AP Biology · Unit 8 lecture · Part 6 of 12 · 9 min

8.4 Effect of density on populationsLimits, carrying capacity and the S-curve

Mrs. Otero
A few deer released on an island with no predators: at first they boom. Then food runs short, and the boom slows to a crawl. Where does it stop, and why?

Carrying capacity, K, is the sustainable abundance of a species that the ecosystem's total available resources can support. As a population grows, limits kick in. Density-dependent factors hit harder as the population gets more crowded: competition for food and space, disease spreading between neighbors, predators focusing on abundant prey, and buildup of wastes. Density-independent factors affect a population no matter how crowded it is: a freeze, a fire, a flood, a hurricane.

Density-dependent

  • Effect grows with crowding
  • Competition, disease, predation, waste buildup
  • Pushes the population toward K

Density-independent

  • Effect is the same at any density
  • Weather, fire, floods, volcanoes
  • Can crash a population at any size

As these limits are imposed, a logistic growth model typically results: $\frac{dN}{dt} = r_{max} N \left(\frac{K - N}{K}\right)$. The fraction $\frac{K - N}{K}$ is the share of 'room' left. When N is small, it is close to 1 and growth looks exponential. At N = K/2, the product is largest, so growth is fastest. As N nears K, the fraction nears 0 and growth stops. The graph is S-shaped.

?Wait, does growth stopping mean no babies?
No. At K, births still happen; they're just balanced by deaths, so B − D = 0. Real populations also bounce around K as conditions change.
048121620240100200300400500600700800900time (years)population size NK = 800S-shapedfastest at K/2
Logistic growth with K = 800 and $r_{max}$ = 0.5 per year, starting at 20. The curve is steepest when N = 400 (K/2) and levels off at K.
0100200300400500600700800020406080100120population size NdN/dt (per year)100 at N = 400zero at K
The same model drawn as growth rate against population size. dN/dt peaks at 100 per year when N = 400 and falls to zero at K.
Calculate logistic growth
A population has $r_{max}$ = 0.5 per year and K = 800. Calculate dN/dt when (a) N = 200, (b) N = 600, (c) N = 900. (d) Explain the sign in (c).
  1. (a) 0.5 × 200 × (800 − 200)/800 = 0.5 × 200 × 0.75 = 75 per year.
    Why?
    Plug in K − N, not N − K.
  2. (b) 0.5 × 600 × (200/800) = 0.5 × 600 × 0.25 = 75 per year.
    Why?
    Same rate as at 200: the curve is symmetric around K/2 = 400.
  3. (c) 0.5 × 900 × (−100/800) = −56.25 per year.
    Why?
    N is above K, so K − N is negative.
  4. (d) Above carrying capacity, resources can't support everyone, so deaths outnumber births and the population shrinks back toward K.

Answer: (a) 75 (b) 75 (c) −56.25 per year (d) Above K, the population declines toward K.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Write the equation with K − N in the parentheses.
  2. (K − N)/K is 0.75 at N = 200 and 0.25 at N = 600.
  3. What does a negative growth rate mean?

Are two means really different? Error bars

Density experiments produce means, and the course expects you to judge whether two means are really different. The standard error of the mean, $SE = \frac{s}{\sqrt{n}}$, measures how precisely a sample mean estimates the true mean. A bar of ±2 SE around a mean is roughly a 95% confidence interval. If the ±2 SE bars of two groups don't overlap, the difference is likely statistically significant. If they overlap, you can't conclude that the means differ.

Beetles per jarMean eggsSEMean ± 2 SE
1042.00.6340.7 to 43.3
2039.50.6938.1 to 40.9
4031.00.8229.4 to 32.6
Eggs laid per female flour beetle at three densities, 10 females measured per group (illustrative).
?Wait, what's standard deviation again?
It measures how spread out the individual values are around the mean (formula sheet). The standard error divides it by √n, so bigger samples give smaller error bars.
Read error bars
Use the table and graph. (a) Compare 10 and 40 beetles per jar. (b) Compare 10 and 20. (c) Which kind of factor do the results suggest, and why?
010203040502530354045beetles per jareggs per female42.039.531.0
  1. (a) 10 per jar: 40.7 to 43.3. 40 per jar: 29.4 to 32.6. The bars don't overlap, so the difference is likely significant: females lay fewer eggs at high density.
    Why?
    Non-overlapping ±2 SE bars: likely a real difference.
  2. (b) 10 per jar: 40.7 to 43.3. 20 per jar: 38.1 to 40.9. They overlap (40.7 to 40.9), so you can't conclude that egg laying differs.
    Why?
    Overlap doesn't prove the means are equal; it means the data can't show a difference.
  3. (c) A density-dependent factor: egg laying drops as crowding increases, likely from competition for food and space.
    Why?
    The effect grows with density.

Answer: (a) Significant drop at 40 per jar. (b) Can't conclude a difference. (c) Density-dependent (competition).

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Write each group's ±2 SE range.
  2. Do the ranges share any values?
  3. Does the effect get stronger with crowding?
Pause and think
A hurricane kills 40% of a lizard population on an island, whether the lizards were crowded or sparse. Which kind of factor is it, and would the population still tend back toward K afterward?
I thought about it. Show me
Density-independent: the share killed doesn't depend on crowding. Afterward, with fewer lizards and the same resources, density-dependent limits ease, so the population can grow back toward K.
Check yourself
A population is growing logistically with K = 1,000. At which size is it growing fastest?
  1. A100
  2. B500
  3. C900
  4. D1,000
Show the answer

B. Logistic growth is fastest at K/2 = 500, where $r_{max}$ N (K − N)/K is largest. At 1,000 growth is zero, not maximal: the common trap.

  • Carrying capacity K: the population the ecosystem's resources can sustain.
  • Density-dependent factors (competition, disease, predation, waste) grow with crowding; density-independent factors (weather, fire) don't.
  • Logistic: $\frac{dN}{dt} = r_{max} N \left(\frac{K - N}{K}\right)$. Fastest at K/2, zero at K, negative above K.
  • ±2 SE bars: no overlap, likely significant; overlap, can't conclude a difference.