so it's elastic" is not: inelastic collisions bounce too.

Answer: (a) 1.0 kg·m/s before and after. (b) Elastic: the system's kinetic energy is 1.0 J both before and after.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Momentum: add (mass × signed velocity) for both carts, before and after.
  2. Kinetic energy: $\tfrac12 mv^2$ for each cart, then add.
  3. If the kinetic energy totals match, it's elastic. If the "after" total is smaller, it's inelastic.

A handy shortcut, beyond the course, as a bonus: in an elastic head-on collision, the speed at which the two objects approach each other equals the speed at which they separate. In the cart example, they approached at 2.0 m/s and separated at $2.5 - 0.50 = 2.0$ m/s. In a perfectly inelastic collision the separation speed is zero.

Check yourself
In a collision of an isolated two-object system, a student's data show the total kinetic energy increased by 5 J and nothing inside the objects released energy. What should the student conclude?
  1. AThe collision was super-elastic, which is common.
  2. BThe collision was perfectly inelastic.
  3. CThere is an error in the data, because the system's kinetic energy can't increase without an energy source.
  4. DMomentum was not conserved.
Show the answer

C. Kinetic energy can stay the same (elastic) or decrease (inelastic), but it can only increase if stored energy, like a compressed spring or a chemical reaction, is released. Without that, the data are wrong. Momentum is a separate question: the data could still conserve it.

Check yourself
Which collision loses the greatest fraction of the system's kinetic energy?
  1. AA moving cart hits an identical cart at rest and they bounce apart elastically.
  2. BA moving cart hits an identical cart at rest and they stick together.
  3. CTwo identical carts moving toward each other at equal speeds stick together.
  4. DA moving cart hits a much heavier cart at rest and bounces back elastically.
Show the answer

C. Two identical carts at equal and opposite speeds have zero total momentum, so after sticking $v' = 0$ and all the kinetic energy (100%) is lost. Sticking with one cart at rest keeps half, since $v_{cm}$ isn't zero. The elastic choices lose nothing.

Exam tip from Mr. T

If an FRQ asks "elastic or inelastic?", calculate the system's kinetic energy before and after, compare them in a sentence, and state the type. The words "it bounced" or "they stuck" alone are not evidence, except that sticking always means perfectly inelastic.

  • Every collision of an isolated system conserves momentum. Only elastic collisions also conserve kinetic energy.
  • Inelastic: some kinetic energy becomes internal energy and sound. Perfectly inelastic: they stick, and the most kinetic energy possible is lost.
  • What's left after sticking is $\tfrac12Mv_{cm}^2$; it's zero only if the total momentum is zero.
  • Equal masses, elastic, one at rest: they swap velocities.