AP Biology · Unit 7 lecture · Part 7 of 12 · 7 min

7.6 Evidence of evolutionReading the clues

Mrs. Otero
Evolution is one of the best-supported ideas in science, not because of one famous discovery, but because clues from rocks, bones and molecules all point the same way. Let's read each kind.

Evolution is supported by evidence from many disciplines: geographical, geological, physical, biochemical and mathematical data, from both living (extant) and extinct organisms. The course groups it into three families: fossils, morphological homologies, and DNA and protein sequences.

Fossils and how they're dated

Fossils show that life has changed over time: older rocks hold organisms unlike any alive today. The course names three ways to date them. First, the age of the rocks they're found in: sedimentary rock forms in layers, newer on top, so deeper layers are usually older. Second, the decay rate of radioactive isotopes, including carbon-14, which gives ages in years. Third, geographical data, such as where a fossil is found and how continents were arranged then.

CBAash: 50 myaash: 72 myayoungestoldestdeeper layers are older
Rock layers with two volcanic ash beds dated by radioactive decay (mya = million years ago). Fossil B lies between them, so it is 50 to 72 million years old.
?Wait, what's a half-life?
The time for half the atoms of a radioactive isotope in a sample to decay. After one half-life 50% is left, after two 25%, after three 12.5%: halve each time.

A living organism takes in carbon, so its carbon-14 level matches its surroundings. When it dies, intake stops and its carbon-14 decays with a half-life of 5,730 years. Carbon-14 works only up to about 50,000 years; after that too little is left. Older fossils are dated using longer-lived isotopes in the volcanic layers around them.

0510152025300255075100time since death (thousands of years)carbon-14 left (%)1 half-life: 50%2: 25%3: 12.5%
Carbon-14 left in a dead organism, computed from a half-life of 5,730 years.
Date a fossil
A bone has 12.5% of the carbon-14 found in living animals. (a) How old is it? (b) A second bone has 25% left. Which is older, and by how much? (c) Could carbon-14 date fossil A in the rock diagram?
  1. (a) 100 → 50 → 25 → 12.5 is 3 half-lives, so 3 × 5,730 = 17,190 years.
    Why?
    Count the halvings, then multiply by the half-life.
  2. (b) 25% is 2 half-lives, 11,460 years. The first bone is older by 5,730 years.
    Why?
    Less carbon-14 left, more time passed.
  3. (c) No. Fossil A is over 72 million years old, more than 12,000 half-lives, so no carbon-14 is left. Date the rock layers instead.

Answer: (a) 17,190 years. (b) The first, by 5,730 years. (c) No; date the surrounding rock.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. How many halvings take 100% to 12.5%?
  2. Multiply by 5,730.
  3. Carbon-14 works up to about 50,000 years.

Homologies and molecules

Morphological homologies are structures that share the same underlying anatomy because they were inherited from a common ancestor, even if they now do different jobs. A human arm, a bat's wing, a whale's flipper and a cat's leg contain the same bones in the same arrangement. Vestigial structures are reduced structures with little or no function that were functional in ancestors: the small pelvic bones of whales, the hind-limb spurs of pythons, the human tailbone.

Homologous structures

  • Same underlying anatomy
  • Inherited from a common ancestor
  • Can do different jobs
  • Evidence of common ancestry

Analogous structures

  • Similar job, different anatomy
  • Evolved independently (convergent evolution)
  • Bird wing and insect wing
  • Not evidence of close ancestry
?Wait, how does a DNA sequence become a protein sequence?
From Unit 6: DNA is transcribed into mRNA, and each three-base codon is translated into one amino acid. So DNA changes can show up as amino acid changes, and proteins can be compared one amino acid at a time.

Comparing DNA nucleotide sequences and protein amino acid sequences is powerful evidence for common ancestry. After two lineages split, each collects its own mutations, so the longer ago they split, the more their sequences differ. And every organism has DNA, even ones that look nothing alike.

SpeciesAmino acid differences from humans
Gorilla1
Monkey8
Mouse27
Chicken45
Frog67
Amino acid differences from humans in one 146-amino-acid protein (illustrative values).
Pause and think
Which species in the table shares the most recent common ancestor with humans? Is the frog 'less evolved'?
I thought about it. Show me
The gorilla (1 difference). And no: the frog's lineage has evolved for exactly as long as ours since the split. The frog is more distantly related, not more primitive.
Check yourself
Which observation is the strongest evidence that whales and land mammals share a common ancestor?
  1. AWhales and fish both have streamlined bodies.
  2. BWhales have small pelvic bones and limb bones arranged like other mammals'.
  3. CWhales and sharks both live in the ocean.
  4. DWhales are larger than most land mammals.
Show the answer

B. Vestigial pelvic bones and homologous limb bones are shared anatomy from an ancestor. The streamlined body is the trap: it's analogous, the result of similar pressures in water.

  • Evidence comes from geographical, geological, physical, biochemical and mathematical data.
  • Fossils are dated by rock layers, radioactive isotopes (carbon-14 up to ~50,000 years) and geographical data.
  • Homologies, including vestigial structures, show common ancestry. Analogous structures don't.
  • Fewer DNA or protein differences means a more recent common ancestor.