5.1 Beneficial and harmful effectsEvery innovation cuts both ways

People create computing innovations, and then the way people do things changes to include them. We navigate with apps instead of paper maps, pay with phones, and look up a fact instead of asking someone. A computing innovation is anything that includes a program as an integral part of how it works: an app, a smart device, a social network, even a car with self-parking.
?Wait, what counts as a computing innovation?
Here's the key idea of the topic: one innovation can be beneficial and harmful at the same time. A single effect can be seen as helpful by some people and harmful by others, or even as both by the same person. A work phone that gets email everywhere is convenient, and it also means work never quite ends.
| Innovation | A beneficial effect | A harmful effect |
|---|---|---|
| Ride-hailing apps | Rides in places with few taxis; flexible work for drivers | Drivers can earn little after costs; more traffic downtown |
| Video doorbells | Owners see who is at the door; fewer stolen packages | Neighbors and passersby are recorded without agreeing |
| Music and video recommendations | You find artists you would never have heard of | You can get stuck seeing only more of the same |
| Instant translation apps | Travelers, patients and new arrivals can be understood | Mistranslations can matter in a hospital or a courtroom |
| Phone payments | Fast, no cash to carry | People without phones or bank accounts are left out |
The best habit for this topic is to ask "who?" before "good or bad?". List every group the innovation touches: the people who use it, the people who make money from it, and the people who never chose it but are affected anyway.
?Wait, what's a stakeholder?
I thought about it. Show me
- (a) Beneficial: lights only brighten when needed, which saves energy, and the counts help put buses where people actually walk.
Why?
Tie the benefit to what the innovation actually does. "It's helpful" earns nothing. - (b) Harmful: the sensors record people's movements. If the data is detailed enough, it could reveal where specific people go and when.
- (c) Everyone who walks down the street is counted, and none of them agreed to it.
- (d) For example: what exactly is recorded, how long is it kept, and could someone combine it with other data to identify people?
Why?
The CED expects programmers to consider the unintended ways an innovation can be used, while knowing they cannot foresee every one.
Answer: (a) Energy savings and better bus planning. (b) Movement data could reveal individuals' routines. (c) Pedestrians, who never chose it. (d) What is recorded, for how long, and could it identify people?
Stuck? Get a hint
- What does the light do, and what does it record?
- Who walks under it, and did they agree to anything?
- Think about what the movement data could reveal if it were detailed or combined with other data.
- AA bug in the app, because the app chose a bad route
- BA harmful effect of the innovation, though the app works as designed
- CAn example of the digital divide
- DAn effect that is beneficial for everyone involved
Show the answer
B. The app does exactly what it was designed to do: it saves drivers time. The heavy traffic is a harmful effect on the people near that street. The top trap is calling it a bug. Effects are about impact, not about whether the code is correct.
- People create innovations, and the way people do things changes to include them.
- One innovation can be beneficial and harmful. One effect can be both, depending on who you ask.
- List every group touched, including people who never chose the innovation.