AP Physics 1 · Unit 1 lecture · Part 7 of 10 · 8 min

1.4 Reference frames and relative motionIt depends who is watching

Mr. Thompkins
You're sitting still on a train. Are you moving? Your seatmate says no. Someone on the platform says you just zoomed by at 30 m/s. You're both right. Velocity always depends on who's measuring it.

A reference frame is the point of view you measure from: a coordinate system attached to some observer. Position, displacement, velocity and acceleration all depend on the frame. The ground is the frame we use most, but the AP exam often asks you to switch: a person on a walkway, a boat on a river, a plane in the wind.

The rule for switching frames is vector addition. If $\vec v_{AB}$ is the velocity of A relative to B, and $\vec v_{BC}$ is the velocity of B relative to C, then the velocity of A relative to C is $\vec v_{AC} = \vec v_{AB} + \vec v_{BC}$. Read the subscripts like dominoes: the inner letters match and cancel, AB + BC gives AC.

?Wait, how do I add vectors in one dimension?
Just add them with their signs. +1.5 m/s plus +1.2 m/s is +2.7 m/s. +1.5 m/s plus −1.2 m/s is +0.3 m/s. The sign carries the direction, so the arithmetic handles everything.
walking forwardwalkway 1.5you, rel. walkway 1.2you, rel. ground 2.7 m/swalking backwardwalkway 1.5you, rel. walkway −1.2you, rel. ground +0.3 m/s
An airport walkway moves at 1.5 m/s. Walking forward on it at 1.2 m/s, you move at 2.7 m/s relative to the ground. Walking backward at 1.2 m/s, you still drift forward at 0.3 m/s.
Pause and think
Two cars drive toward each other, each at 25 m/s relative to the ground. How fast is one car moving relative to the other?
I thought about it. Show me
50 m/s. Take A's direction as positive. Car A moves at $v_{AG} = +25$ m/s relative to the ground. Car B moves at $-25$ m/s relative to the ground, so to someone riding in B the ground slides by at $v_{GB} = +25$ m/s. Then $v_{AB} = v_{AG} + v_{GB} = +50$ m/s. Head-on speeds add.
?Wait, why is $v_{GB} = -v_{BG}$?
If B moves at −25 m/s relative to the ground, then to someone riding in B, the ground slides by at +25 m/s. Swapping the order of the subscripts flips the sign: $\vec v_{GB} = -\vec v_{BG}$.

The same rule works in two dimensions, where you add the vectors head to tail. A plane points due north and flies at 80 m/s relative to the air. A wind blows the air east at 20 m/s relative to the ground. Relative to the ground, the plane moves at the sum of those two vectors, and since they're perpendicular, the Pythagorean theorem gives its size.

$v_{PA}$ = 80 N$v_{AG}$ = 20 E$v_{PG}$ = 82.514.0°NEP: plane, A: air, G: ground
The plane heads north at 80 m/s relative to the air (orange), while the air moves east at 20 m/s (blue). The plane's velocity relative to the ground is the teal sum: 82.5 m/s, 14.0° east of north.
A plane in a crosswind
A plane heads due north at 80 m/s relative to the air. The wind blows due east at 20 m/s. Find the plane's speed and direction relative to the ground.
  1. Write the rule with subscripts: $\vec v_{PG} = \vec v_{PA} + \vec v_{AG}$. Here $\vec v_{PA}$ = 80 m/s north and $\vec v_{AG}$ = 20 m/s east.
    Why?
    P is the plane, A is the air, G is the ground. The inner letters A and A match, so the sum is plane relative to ground.
  2. The two vectors are perpendicular, so the size is $\sqrt{80^2 + 20^2} = \sqrt{6800} = 82.5$ m/s.
    Why?
    Head to tail they form a right triangle, and the sum is the hypotenuse.
  3. Direction: $\tan\theta = \frac{20}{80}$, so $\theta = \tan^{-1}(0.25) = 14.0°$ east of north.
    Why?
    Measure the angle from the direction the plane points (north), toward the direction the wind pushes it (east).

Answer: 82.5 m/s, 14.0° east of north.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Draw the 80 m/s arrow north, then put the tail of the 20 m/s east arrow at its tip.
  2. The sum goes from the first tail to the last tip. It is the hypotenuse of a right triangle.
  3. Size $\sqrt{80^2 + 20^2}$; angle $\tan^{-1}(20/80)$ from north.

One more idea the course expects. A frame moving at constant velocity is called an inertial frame, and the laws of motion look exactly the same in every inertial frame. Drop your keys on a smooth train moving at constant velocity and they fall straight down at your feet, just as on the platform. Someone on the platform sees the keys trace a curve, because they also share the train's forward velocity. Different frames, different paths, same physics. All observers in inertial frames also measure the same acceleration for the keys: $g$ downward.

Check yourself
A boat moves at 4.0 m/s relative to the water, heading straight downstream. The river flows at 1.5 m/s relative to the shore. What is the boat's speed relative to the shore?
  1. A1.5 m/s
  2. B2.5 m/s
  3. C4.0 m/s
  4. D5.5 m/s
Show the answer

D. Both velocities point downstream, so they add: $\vec v_{BS} = \vec v_{BW} + \vec v_{WS} = 4.0 + 1.5 = 5.5$ m/s. Heading upstream would give 2.5 m/s, the trap in choice B.

Exam tip from Mr. T

Write the subscript equation, $\vec v_{AC} = \vec v_{AB} + \vec v_{BC}$, before plugging anything in. It turns a confusing word problem into one line, and it shows the grader your reasoning.

  • Velocity depends on the reference frame. Always say "relative to what".
  • $\vec v_{AC} = \vec v_{AB} + \vec v_{BC}$. Swapping subscripts flips the sign: $\vec v_{BA} = -\vec v_{AB}$.
  • Same direction: velocities add. Opposite: they subtract. Perpendicular: Pythagorean theorem for the size, inverse tangent for the angle.
  • Observers in inertial (constant-velocity) frames see different velocities but the same acceleration and the same laws of motion.