4.3 Systems, internal and external forcesDraw the dashed line first

?Wait, what's a system again?
Think about two carts colliding. During the collision, cart B pushes on cart A, and by Newton's third law A pushes on B with the same size force in the opposite direction, for exactly the same time. So the impulses are equal and opposite: $J_{B\,on\,A} = -J_{A\,on\,B}$. Whatever momentum A loses, B gains. That is a momentum transfer, and it can only happen through forces between the objects.
Now draw a dashed line around both carts and call them one system. The collision forces are both inside the line, so for the system as a whole they cancel. Only external forces can change a system's total momentum: $\Sigma F_{ext}\Delta t = \Delta p_{sys}$. If the net external force is zero, the total momentum of the system stays exactly the same. That's the law of conservation of linear momentum, and it holds whether the carts bounce, stick, crumple or explode.
In real life the net external force is rarely exactly zero. A track has a little friction. Air pushes back. But during a collision that lasts a few hundredths of a second, the collision forces are huge and the outside forces are small, so the outside impulse $F\Delta t$ is tiny. That's why we can say momentum is conserved "just before to just after" a collision, even when friction slows things down later.
?Wait, what's an isolated system?
The same event, two systems
Here's where choosing matters. Drop a ball. If the system is just the ball, Earth's gravity is an external force, so the ball's momentum grows as it falls. Not conserved. If the system is the ball and the Earth, gravity is an internal pair: the ball pulls up on the Earth as hard as the Earth pulls down on the ball. The total is conserved. The Earth gains exactly as much upward momentum as the ball gains downward, but with a mass of about $6\times10^{24}$ kg, its velocity change is far too small to notice.
I thought about it. Show me
- Right is positive. (a) Impulse on A: $J_A = F\Delta t = (-25)(0.040) = -1.0$ N·s, so $\Delta p_A = -1.0$ kg·m/s.
Why?
The force on A points left, so its impulse is negative. - A's new momentum: $p_A' = (0.50)(2.0) + (-1.0) = 0$. So A stops: $v_A' = 0$.
- (b) By the third law, A pushes B with 25 N to the right for the same 0.040 s, so $J_B = +1.0$ N·s and $v_B' = 1.0 / 1.0 = 1.0$ m/s to the right.
Why?
Equal and opposite forces for equal times give equal and opposite impulses. That's the transfer. - (c) $\Delta p_{sys} = \Delta p_A + \Delta p_B = -1.0 + 1.0 = 0$. The system's momentum is 1.0 kg·m/s before and after.
Why?
The collision forces are internal, so the system's momentum doesn't change.
Answer: (a) −1.0 kg·m/s; A stops. (b) 1.0 m/s to the right. (c) Zero: the system keeps 1.0 kg·m/s.
Stuck? Get a hint
- Impulse on A = force × time, and the force points left.
- Add that impulse to A's starting momentum of +1.0 kg·m/s.
- B gets the opposite impulse, +1.0 N·s, from Newton's third law.
- AThe skateboarder alone
- BThe friend alone
- CThe skateboarder and the friend, if friction from the ground on them is negligible
- DNo system, because a push is a force
Show the answer
C. The push is internal to the system "skateboarder + friend", so if the ground's horizontal forces are negligible, that system's momentum is constant: one gains forward momentum and the other gains backward momentum. For either person alone, the push is external, so that person's momentum changes. A force inside the system doesn't break conservation.

In a justification, the phrase that earns the point is close to this: "The net external force on the system of A and B is zero (or negligible during the collision), so the total momentum of the system is conserved." Name the system and say why. "Momentum is always conserved" earns nothing.
- Choose the system first. Forces between its parts are internal; forces from outside are external.
- Internal forces come in third-law pairs with equal and opposite impulses, so they move momentum around inside the system without changing the total.
- Only a net external impulse changes a system's momentum: $\Sigma F_{ext}\Delta t = \Delta p_{sys}$.
- During a brief collision, small external forces like friction give negligible impulse, so momentum is conserved from just before to just after.