AP Biology · Unit 8 lecture · Part 9 of 12 · 6 min

8.6 BiodiversityWhy diverse ecosystems hold up

Mrs. Otero
A cornfield of one variety and a prairie with 200 species both get hit by the same drought and the same new pest. Which one is still green next year?

Natural and artificial ecosystems with fewer component parts, and with little diversity among the parts, are often less resilient to changes in the environment. In a diverse ecosystem, if one species is harmed, others with similar roles can take over, and some species are likely to tolerate the new conditions. A monoculture has no backup.

?Wait, how is this different from Topic 7.11?
Topic 7.11 was genetic diversity within one population. Topic 8.6 is diversity of species and parts across a whole ecosystem. The logic is the same: more variety, more ways to survive a change.

Keystone species, producers, and essential abiotic and biotic factors help maintain an ecosystem's diversity. A keystone species has an effect that is disproportionate to its abundance: there may be few of them, but when they are removed, the ecosystem often collapses. In a classic experiment in the 1960s, removing a predatory sea star from tide pools let mussels crowd out other species, and the number of species fell by about half.

01234560369121518years after startspecies in tide poolssea stars leftsea stars removed
Illustrative results of a keystone removal experiment in tide pools.
Analyze a removal experiment
Use the graph. (a) Identify the control and the experimental group. (b) Describe the result after 6 years. (c) Explain why removing a predator lowered diversity.
  1. (a) Control: pools where sea stars were left. Experimental: pools where they were removed.
    Why?
    The only planned difference is the sea stars.
  2. (b) Control pools stayed near 14 to 15 species. Removal pools fell from 15 to 8 species, about a 47% drop.
    Why?
    (15 − 8) ÷ 15 × 100 ≈ 47%.
  3. (c) The sea star ate the dominant competitor (mussels). Without it, mussels took over the rock space and outcompeted other species, so fewer could live there.
    Why?
    A keystone predator keeps one competitor from monopolizing a resource.

Answer: (a) Sea stars present (control) versus removed. (b) 15 to 8 species, about 47% fewer; control steady. (c) The predator kept a dominant competitor in check.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Which pools had nothing changed?
  2. Read year 0 and year 6 for each curve.
  3. Who did the sea star eat, and what did that prey do without it?
Pause and think
Is the most abundant species in an ecosystem always the keystone species?
I thought about it. Show me
No. A keystone species' effect is out of proportion to its numbers; it can be rare, like a top predator. A very abundant species with a big effect, like the dominant tree of a forest, is usually called a foundation species instead (beyond the course).
Check yourself
Which ecosystem is most likely to recover from a new plant disease?
  1. AA tree plantation of one species
  2. BA lawn of one grass variety
  3. CA mixed forest with many tree species
  4. DA cornfield of one hybrid
Show the answer

C. More component parts and more diversity mean more resilience. The other three are monocultures.

  • Ecosystems with fewer parts and little diversity are less resilient.
  • Keystone species, producers and essential abiotic and biotic factors maintain diversity.
  • A keystone species' effect is out of proportion to its abundance; removing it can collapse the ecosystem.